Ayn Rand's Steady-State Universe

Our scientific instruments are extensions of our senses. Our plain validity of the senses gets us to the lab, to setting up a rotating mirror and a laser and a photo detector, from which we carry on to measuring the velocity of light and the tolerances we give to our measurement. Rand’s philosophy does not place any interfering constraints on the practice of science. Although, from her philosophic viewpoint, she should smile on the regular enterprise in science to find how the micro yields the macro (from Bohr’s correspondence principle guiding the development of QM to here). 

You may want to check what Ostaric has to say in The Criique of Judgment and the Unity of Kant’s Critical System (2023).

Kant’s tie of his KrV to his MFNS is pretty embarrassing (as is his reasoning in the First and Third Analogies of Experience in KrV). MFNS ends up being a regression almost so bad as the reasoning of Descartes to his laws of mechanics. Too much philosophy, not enough science. Kant thought he needed to supercede Newton’s laws of mechanics in MFNS  for integration with his results in KrV. He was always trying to get a leg up on Newton from the philosopher’s armchair, from Kant’s early efforts to find an account for the 3-dimensionality of space to Critical constraints on mechanics in MFNS. (And in his early embarrassing repetition of a popular-science magazine false argument to the inverse-square falloff of gravity—which was clearly clueless concerning Newton’s argument for that.) Rand seemed to have some sense of when she should not enter from her philosophy some fray going on in science. Some of her students lacked that sagacity. And she seemed to have some sense of when some popular disparity between scientific frontiers and ordinary experience was being stewed up—unreal—such as in the old silliness that because atoms and molecules are mostly empty space, I should be falling right through this chair I’m sitting on.


I should add, Cave Dweller, that I do not agree with the thesis of the inerrancy of the senses. Because peceptions are leaders, not just reporters. The moon illusion (which is not detrimental so far as I know) and the Mach-Bands illusion (which enhances accuracy of action) are not the predominant sorts of our perceptions. And anyway, I don't see Rand's inerrancy of the senses doctrine as any more constraining of science than Russell's.