4 hours ago, KyaryPamyu said:
No, not the Kantian meaning, just the common one: “many and various.”
Suppose that “existence exists” merely meant: “at least two things exist”. No talk about a universe, cosmos, multiverse or whatever. Could you jump from this modest claim to “the totality of everything is unborn, causeless, non-destructible”?
I’d say “yes”, even if the total number of entities was literaly two. They key lies in how you’d form the concepts “nothing” and “cause”.
In my understanding, you can form the concept “nothing” by observing an entity changing. When an entity “sheds its old skin” (form) and takes on a new one, I think: “that form turned to nothing.” So, nothingness never refers to the non-being of an entity, but only serves to differentiate what is currently true of an entity (actually, of its “ingredients”, since they can branch out into other entities), versus what used to be true about said entity.
The concept of “cause”, too, rests on observing an entity changing. You can look for the cause of a change, but only if there is a change – in the entity. Entities precede causes, not the other way around.
In order to draw these conclusions, the number of entities you observe is irrelevant. It could be two entities, or a googol entities. That’s the only thing my “city, country, planet, cosmos” example was hinting at. The amount of knowledge you need to verify both “existence exists” and its purported logical implications, is very small.
Now, let’s see how this could be applied to the Big Bang. If you concede my “entities first” conclusion, and conscientiously try to remain within its bounds, then the relationship between our current universe and the initial singularity is genetic, not causal. Where did the initial singularity dissapear? Well, answer this for me: in the case of the plant, where did the seed go, and in the case of the butterfly, where did the catterpillar go? I believe my analysis of “nothingness” shows how to answer this.
By the way, would you say that Kant’s conception of what metaphysics should be aligns, more or less, with your own? And is what Rand tried to accomplish in metaphysics even possible?
By the way, even Kant, who labored intensely at establishing the boundaries of our knowledge claims, simply took something as a given, with no need for further explanation: the thing-in-itself. Just like “nothingness” in Objectivism, Kant’s “noumenon” is not a positive, but a purely negative construct: that to which the categories have no applicability, or, what is left over after considering which things do fit into phenomenal experience. But he treats it as if it were a real existent (even ascribing it a name), which is indefensible on Critical grounds.
Genetic? That would entail something like an Aristotelian efficient cause. Consider that in Physics II.1–2, Aristotle distinguished between nature (physis) and art/craft (techne). The efficient cause of the former is internal (an acorn), while the efficient cause of the latter is external (the sculptor of a bust of Caesar, and his tools). The acorn is genetically programmed to grow into an oak, given the correct external conditions (sunshine, water, minerals in the soil). Nature “programs” the acorn to grow into an oak, but did nature exist at the time of the singularity? What programmed the singularity to grow into the universe? And were any external factors involved with the singularity as there are with the acorn growing into an oak? Is the singularity a real thing? Or is it just a placeholder that makes the Big Bang theory work? Can we talk about genetics (in your use of the term) coherently with regard to the singularity? I have more questions than answers.
Quote
Could you jump from this modest claim to “the totality of everything is unborn, causeless, non-destructible”?
That depends on the philosophy or physics or theory of the cosmos you choose to believe. If the universe is infinite and boundless, then you can’t speak coherently of a totality. “Infinity” isn’t a number, it’s a concept that resists being totaled. If, however, we only have two entities in the universe, we need more evidence to get from there to “unborn, causeless, and non-destructible.” Because “totality” isn’t a thing that you can attach attributes and actions, or even relations, to. Totality is a conceptual limit, not an ontological limit. The edge of the map (mental model) is not a place, it’s a limit. So we can’t get from “here” to “there” without committing a category error, a paralogism. And to resolve this, you will need to offer more evidence. And to get that evidence, you’d need what Kant calls intellectual intuition, that is, a god’s viewpoint to see the totality as a thing, to qualify the totality with the attribute of thingness. Apart from that, we are just “pretend” gods playing with words.
Quote
By the way, would you say that Kant’s conception of what metaphysics should be aligns, more or less, with your own?
To leap from epistemic conditions to metaphysics is a short-cut to knowledge. That is, to alleged knowledge that confuses the map with the territory. Metaphysics is useless as a stand-alone science; it must be connected to something real, that is, connected to empirical grounds that substantiate it. Kant didn’t destroy metaphysics, although he was incorrectly called the Great Destroyer. He gave it boundaries by limiting it to the empirical (or phenomenal). That was the whole point of the noumenal/phenomenal distinction: not to destroy knowledge of reality and leave us only with illusions, but to show that the illusions are in a metaphysics not grounded in the empirical (phenomenal). He called this transcendental illusion.
Quote
And is what Rand tried to accomplish in metaphysics even possible?
Practically speaking, a dogmatic metaphysics such as Rand’s is a magnet for skeptics. If all we had to do was declare axioms, then why didn’t philosophers for the last 2500 years think of that? Perhaps they did; perhaps some of them even attempted it. But the result would be “barbarians at the gates.”
The barbarians (skeptics) will respond, “Did Rand think to offer a secure foundation? It’s only certain to provide great confidence to its followers. But let’s see how confident they are after we knock the foundations out from underneath it.” But their confidence won’t be as easily undermined as the system itself, which stands on unfirm ground. Human nature demands that people continue to loudly and ever more steadfastly reaffirm their beliefs even as their mouths are being covered over by the quicksand they are (were) standing on, that appeared to be solid ground to the unwary.
I don’t believe that Rand intended to revive old-school metaphysics on solider ground. Not that you asked about this. She kept her metaphysics brief. The move from “A is A,” which is a logical construct, to its application as a metaphysical axiom was not given any intellectual warrant whatsoever. Rand simply asserted it. The ancient Greek law “A is A,” which originally said “A is A, and not-A is not-A” or the law of non-contradiction “A is not not-A” (Metaphysics, book Gamma), is about how we should think about things logically, and does not pretend to offer a theory about how things really are. Yes, really. Because, for Aristotle, this is not, at this point, about solving philosophical riddles, but providing the preconditions for doing philosophy at all. So for Aristotle, “A” can technically stand for anything you can imagine, although Aristotle intended “A is not not-A” to limit discussions of Being as such. For Rand, “A is A” is a metaphysical statement in which “A” is limited to the senses which she declared, without a positive proof, to be valid. Rand said that Aristotle brought the discussion back down to reality (“It is Aristotle who first formulated the principles of correct definition. It is Aristotle who identified the fact that only concretes exist”; “Definitions,” Introduction to Objectivist Epistemology, 52). But in fact, he limited it to thinking, at first. And this is why, for Aristotle, philosophy begins with logic, not metaphysics. She bypassed Aristotle’s call to apply “A is not not-A” to discussions about Being as such, and used it to assert her own truths.