One thing that occurred to me insofar as we’re talking about apparent excommunication of DH from the Church of Objectivism is that we just had a great discussion clarifying, exactly, “What Is and Is Not an Objectivist”:
http://forum.objectivismonline.com/index.php?showtopic=23201
In this thread LP is used as a reference wherein he advocates a contextual definition and in practically discourages using the label as it is rhetorically fraught with peril.
***
I think the heart of the problem here is that we’re conflating the personal and the philosophical.
With that, a solution to this whole mess would be for LP to rename ARI and his other organizations, “Leonard Peikoff”. Then removing a link from somebody who insulted him would be a personal tit-for-tat (and I would have no problem with that action per se). Then his statements would be, “so and so is no longer my friend and I’m de-linking him from my site”, _ and not _, “so and so is no longer an Objectivist and all past/present/future works from so and so are no longer valid” or whatever.
***
I should also say, for the record, that I actually do think DH misspoke when she accused LP of “armchair philosophizing”. First, that phrase is not particularly clear and is somewhat vacuous and thus smacks of name-calling. Second, it wasn’t armchair philosophizing but rather armchair doctoring. Third, the real issue is that LP took on the topic at all in any depth rather than dismissing it as an issue outside of philosophy and thus outside of his own vocation.
I most certainly do also sympathize with the emotion might have driven DH to write what she wrote which might have made it harder to stay on message. When a value–a smart, useful LP that writes interesting, useful things that are true–evaporates before your eyes and apparently travels down a path that so many modern-day annoying pundits do, that would tend to make you mad.
Hence my first reaction to this situation and LP’s words was chronicled here as, “has he gone nuts?”…