From what I remember, Cicero was instrumental in discovering Catiline’s conspiracy and publicly exposing his machinations. Even just 100 years ago, the majority of the public was still very well versed in Ancient Greco-Roman history, and paintings about those ancient times abounded (since these were intended for popular consumption, and assumed a certain level of knowledge, they give an indication of the popular interest and understanding of those times). Even a great gallery such as Cordair has not even one painting with a Classic theme in mind. Anyway, back to Catiline, here’s one famous 19th century painting of Cicero’s denounciation:
http://www.skidmore.edu/academics/classics…om/denounce.jpg
Catiline, ostensibly a respectable Roman senator yet working under covers to maliciously undermine the government, is helplessly isolated in the Senate by Cicero, who systematically and methodically destroys, demolishes, Catiline’s public character, respectability, and any future for his designs.
About Cicero, Cato, and Murena, here’s a quote from Plutarch that mirrors what you said:
When Cicero, being consul, undertook the defence of Murena against Cato`s prosecution, by way of bantering Cato, he made a long series of jokes upon the absurd paradoxes, as they are called, of the Stoic sect; so that a loud laughter passing from the crowd to the judges, Cato, with a quiet smile, said to those that sat next to him, “My friends, what an amusing consul we have.”
Cicero, of course, along with Seneca, became the most famous of all Stoics, so there’s more here than meets the eye. It would be helpful to remember that at this time he was primarily a lawyer, and not averse to making sweeping claims to sway his courtroom. The historical context here is also important - the speech was delivered in 63BC, whereas Caesar/Crassus/Pompey Triumvirate became fully inagurated in 59BC when Caesar won the consulship. So, before the dire threat that these three men posed to the Republic became apparent, there may have been petty dissentions among Rome’s leading men. But after Caesar increasingly made it apparent what his designs were while campaigning in Gaul and smashing enormous armies of the unwashed and hairy French (
), then Cicero and Cato became more allied in their values and aims. Indeed as time went on, the two men acquired tremendous respect for each other. At one point Cato completely alienated the Roman people and Senate by his intransigent opposition to tyranny and corruption of the Late Republic. Cicero, a very well known and respected politician, was his greatest defender both with the People and in the Senate; in a number of places he records his near-worship for Cato’s virtues and Stoic attributes, and ridicules men who dare show anything but the utmost respect for the man.
The best places to learn about these two Roman heroes are “Cato” and “Cicero” by Plutarch, a 1st century AD biographer/historian. These works have never been equalled in my opinion, because unlike even the best modern books, they never succumb to impotent synicism and skepticism, and allow hero-worship to take a central role when appropriate.
The play “Cato” is short, however, and *very* moving, so that may actually be a good first step, in order for you to acquire inspiration and emotional fuel to devote time to reading longer works on the subject. Cicero is absent in the play, for the story focuses on the last gasps of the Republic when Caesar has crossed the Rubicon, and the Senate had to evacuate Rome for Utica in Africa (Cicero stayed in Rome, not willing at the time to ally himself with the Republicans in face of Caesar’s fury). There, in Utica, Cato and a few others prepare to make a final stand for freedom.
In general, Cato’s legacy has been a Stoic intransigence against tyrants and the mob - in action more than in words. Cicero’s legacy has been a whole corpus of political and philosophical writings that served in America’s founding; I also remember that he might have been the first Latin translator of Aristotle (!); and finally, his works are an unmistakable collection of speeches and letters all with one overwhelming aim of arguing for rational human happiness and a society of natural rights. Cato was a stronger man, in my opinion, but more quiet and reserved in his intellectual range and thought - a conservative in the best sense of the word. Cicero did a few things that betrayed his Stoic heritage, but he was a philosopher of the first rate, a true man of action who was Rome’s greatest ethical/political thinker and at the same time someone who actively influenced public policy. Cicero’s thought can be described by worship of the classic Roman virtue, mixed with intellectual innovation and an inherent a desire for human progress - a liberal in the best sense of the word. The Founding Fathers may have admired Cato a little more, but it was Cicero’s works that they invoked during the Constitutional Conventions, and his impassioned speeches inspired them as much as Cato’s actions.