I am from scotland and have made a starteling descovery. I seem to be the only scotish Objectivist.
Will someone please prove me wrong. :unsure:
I am from scotland and have made a starteling descovery. I seem to be the only scotish Objectivist.
Will someone please prove me wrong. :unsure:
No true Scotsman would fail to capitalize Scotland or misspell Scottish. Youāre cover is blown, Joshua. Youād have us think you hail from the land of the heroic Calcagus, when Epimenides is your true countryman, deny it all you like.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eKgPY1adc0A
In any event, Nicholas Dykes is from Herefordshire, thatās pretty close to Scotland. Also, John Galt was Scottish, though I suppose that doesnāt count for much.
Ninth Doctor, In response to the grammer/spelling mistakes, I have a very small keyboard. sue me.
Nicholas Dykes is, as you say, from Herefordshire, AKA England. Us Scots historicaly donāt like the English. In fact, we are having a referendum on gaining independance from the UK in 2014.
As for John Galt being Scottish, This is intresting, but I was more looking for someone to discuss Scottish matters with (like the independance referendum.)
I donāt remember anyone else on the board from Scotland.
In fact, we are having a referendum on gaining independance from the UK in 2014.
Is a 50%+ majority enough for this to pass? Iāve read that the majority of folk in Scotland donāt favor independence, at least not enough to want to rock the boat.
To me, it does not make sense for areas within medium-sized western countries to seek independence unless it would result in a significantly increased support for individual rights. So, if someone wants to split in order to keep more North Sea oil money, thatās a pretty bogus reason. If someone wants to split because of some type of ethnic pride, thatās just as bogus. If an area is particularly productive and ā as with typical progressive-taxation states ā they are subsidizing other areas, then people who are really interested in individual rights would be campaigning to reduce those tax burdens, not just to bring the spending āhomeā.
Do you support independence? Why, or why not?
David Hume and Adam Smith were at U. Edinburgh. That would make it Objectivism-unfriendly territory.
The pro/anti independance split as prety much 50/50. I personaly support independance 100%. Westminister, who have most of the control in the uk, are almost solely concerned with Engalnd, with very little wory for Scotland. Independance would let us decide our own course and give us fair representation in the EU, if we decide to join. The argument against is almost compleatly economical, but there is no conclusive proof that we would be worse off. We have proven that we can handle power (we have a partialy devolved parlement with lmited decision making abilities) so now it is time for us to walk on our own two feet!
By the way, Reidy, Just having historical figures in our past that donāt support Objectivism doesnāt mean that Scots nowadays wont support it.
Westminister, who have most of the control in the uk, are almost solely concerned with Engalnd, with very little wory for Scotland. Independance would let us decide our own course and give us fair representation in the EU, if we decide to join.
Fair enough. Can you put this in terms of individual rights though? I curious what concrete violations of individual rights take place today that would be protected with self-rule. Are their some type of property rights, freedoms of speech, or some such aspects that would be enhanced by self-rule.
I know little of Scotland, but I come from a country that was once ruled by Britain. Around WW-1, the whole world began to talk of national self-determination, and colonialism lost the moral high-ground. The good of self-rule and self-determination seem obvious enough, but the truth is that democracy and ways in which we vote for leaders is a secondary factor. The primary factor is: how well does a government protect individual rights. We see that most British third-world colonies ended up voting themselves some form of socialism. In fact, these were the best cases; in others, dictators soon took over.
Obviously Scotland is not a third-world country. In intellectual development of ideas like freedom and capitalism, it is like Britain. In fact, some people point to Hume and Smith to show that the Scottish enlightenment actually led the way. Still, my point is that self-rule, as such, is not good unless it will deliver some better protection of individual rights.
Hereās a question, what if people living in a state in the U.S. wanted to form a country of their own? How would we judge if this is a good thing or a bad thing? The starting point would be to ask if this new entity will protect individual rights any better. So, for instance, if they wan ted to break away in order to become a little more Christian fundamentalist or a little more socialist, those would be illegitimate ā even if huge majorities within that state supported the move. It is not legitimate for a democracy to infringe on the rights of its citizens.
What if the Scottish Highlanders said that they wanted to form a country of their own because Edinburgh was mostly concerned with the Lowlands. Would you support a move like that? Why or why not?
Our indevidual rights will be better protected because we will finaly get some representation. In the EU, there are more MEPs for london alone than the whole of Scotland. We are little more than an after thought for Westminister, and with independance, we will be able to represent ourselves fairly.
Scotland owns the majority of the north sea oil, but get very little if any benefit from them. Any money goes to Westminister, And we no longer want to be ruled by looters.
As for the highlands claiming independance, there wouldnāt be enough people there. the highlands are mostly uninhabited and uninhabitable. it would be like the mohave desert claiming independance (sans Las Vagas). Plus, we do represent the highlands. They wanted wolves re-intreduced to the highlands, so we re-intreduced them.
Ninth Doctor, In response to the grammer/spelling mistakes, I have a very small keyboard. sue me.
Donāt worry, I was just messing with you. With the US elections coming up, Epimenides is often in my thoughts.
David Hume and Adam Smith were at U. Edinburgh. That would make it Objectivism-unfriendly territory.
Why do you think Adam Smith is Objectivism-unfriendly? As Enlightenment philosophers go, heās about as good as it gets.
David Hume and Adam Smith were at U. Edinburgh. That would make it Objectivism-unfriendly territory.
Smith is cited as the father of modern economics and capitalism-wikipedia.
Seems like he would be rather pro Objectivist :rolleyes: .
Rand and Peikoff considered Smithās ethical theory inimical (though I donāt know much about it); he was in the last edition of the āHorror Fileā in The Objectivist. His better-known economics expressly refused to mount an ethical defense of capitalism. The most famous quote from him is something to the effect that free markets are workable but, unfortunately, immoral - not throught the benevolence of the butched and baker⦠or something to that effect.
Hume also had some good ideas about economics.
In any case, Ayn Rand was born in russia, but that doesnāt mean that they are capitalist or objectivism friendly. You canāt judge a country based just on a few historical figures.
Fair enough. Can you put this in terms of individual rights though? I curious what concrete violations of individual rights take place today that would be protected with self-rule. Are their some type of property rights, freedoms of speech, or some such aspects that would be enhanced by self-rule.
Scotland is significantly to the left of the South of England. Without Scotland, we would not have had a socialist British government for a very, very long time.
With the powers they do have, they tend to be more redistributive (making all university education 100% state funded), and more restrictive (banning the display of tobacco in shops, etc.).
Scotland is significantly to the left of the South of England. Without Scotland, we would not have had a socialist British government for a very, very long time.
With the powers they do have, they tend to be more redistributive (making all university education 100% state funded), and more restrictive (banning the display of tobacco in shops, etc.).
While it is true that scotland is a rather socialist country, so is the UK as a whole.
plus, a lot of our ārestrictiveā and āredistributiveā policies donāt come from us, but the EU.
āIndependence is the recognition of the fact that yours is the responsibility of judgment and nothing can help you escape itāthat no substitute can do your thinkingā¦ā Atlas Shrugged P3C7
Is that good enough reason for independance?
Is that good enough reason for independance?
That quote is not about nations like Scotland gaining independence. It is about the trait of independence in an individual. e.g. when someone says: āHe wonāt believe that rumor just because everyone is repeating it; instead, heāll make an independent judgementā
The quote describes the concept.
Why does the concept not apply to scotland?
Why does the concept not apply to scotland?
Well, the concept of āindependenceā can apply to Scotland. It can apply to all sorts of situations where you want to describe a certain type of lessened relationship between two or more āthingsā (people, countries, algebraic variables). However, iIt would be a distraction to discuss why Randās quote does not apply to Scotland.
Letās focus on political independence. Why is it a good thing? The typical answer is that it would allow people in Scotland to decide things for themselves. Fair enough, but that leads to two questions:
Question 1. What concrete laws would an independent Scottish government pass, which are not in force today? And, what laws will they repeal which are in force today?
Maybe they will roll back some law that limits free-speechā¦that would be a good thing. Maybe they would also create some new law that would further limit some property right or other. That would be a bad thing. In balance, are you convinced that an independent Scottish government will create a system of laws that protects individual rights better than the current system does?
Question 2. Why not break Scotland up into two or three parts, and allow each to be a country on its own. After all, if more localized decision-making is a good thing, why not make ever-smaller countries?
SoftwareNerd.
As to question one, no-one can predict with much certanty what specific laws will be enacted, as party politics will still play a role in the shape of our country, but it is almost universaly agreed that step one would be to get all the UKās nuclear stockpile out of scotland, where 100% of it is as of now.
For question two, To take this point to itās logical conclusion, the ideal would be for all men to be self governing, esentialy being the anerchist paradice. What is needed is a government that A. the people respect and B. works in itās citizens intrests. For scotland, Westminister fails at both criteria, but Holyrood passes the former to a certain extent, (although, in fairness, not compleatly) and totaly for the latter.
What is needed is a government that ⦠⦠works in itās citizens intrests.
It is not the role of government to work for any and every type of citizen interest. Citizens are supposed to work for their own interests. The role of government is to ensure that individual citizens can work in their own interest and keep and trade the things they own or create, without other citizens using force upon them.
As for the article, the person claims that Scotland pays half a million for nuclear subs. That is an odd way to look at it. After all, the English and Welsh pay too. Obviously, all taxpayers will fund the common army. Also, it is silly to get rid of nuclear weapons. Do you also want to disband the whole army? If not, why single out nuclear weapons?