Border Patrol Agents Get 11 Year Sentence for Doing Their Job

There are right ways and wrong ways to enter a country. If the Mexicans are invading by coming over the border in droves, then they are short-circuiting the acceptable means of entry. My parents escaped Germany in the run up to Hitler’s regime and they came through Ellis Island and it took months, but they did it by the law and respected the new country’s laws. I myself brought my immigrant wife here from Asia and I went by the laws and didn’t try to smuggle her in, despite the hardship those laws created for me due to my low income.

Yes, and President Roosevelt was also just enforcing the immigration laws:

The Voyage of the Damned

The St. Louis sailed out of Hamburg into the Atlantic Ocean in the summer of 1939 carrying over 950 Jewish refugees, mostly wealthy, seeking asylum from Nazi persecution just before World War II.

After seeking asylum in Cuba and being refused, the ship headed to Florida, where, on 4 June 1939, it was also refused permission to unload on orders of President Roosevelt. It then tried to enter Canada but was refused once more. The ship sailed back to Germany, whereupon various European nations each agreed to admit a small number of its passengers, the vast majority of whom ended up perishing in the Holocaust as most of the host countries came under Nazi occupation at some point during World War II, which started only a few weeks after the ship’s return to Hamburg.

But I am glad we have a screening process, however defficient it may be–for it’s better than no screening and letting in of diseased, criminal-minded and philosophically dangerous persons, in addition to the many who just want a better life.

That’s a red herring argument if I’ve ever seen one. Were those in the above ship “diseased, criminal-minded…”? Were you, your parents or your wife? No one is against keeping out criminals. That is not the purpose of today’s immigration laws.

As for zoning, it’s not keeping out riff-raff–it’s expecting the town to keep its end of the agreement. We complied and they said ‘screw you’ we’re going to give this developer privilages you never had.’ That’s what we object to.

You don’t have the right to tell other property owners what they can do with their property. Any “agreement” between the town and you over someone else’s right to property is invalid. If you want to control what they do with their property, buy it.

Your position is contrary to the right to property, an essential tenet of Objectivism. You are not an Objectivist. That is not meant as ad hominem, but a simple statement of fact. Why don’t you acknowledge that? Instead, you want to have your cake and eat it too, by claiming that you are an Objectivist, while denying essential elements of the philosophy.

All so that you can live on your mountaintop? It’s time to climb down from the mountain, brother.

When you’ve been around for eight decades, you start to see more, look beyond the simple black and white hypothetical concepts and into the application of social science. Young people may be smart, but they lack wisdom. And Wisdom, my friend, comes with experience and age.

Youth is wasted on the young.

That is a non-argument, both from intimidation (as someone points out above) and ad hominem. Do you see that? Perhaps that is acceptable to you.

So 40 or 50 would be a more realisitic age requirement for being taken seriously.

Hmm… I guess I’ll just be leaving then…

Hmm… I guess I’ll just be leaving then…

Well, I don’t have the wisdom of an 80 year old. I have about half that wisdom. :slight_smile:

I don’t think I have the wisdom to proceed, either…

This is an argument from intimidation. What does “in the letter of Objectivism, but not in the spirit of Objectivism mean.”

Not only is it an argument from intimidation, it’s just plain false. I know of at least one “older Objectivist” who is an advocate ofopen borders. Maybe he just hasn’t gained enough “wisdom” to see those Mexicans for the “ferocious animals” they truly are, eh mweiss?

Hmm… I guess I’ll just be leaving then…

I apologize…, I(and I assume,Dr. Peikoff) did not mean that in a general(or insulting) sense, but in the intellectual sense. In the world of, say, philosophy, 19 year old undergrads should be unsurprised if they don’t make waves in their field right away. In any field of study, the gaining of the field’s knowledge as well as the subsequent and necessary integrations, realistically take some time to master. This is not to say that learning stops at that point or that no ideas had before that point are of value. Typically, though, it is the case that an individual will have a “great new idea” and find later that it has already been investigated by 14 predecessors in the field.

Thorough knowledge of what is already known is sort of a beginning step which must be taken. The condecension sometimes recieved from people older and/or more advanced in a field is the result of an unwillingness or inability to try to explain a difficult idea without the predicating knowlege set. I would not take it too personally as it is typically just indicative of them not understanding the subject in question, thoroughly enough to concretize it to a laymen’s level.

To be especially clear, I do not mean to equivocate age with wisdom. Age is a necessary but not sufficient requirment. If you don’t agree, consider whether you think you personally will be wiser when you are twice your current age. More time equals more oppurtunity for observation and introspection. That’s all it means. It does not mean that an individual will actually utilize that oppurtunity or that a person could not put more effort into his self-creation and get there a bit sooner then average.

However, the Italians who immigrated in 1909, vs. the street gangs who immigrate from Mexico today are two totally different groups of people. The former were self-made men who had goals and a sense of personal responsibility. The second group are ferocious animals who are claiming territory and killing everyone who stands in their way.

The first group got here by legal means. The second group got here by trespass.

So Italians who migrated here had nothing to do with organized crime? Interesting. And all the immigrants from Mexico are street gang members? Wow. I think you are VASTLY over-generalizing here.

I distinctly notice a plethora of Mexican immigrants picking fruits and vegetables and working in the food service industry. Most of them seem like decent, hard working folks. And the ones picking fruit are doing those dirty little jobs that don’t pay well enough for “Amuricans”.

I am not exactly sure why the current immigration laws are immoral, if someone could explain I think that would be great. My main concern in general with illegal immigration is the possibility of the free entrance of terrorists. Perhaps it isn’t as big of a problem as I imagine, but I don’t know. I feel that for a nation to be secure it ought to have distinct boundaries that are protected.

Anyway, what are some ideas to improve the immigration system in America? All I seem to see are complaints and somewhat ad hominum statements, which is odd due to the individuals involved in the discussion.

I am not exactly sure why the current immigration laws are immoral, if someone could explain I think that would be great.

Already done:

Ultimately, the proper solution is to remove the irrational restrictions on immigration which cause this problem. The current immigration laws state that only so many Mexicans are allowed in. Why? No reason. Immigration policies could, optionally, restrict people from entering the country for reasons of individual merit, criminal screening, and such, (for example, we do have a citizenship test and we should keep it) but restricting based on _ national quotas _ ? That’s completely insane.

I am not exactly sure why the current immigration laws are immoral, if someone could explain I think that would be great. My main concern in general with illegal immigration is the possibility of the free entrance of terrorists. Perhaps it isn’t as big of a problem as I imagine, but I don’t know. I feel that for a nation to be secure it ought to have distinct boundaries that are protected.

King, Laws designed to keep out or trap terrorists and thieves and such would be moral. To the extent that the US immigration laws achieve that end, they’re quite okay.

However, most of the immigration rules are designed to keep people out, as such – not because they’re suspected of being bad guys. That is the immoral aspect. I’ll provide some examples, but if you want to get a good flavor of it, I suggest you read this story (the “protagonist” is a close friend of mine).

Over and above the current laws, there are some who would make them still more immoral, by suggesting that they be based on things like the speaking of English. While it makes a lot of sense for an immigrant to the US to speak English, this is really not the role of the government. The same with the immigrant’s culture. Any move to make the immigration laws more cognizant of such things would be to make them more immoral.

Anyway, what are some ideas to improve the immigration system in America?

In principle, the system should be changed so that any government control is based solely on the principle of protecting legitimate individual rights. There are a whole host of laws that need to change to align the current system with that. An overhaul is required. However, it might be easier to understand it in terms of what current laws need to be rolled back. So, here are some examples.

  • Today, the government allows some people to come to the US, but only under the condition that they will not work.
  • Today, the government has created certain rules about qualifications people must have before the government will allow them to immigrate. Even if a person has an offer of employment saying he’ll be paid twice or three times the median wage, that’s not qualification enough under current law.
  • Even under the current rules many people qualify to enter the country on “work permits”. However, in any year, only a certain number are allowed in. This annual quota is normally filled in the first quarter of each year. After that, no more are allowed in, regardless of qualification

All I seem to see are complaints and somewhat ad hominum statements, which is odd due to the individuals involved in the discussion.

Not sure who you’re referring to, but I hope this post addresses some of your questions, and I’ll be more than happy to explain anything in more detail.

Just so that you get the whole picture, there are three typical objections to immigration.

1. Not practical in a welfare state: Immigration should be free in and ideal society, but in a welfare state, it would simply encourage moochers to come here to exploit the system. There’s a more subtle version of this argument that goes as follows: in a welfare state, well-meaning, lower-paid honest folks are inadvertent moochers on the richer folk who pay the bulk of the taxes for their schools and roads and government. So, allowing honest, but poorer-paid folk into the country under the current system strains the system. This is a view held by some Objectivists as well, and in my view it has credibility. Though I disagree that things should remain just as they are, it’s definitely worth talking through the details and seeing what can and cannot be done, what should and should not be done.

2. Hurt American jobs: The bulk of the current laws are written with the view that the government should be protecting “American jobs”. This is a traditional protectionist argument. You might say this is the left-wing argument. Personally, I consider this view to be debunked long-ago, along with other socialist ideas, but I do understand how and why people hold it honestly. It’s worth explaining why this is the wrong view.

3. Cultural protection: This is the right-wing argument, that says that the government should protect American culture and tradition, and not let outsiders dilute it. This is the argument with which this thread begun. In my judgement, this view has the least rational basis of the three objections. [There is a variation on this that has a little more credibility, which is the argument that outsiders who do not understand the American system will come here, vote for socialists, and turn the US into another Mexico. This version is not pushed as primary, because the proponents do not want to encourage the obvious counter-argument, which is: let the hordes in, but don’t let them vote.]

Hopefully, this post (and the link I provided) give you something substantial to chew on.

Over and above the current laws, there are some who would make them still more immoral, by suggesting that they be based on things like the speaking of English. While it makes a lot of sense for an immigrant to the US to speak English, this is really not the role of the government. The same with the immigrant’s culture. Any move to make the immigration laws more cognizant of such things would be to make them more immoral.

Interesting. Why would this be immoral, specifically? I can see calling our immigration policy irrational because it makes no sense, but immoral? Doesn’t that imply someone’s rights are being violated? Whose rights? Who has a right to become a citizen?

Interesting. Why would this be immoral, specifically? I can see calling our immigration policy irrational because it makes no sense, but immoral? Doesn’t that imply someone’s rights are being violated? Whose rights? Who has a right to become a citizen?

Nice summary of the immigration debate, SoftwareNerd.

In answer to Inspector’s question above, he is failing to distinguish between immigration and citizenship. Even under our current laws an immigrant must wait a period of time (is it 7 years?) before becoming a citizen. It is immoral to restrict immigration, except for the sole reason of keeping out criminals, terrorists and residents of enemy countries. The reason is that a person has the right to live where he wants; such right is part of his right to life and property.

When it comes to becoming a citizen, I do think certain restrictions are permissible. I haven’t thought the issue through, but citizenship today requires a demonstration of some knowledge and appreciation of the American system of government. That seems appropriate. Personally, I do not think speaking English should be a requirement, but it seems entirely reasonable and practical to give the citizenship test in English, since that is our country’s dominant language. Of course, if an immigrant has failed to learn any English in 7 years (or whatever waiting period that is called for by the future immigration law), he would have trouble passing the test.

Interestingly, in a laissez faire society, there would be very little difference in status between being a citizen and non-citizen. Any individual living in this country would have the full protection of government. The non-citizen would only lack the right to vote.

***

From SoftWareNerd:

There’s a more subtle version of this argument that goes as follows: in a welfare state, well-meaning, lower-paid honest folks are inadvertent moochers on the richer folk who pay the bulk of the taxes for their schools and roads and government. So, allowing honest, but poorer-paid folk into the country under the current system strains the system. This is a view held by some Objectivists as well, and in my view it has credibility. Though I disagree that things should remain just as they are, it’s definitely worth talking through the details and seeing what can and cannot be done, what should and should not be done.

I disagree with this argument, apparently held by some Objectivists. It is a dangerous idea to advocate more government controls as an answer to problems caused by existing government controls. One should never advocate government controls for any reason I can think of, because doing so sanctions the growth of government power. The answer to the above situation is to eliminate taxes, and thereby remove any apparent injustice against tax-paying citizens.

By advocating the above view, one puts oneself in alliance with the typical anti-immigrationist who wants to keep out immigrants for the other reasons mentioned in SoftwareNerd’s post, or simply because he fears foreigners.

Also, I doubt there is much validity to the argument in economic terms. It may be true for some border regions where lots of illegal Mexican immigrants live. I would use the existence of that problem to argue for the legalization of their immigrant status so the Mexicans could earn more money as legally-recognized workers. The fact of being illegal residents limits the Mexicans to lower-paying jobs. Also, I would use the existence of immigrant burdens on public hospitals and schools to call for the ending of government provision of those services.

In answer to Inspector’s question above, he is failing to distinguish between immigration and citizenship.

Ah, right. Of course.

It is immoral to restrict immigration, except for the sole reason of keeping out criminals, terrorists and residents of enemy countries. The reason is that a person has the right to live where he wants; such right is part of his right to life and property.

I don’t quite see this. Are you saying that if someone approaches the border of the country and demands to enter, that it is a violation of his rights to refuse him? I understand that a lot of the restrictions of immigration these days are irrational, yes. But it is another thing altogether to say that they violate rights. Are you saying that all people on earth have a right to enter the American borders at will and live here, provided that they don’t represent a provable threat to the country? That the government of the USA is initiating force against many of those to whom it refuses entry?

I thought that entry for non-citizens was a permission, not a right. Yes, I know that citizens have a right to enter. But the position you state seems to lead (I think) to the idea that borders, as such, are immoral.

Inspector, Not all the existing irrational rules are immoral. The immorality is in the intent of many of the rules, the ones that are designed to keep “good people” out. I’ll post more later, but just to see if we have common ground here, imagine a situation where the US embassy has actually checked into a person’s background and given them a “clean chit”, and a US-based employer has offered the person a job. Now, a law that is designed to keep that person out, not because he might be a security risk, but specifically because he is likely to come to the US and work, is immoral. The same for a rule that allows a couple into the country, but insists that the wife can only do so if she undertakes not to work here. Would you agree?

Would you agree?

Irrational certainly and immoral to that extent absolutely. They target something good: the ability and willingness to work, and refuse on the basis of their virtue.

But a violation of rights? That I don’t see. Perhaps you will be able to enlighten me.

Irrational certainly and immoral to that extent absolutely. They target something good: the ability and willingness to work, and refuse on the basis of their virtue.

But a violation of rights? That I don’t see. Perhaps you will be able to enlighten me.

All humans have rights by virtue of being humans. Is it no less a violation of rights if a government harms a foreigner than if he harms a citizen or resident? When would it ever be moral to violate the rights of foreigners?

If immigration is used for the purposes I mention, that is consistent with upholding everyone’s rights, both those of the domestic residents/citizens and of foreigners. Furthermore, speaking as a citizen, when is it in my self-interest to deny the rights of foreigners? This points up the fact that immigration is, as a general rule, highly beneficial to me as a citizen. I benefit from the productive labor, ingenuity and capital that is brought to America by its immigrants.

So, I am making two points:

(1) A government cannot violate the rights of any individual, whether he is foreign or domestic.

(2) It is in my self-interest as an American citizen not to have foreigners’ rights violated, including their right to settle here (subject to the exclusions I already mentioned). The latter is part of anyone’s right to life & property.

So, I am making two points:

(1) A government cannot violate the rights of any individual, whether he is foreign or domestic.

Certainly, I agree. But you need to establish that a foreigner has the right to cross our border.

Certainly, I agree. But you need to establish that a foreigner has the right to cross our border.

In principle everyone has a right to do whatever they wish as long as they do not violate the rights of others. Rights do not flow from government; rather, governments are instituted to recognize and protect those rights.

This does not imply that all foreigners are to be presumed innocent until guilty; it does not imply that a foreigner should get such protection for free; also, a particular foreigner may be denied such a right for good reasons. However, all those details should be decided within the framework of the broad principle that everyone has rights.

Certainly, I agree. But you need to establish that a foreigner has the right to cross our border.

Well, everyone, foreigner or domestic resident/citizen, has rights. As part of one’s right to life and property, one possesses the freedom and right to live wherever one pleases. No government can tell someone where he can live. I do not see why that does not apply equally to everyone, regardless of where he is domiciled.

Now, here is the issue. There are legitimate reasons for denying entry to a foreigner. If he is a criminal, an agent or resident of an enemy country, or in some other way demonstrably represents a threat of force against Americans, he can and should be barred from entry. The reason for barring entry is that the foreigner represents an objective threat to the rights of American residents & citizens. So, foreigners who threaten the rights of Americans are denied entry.

Now, consider: If a foreigner is not threatening the rights of Americans, what would be the reason for denying him entry?

I think you would agree that barring freedom of movement to a peaceful and non-threatening person is a violation of his rights. To do that of foreigners would deny them their rights. Yes, they have a right to emigrate to the United States. However, if they are peaceful and non-threatening, they are… peaceful and non-threatening. They are not a threat to Americans and should be permitted entry.

Having said all that, I would agree that the government should have a fair amount of discretion in deciding whether someone represents a threat. For example, a spy from a country that is hostile to us, but against whom we have not declared war, could and should be denied entry. I do not have a problem with special immigration courts that would adjudicate lawsuits arising from such decisions. As a side observation, I wonder how often a real spy would sue for entry, when in the act of defending himself, he would have to blow his cover.

The bottom line is that I do not think national security is compromised by respecting the right of everyone to live where he wants, whether he is domestic or foreign, and upholding what is implied by that right: foreigners have a right to move to the United States. In fact, I would contend that if foreigners’ rights could be violated – if foreigners could be denied entry for arbitrary or racist or political reasons – then a government with such power against foreigners becomes a threat to Americans. Abusive government power cannot be compartmentalized in one area. It always metastasizes until it invades every area of life.

When would it ever be moral to violate the rights of foreigners?

In the case of expected collateral damage during the bombing of a foreign nation during war, it seems that the rights of those innocents which are killed are morally violated by the bombing nation. I am with inspector. I do not understand how someone would have a right to enter a country unless it is presumed that all people in the world have automatic citizenship in a properly free country.

In the case of expected collateral damage during the bombing of a foreign nation during war, it seems that the rights of those innocents which are killed are morally violated by the bombing nation. I am with inspector. I do not understand how someone would have a right to enter a country unless it is presumed that all people in the world have automatic citizenship in a properly free country.

The distinction between immigrant and citizen (implied by “automatic citizenship”) have already been made. Being able to immigrate into a country and being a citizen are two different things.