Two points: 1: This was a violent felon drug smuggler that was shot–a violent criminal.
Well, the “drug smuggler” part is hardly a strong political argument to make to us Objectivists. However, in this particular case, the real issue is: should we allow cops to shoot people who are not threatening them, as long as it later turns out that the person who was shot was a felon? Is that the type of power you wish to grant to the cops? Think about this carefully, since you’re the one who often talks about responding violently when the cops come to get you!
Yes, America was built largely by immigrants. However, the Italians who immigrated in 1909, vs. the street gangs who immigrate from Mexico today are two totally different groups of people. The former were self-made men who had goals and a sense of personal responsibility. The second group are ferocious animals who are claiming territory and killing everyone who stands in their way.
This is untrue. It is completely false that Mexicans who immigrate are predominantly criminals. As for the Italians – it’s funny you chose that particular group. Would one have said that the mafia who immigrate from Italy are ferocious animals, killing everyone who stands in their way? (Check out Sopranos for some concretes
)
The gangs, to the extent they exist, are largely a creation of government, in this sense: because the government outlaws legitimate activity (immigration and drug-sales), criminals take up those activities.
The second group got here by trespass.
You fail to point out that to the extent that this could be considered trespass, it is only because the law is defining trespass incorrectly and immorally. The vast majority of Mexicans in the US are trading with other people just as native born folk do. The government may impose immigration controls to help identify criminals and keep them out, but it may not legitimately adopt a purpose of keeping anybody else out.
One final point: a nation is defined by language, borders and culture.
“Is” or “ought to be”? Borders, yes… language and culture, obviously not. It is untrue that the state should impose a language and a culture. That is a collectivist idea. What next? a Ministry of Culturally-appropriate song and dance?
When, as you propose, open the borders to all immigrants, regardless of condition, the effect is to annihilate the American nation.
Your statement is a metaphor. Obviously, the nation won’t be annihilated. If you drop the hyperbole and re-phrase this with proper concepts, it might be possible to discuss it.
If you eliminate borders, why not just unite the US with S. America and then the rest of the world and have one world government? That’s what you want, isn’t it?
if Mexico wants to be the 51st state, there’s no fundamental moral reason to refuse. I can think of some pros and cons, but the higher number of Spanish speakers and the risk that more white folk will give up Pizzas for Burritos is an extremely poor moral argument. I mean, I can understand it as a personal preference, but that’s what rights are all about: as placing limits on where one’s personal preferences can be used to tell other people what to do. So, one may boycott the Taco shop, but one may not ask the town to issue a licence only to Pizza shops.
Let’s look at what happens when we don’t have border control, which discriminates between hoodlums and good, honest people who might want to assimilate into our culture: You end up with Southern California, which is today 52% Hispanic, spreading across the entire US. You end up with Muslim terrorists entering the country (since no border guards are there to stop them from coming in) …
You use the word “assimilate”, a vague word to use, because it could mean a lot of things. If its means trading honestly, then fine; but the vast majority of Mexicans already do that. However, the rest of your post implies that it means following the optional cultural habits of the pre-existing population. Some political philosophies hold that to be the proper role of government; Objectivism does not.
As for the Muslim terrorist part, that’s a red herring. If one were really interested in keeping Muslim terrorists and other criminals out, an extremely important step is to de-criminalize immigration by folk who want to work and trade. The government has created a situation where honest millions keep silent about the gangsters in their midst because they need those gangsters now and then to get around illegitimate laws. One has created the situation where a person who is crossing the border illegally is more likely to be honest than a criminal. That fact lies at the root of the “border-control problem”. If the rules were changed, and the honest could enter legitimately, the border would be far more secure from criminals. Opening up immigration is an important step toward keeping criminals out.
… America, for it’s defining characteristics, language, culture, ideas,…
If one is speaking in the context of immigration law, or any other law, then the defining characteristic of America is not its language or its culture; not even its “ideas” used loosely. In this context, America is a political system. It’s defining characteristic is its political system. If someone were to argue that America’s political system would be stripped of more rights, because the system is flawed in ways that would allow that to happen, that would be a decent argument. However, there are ways to ensure that that does not happen. It would be interesting to discuss the options with people who accept rights as a starting point. As stated however, I dismiss those concerns as polemical points in favor of rights, being made by people who really aren’t interested in rights.
The problem with young so-called “Objectivists” today is that they take certain statements in the philosophy too literally and out of context, which results in absurd notions that we ought to just not have any borders, since it’s “freedom”, …
No, it’s not about taking philosophy “too literally”. Really, it’s a statement of an ideal. One can raise objections as to why the we cannot get there in a single leap today; one can make the argument that controls breed controls and that one cannot unwind one set of controls without the other. The point is that one has to start with the goal and then talk about constraints present today. You haven’t attempted to do so. Instead, your arguments are about Spanish and burritos.
The point is that the “young Objectivists” are starting with the right principle; now, all they have to figure out is how to apply it. You however, are starting from the entirely wrong “principle” (if one can call it that), and therefore you have no decent argument to offer.
The question you need to consider is "does everyone deserve a better life? If so, then at the expense of WHOM?
No, the question to consider is: is it moral to stand in the way of someone who wants to achieve a better life? This is an old question. For instance, a criminal may say that he wants to achieve a better life by taking my property – can I stand in his way? A competitor may want to acheive a better life by making a product just like mine, but slightly better, and it drives me out of business – can I stand in his way? Many people get this mixed up because they aren’t clear on the meaning of rights. Clearly, you have them mixed up, with your implicit “right to culture and language”.