Under the premise that you lead with your main conclusion, Byrne makes a significant error in saying that the US is being “weakened by an erosive array of social, economic and political forces”. This is a good example of the concrete-boundness that characterizes the disease of Disintegration. The cause is philosophy, which leads to social, economic and political results, as well as legal and education, and any number of other concrete manifestations. Also, “erosive” is a bit of a floating abstraction (what does “erosive array of forces” even mean? Does he mean “array of erosive forces?”).
“The deterioration of traditional cultural norms and the social upheaval that’s followed — from the living room to classroom the boardroom — is no surprise to Ayn Rand scholars”. Well, I for one am surprised, first because those unspecified traditional cultural norms were, in part, rotten, and were badly in need of deterioration. OMG the traditional norm of heterosexual mono-racial religious marriage with women playing the role of baby-makers and housekeepers has deteriorated, America is doomed! So the underpinnings of the article are rotten, and cannot be repaired by a later add-on quote “She understood that culture, society and politics are shaped by philosophy and when she saw the philosophical trends of the 1940s and 1950s she knew where it would eventually lead”.
Let’s see now how the analysis fares w.r.t. education. Again, the conclusion to be proven here is “Centralized educational bureaucracy has reached deeply into local education in recent decades — to the quantifiable detriment of the system and the nation’s schoolchildren”. The vaguely-hinted-at idea here is that a uniform federal education system is plainly inferior to an erosive array of disparate state level education systems. This is an instantiation of the states-right premise that, for some mystical reason, government action at the state level is automatically better than government action at the national level. Which I suppose would be because it is better for each smaller group of individuals defining a state will better protect individual rights because the group is small. So, it’s not the level / size of government that counts, it’s the fact of government at all that counts.
But actually, the problem is not just about government messing things up, it is about bad philosophy messing things up. Private education can be as bad or worse than public education. The worst institutions of higher education are, in my opinion, private and not governmental. It’s not that they are bad in the sense that they can’t teach that 2+2 = 5, it’s that they very effectively teach evil ideas, especially wokeism. The direct consequence of this training is – that’s where grade school teachers come from. This year’s corrupted college student at a private university becomes next year’s school teacher (private or public, elementary or high school, it doesn’t matter), and next decade’s administrators and eventually operators of the school who sets policy.
I don’t think the article is terrible, it is just disappointing in a predictable way. How about that religion thing? What is the main cultural vehicle for the promulgation of altruism?