There are right ways and wrong ways to enter a country. If the Mexicans are invading by coming over the border in droves, then they are short-circuiting the acceptable means of entry. My parents escaped Germany in the run up to Hitler’s regime and they came through Ellis Island and it took months, but they did it by the law and respected the new country’s laws. I myself brought my immigrant wife here from Asia and I went by the laws and didn’t try to smuggle her in, despite the hardship those laws created for me due to my low income.
Yes, and President Roosevelt was also just enforcing the immigration laws:
The St. Louis sailed out of Hamburg into the Atlantic Ocean in the summer of 1939 carrying over 950 Jewish refugees, mostly wealthy, seeking asylum from Nazi persecution just before World War II.
After seeking asylum in Cuba and being refused, the ship headed to Florida, where, on 4 June 1939, it was also refused permission to unload on orders of President Roosevelt. It then tried to enter Canada but was refused once more. The ship sailed back to Germany, whereupon various European nations each agreed to admit a small number of its passengers, the vast majority of whom ended up perishing in the Holocaust as most of the host countries came under Nazi occupation at some point during World War II, which started only a few weeks after the ship’s return to Hamburg.
But I am glad we have a screening process, however defficient it may be–for it’s better than no screening and letting in of diseased, criminal-minded and philosophically dangerous persons, in addition to the many who just want a better life.
That’s a red herring argument if I’ve ever seen one. Were those in the above ship “diseased, criminal-minded…”? Were you, your parents or your wife? No one is against keeping out criminals. That is not the purpose of today’s immigration laws.
As for zoning, it’s not keeping out riff-raff–it’s expecting the town to keep its end of the agreement. We complied and they said ‘screw you’ we’re going to give this developer privilages you never had.’ That’s what we object to.
You don’t have the right to tell other property owners what they can do with their property. Any “agreement” between the town and you over someone else’s right to property is invalid. If you want to control what they do with their property, buy it.
Your position is contrary to the right to property, an essential tenet of Objectivism. You are not an Objectivist. That is not meant as ad hominem, but a simple statement of fact. Why don’t you acknowledge that? Instead, you want to have your cake and eat it too, by claiming that you are an Objectivist, while denying essential elements of the philosophy.
All so that you can live on your mountaintop? It’s time to climb down from the mountain, brother.
When you’ve been around for eight decades, you start to see more, look beyond the simple black and white hypothetical concepts and into the application of social science. Young people may be smart, but they lack wisdom. And Wisdom, my friend, comes with experience and age.
Youth is wasted on the young.
That is a non-argument, both from intimidation (as someone points out above) and ad hominem. Do you see that? Perhaps that is acceptable to you.