Yes, while morality is a code of values for the purpose of guiding man’s choices, all choices are not dictated by morality; e.g. the flavor of ice cream you choose - subjective.
You do not seem to understand the nature of morality. You seem to be wrongly presupposing that morality does not refer to particular facts. As a classic example of why that is completely wrong, it is a fact that some men are sexually attracted to men, and some men are sexually attracted to women. It is therefore immoral for a gay man to evade knowledge of his nature and pursue a sexual relationship with a woman, and it is just as immoral for a straight man to evade knowledge of his nature and pursue a sexual relationship with a man. The choice is not subjective, it is objective, and it is a function of the objective nature of the individual. Objectivism is never compatible with subjectivism.
Yes, while morality is a code of values for the purpose of guiding man’s choices, all choices are not dictated by morality; e.g. the flavor of ice cream you choose - subjective.
Don’t be silly. Choosing an ice cream is absolutely within the realm of Ethics. Picking the flavor you enjoy is moral, picking a flavor you hate, or you’re allergic to, is immoral. Just because people’s tastes vary, it doesn’t mean their choice is no longer based in objective value judgement.
And of course, taste has nothing o do with the OP’s question.
You do not seem to understand the nature of morality. You seem to be wrongly presupposing that morality does not refer to particular facts. As a classic example of why that is completely wrong, it is a fact that some men are sexually attracted to men, and some men are sexually attracted to women. It is therefore immoral for a gay man to evade knowledge of his nature and pursue a sexual relationship with a woman, and it is just as immoral for a straight man to evade knowledge of his nature and pursue a sexual relationship with a man. The choice is not subjective, it is objective, and it is a function of the objective nature of the individual. Objectivism is never compatible with subjectivism.
You frequently tell people (across forums) that they do not understand when it is you who does not understand.
And you have moralized more than once.
Ignoring your irrelevant analogy, you confuse Subjectivism with subjective (as in optional choices).
I’m certainly not saying that moral values are a matter of subjective choices. I’m saying that there are non-philosophical choices in life that are not objectively (via principles) determined. If you cannot agree with that, then the discussion is closed.
Don’t be silly. Choosing an ice cream is absolutely within the realm of Ethics. Picking the flavor you enjoy is moral, picking a flavor you hate, or you’re allergic to, is immoral. Just because people’s tastes vary, it doesn’t mean their choice is no longer based in objective value judgement.
And of course, taste has nothing o do with the OP’s question.
Read my last post. You also miss the point here. I can’t believe you could think selecting a flavor of ice cream is a moral issue. That’s moralizing.
“Ethics is a code of values to guide man’s choices and actions” - necessary for his survival. That does not include subjective choices that have nothing to do with survival and do not tie to principles.
David, as the moderator, has cancelled some of my posts because they conflict with his points of view, albeit he believes it is because I am not adhering to Oist principles. I am fully an Oist and have been attempting to make valid points here.
He loses his credibility when he controls the forum in order to make his views appear sacrosanct.
David, as the moderator, has cancelled some of my posts because they conflict with his points of view
He didn’t cancel them, he moved them to the Trash forum. Anyone can go there and see that they were removed because they contain exactly zero statements about the subject of the thread, and several observations about the character and knowledge of the people participating in it.
He didn’t cancel them, he moved them to the Trash forum. Anyone can go there and see that they were removed because they contain exactly zero statements about the subject of the thread, and several observations about the character and knowledge of the people participating in it.
He inappropriately “deleted” them. I was responding to his arrogance in the previous post (which is apparently ok for the moderator) and then added valid content.
Then I reponded to your comment (“You do realize you used the word moralizing about a dozen times now without ever hinting at what it means?”) noting your exaggeration and apparent lack of understanding of “moralizing.”
I can admire you sticking up for your friend, but the 2 of you remain unwilling to accept valid points that don’t suit you.
End result: those attempting to determine when receiving gifts is a moral issue remain confused.
There is not a single human choice which is exempt from ethical evaluation.
Whether to pee standing up or sitting down?
Ice cream flavor choice is a good example too.
Ethics would only come into these choices if they had some greater meaning, or if one chose based on some sort of outside influence or conformity.
If I am given a choice between two flavors of ice cream, neither of which I’ve had before, with no one trying to sway me either way, then in what way could my choice fall into the realm of ethical evaluation?
If I am given a choice between two flavors of ice cream, neither of which I’ve had before, with no one trying to sway me either way, then in what way could my choice fall into the realm of ethical evaluation?
Can you afford the expense? Can you afford the calories? Do you have the time to spend agonizing over a choice or should you just flip a coin and get on with it?
Can you afford the expense? Can you afford the calories? Do you have the time to spend agonizing over a choice or should you just flip a coin and get on with it?
When choosing between flavors, I have to assume these questions have already been addressed. (I feel ridiculous here, this is really funny shit).
Can I assume you are implying this is not an ethical choice? Or are you, god help us(excuse the expression), implying flipping a coin is a reasonable way to make an ethical decision?
I only ask because of some of the other really extreme nonsense implied in this thread. (lots of funny shit)
Just want to be sure where everyone is coming from…
When choosing between flavors, I have to assume these questions have already been addressed. (I feel ridiculous here, this is really funny shit).
These “questions that have already been addressed” are ethical questions, so no matter what flavor you choose the decision presupposes ethical content and so is itself ethical. The alternatives here are equally ethical, not non-ethical.
Can I assume you are implying this is not an ethical choice? Or are you, god help us(excuse the expression), implying flipping a coin is a reasonable way to make an ethical decision?
No you may not assume that. The ethical meta-decision of “what is the best use of my time” can indeed justify flipping a coin to make some other decision.
These “questions that have already been addressed” are ethical questions, so no matter what flavor you choose the decision presupposes ethical content and so is itself ethical. The alternatives here are equally ethical, not non-ethical.
No you may not assume that. The ethical meta-decision of “what is the best use of my time” can indeed justify flipping a coin to make some other decision.
If you are choosing a flavor, you have already made a determination of ethical or not. The question of chocolate or vanilla is completely subjective.
If you are choosing a flavor, you have already made a determination of ethical or not. The question of chocolate or vanilla is completely subjective.
Ayn Rand viewed ethics as a guide to everyday decision-making. Every choice can be potentially life-furthering or life-inhibiting. Thus, every choice needs reference to an ethics.
It is, of course, possible that two alternatives in a choice might be equally ethical. My choosing between chocolate and peanut butter cannot be made purely by reference to ethics (unless I am allergic to peanut butter; then one choice is clearly more life-furthering than the other). This is because switching from one to the other does not change the degree to which the result affects my life. I’m furthering life either way (presumably). This doesn’t mean ethics is irrelevant to the choice, but it does mean that I can include my own preferences in choosing.
Ayn Rand viewed ethics as a guide to everyday decision-making. Every choice can be potentially life-furthering or life-inhibiting. Thus, every choice needs reference to an ethics.
It is, of course, possible that two alternatives in a choice might be equally ethical. My choosing between chocolate and peanut butter cannot be made purely by reference to ethics (unless I am allergic to peanut butter; then one choice is clearly more life-furthering than the other). This is because switching from one to the other does not change the degree to which the result affects my life. I’m furthering life either way (presumably). This doesn’t mean ethics is irrelevant to the choice, but it does mean that I can include my own preferences in choosing.
I want to be very clear. I believe that if I have determined that there is nothing immoral, unethical, irrational, or otherwise harmful to me by choosing to have an ice cream, then the choice of flavor is completely outside the realm of ethics. Therefore, none of the above applies to my choice of flavor.
If you are choosing a flavor, you have already made a determination of ethical or not. The question of chocolate or vanilla is completely subjective.
It is an ethical decision which is also subjective within a range, thus it is not completely subjective.
I only use the the word subjective here in the sense of personal. It is true that no principle of virtuous behavior, such as honesty or justice, will distinguish between two flavors of ice cream. But the ultimate justification of those virtues must also be personal if they not to be meaningless abstractions, so there is only a difference in scale and scope between large decisions and small, not a difference in kind.