Eh. That actually makes me kind of want to read that book.
And by the way, being amused by the idea does not mean you wish for it to happen, or that it is irrational. It is more or less the same as someone enjoying a post-apocalyptic fiction.
It all depends on the reasons why you enjoy the fiction. I really enjoyed the remake of Dawn of the Dead.
Anyway, I am figure you disagree with my statement above. I remember you insinuated in the Michael Vick thread that you are against making moral judgments on anyone who does not initiate force. (Please correct me if you perceive that this does not represent your view.) We might as well not enter a similar argument here, applied to a different concrete, when we both already know our disagreement in more fundamental principles.
The author did not -advocate- the disappearance of the human race. He -hypothesized it- and then examined some of the consequences.
The author is hardly responsible for who did or did not applaud his work.
I agree with all of this.
I must have been misunderstood. I did not intended to indicate that the author is consciously advancing the Voluntary Human Extinction Movement or even just environmental fundamentalists. However, I think that members of those groups are enamored with his book, which is resulting in it receiving a lot of attention.
When I listed those books, they were all meant to be examples of purchases that were largely driven by irrational values. The success of Alan Weisman’s book is being driven by the success of the radical Environmentalist movement.
Suppose someone writes a book describing what would happen to the human race if an asteroid the size of the one that wiped out the dinosaurs struck the earth. Would you conclude that he was wishing or hoping such an asteroid would strike?
Not necessarily. It would depend on why the author wrote it. In Lucifer’s Hammer, Larry Niven and Jerry Pournelle did not implicitly support an asteroid collision with the planet. Similarly, by writing Atlas Shrugged, does not mean that Ayn Rand hoped that the planet would be ravaged by Statism, Altruism and Kantian philosophy. Such books can still have great heroes worth cheering for, an exciting plot and excellent character development, which could qualify them as good forms of art.
I wouldn’t. I would suppose that it was a cautionary essay and probably a good reason to keep close watch on earth orbit crossing bodies of considerable size. It would also be the basis of making plans to either divert such a body or find ways of hunkering down and having some of us survive the damage, so we would not go the way of the dinosaurs.
This sounds like a decent reason too.