Communism in China

Anyway, my wife’s family was starving when she was a kid, and she and her sister both worked like crazy, with virtually no resources, to achieve educational and professional success in China then the U.S. At least in my wife’s case, she has nothing but contempt for any lazy poor person in the U.S. who would demand a moral claim on our money, particularly considering that even in inner cities the standard of living and opportunities are 100 times what she started out with, and that they are making the decision to throw their lives away.

what a beautiful story, A.West. I guess some people have had freedom and prosperity for so long they lose perspective of what’s important. I would value her opinion over some rich literati’s any day of the year.

give my highest regards to your wife.

Labrat,

On whether Chinese culture paved the way for Communism, In my paper, I noted some features of philosophic systems that I think helped set the table. Here is the briefest outline of my thoughts on this:

Confucianism - I think this boosted the ethical regard for collectivism and duty, and thinking of oneself in relation to others. There was also a Confucian scorn for merchants and profit.

Taoism - contibuted a false alternative of pseudo-individualism, and epistemologically reveled in the acceptance of contradictions, which I believe set the stage for dialectic theory, and a low respect for Aristotelian - type logic inthe culture.

Legalism - though a dead philosophy, the first emperor created an apparatus of repression, dictatorship and statism that never really went away. The Chinese culture has never abandoned the ethical mandate to serve the state/emperor.

I think your perspective is on the particulars of Communism as practiced in China and how they conflict with specific Chinese cultural practices. I agree there are conflicts there. My perspective is on the Chinese culture’s big picture compatibility with collectivist movements and their ethical/epistemological underpinnings. Similarly, while Communism in Russia violated and broke with traditional Russian practices and customs, it was not inconsistent with Russian culture overall. Which is why I think Ayn Rand would have left for America even if the revolution never happened.

Mr. West,

Sorry I was unable to follow up on this sooner. Also I can’t open the link to your article. I wonder can you send me an email with your article attached? I’d appreciate that very much!

I actually can’t stop thinking about what you’ve said that “Communism was in many ways consistent with Chinese culture”. Emotionally I can’t accept it but I need to rationalize my reasons.

First, the ideology of socialism and communism could not have arisen from a Chinese culture. For 2000 years, China has always been an autocratic country where the Emperor had the absolute supreme power over all his subjects and people pledged ultimate loyalty to the emperors, especially the good emperors, and there were quite a few of them in history. I don’t think this can be considered collectivism or altruism.

The rise of socialism and communism in the West followed French Revolution and Industrial Revolution. I’d consider it an aberration from the Enlightenment movement that is based on false premises. But nevertheless, it is a side product of Western’s democratic and Enlightenment movement that still prevails today.

In the later 19 century, China fell from a once most advance and powerful country in the world to be defeated by Westerners in every aspect and became a semi-Feudal semi-colonial country. In the early 20 century, after China was forced to open its door, many Chinese intellectuals look to the Western humanities to find out why China had fallen behind, and why the once barbaric West had suddenly became so strong. They took the idea of democracy and unfortunately also socialism. For whatever reason capitalism did not appear to be popular then. Perhaps it was partially because that China was a predominantly agricultural country, and partially because of the unfavorable general impression of the colonialists’ practice at the time. The anti-colonialist sentiment was very strong among China’s intellectuals in the early 20 century. Certainly patriotism was considered morally above individualism and capitalism. While China was trying to break from its old culture, which was deemed no longer suited for its advance, it unfortunately turned to the socialism.

Therefore I still don’t think the traditional Chinese culture in any way is more compatible with Communism than the Western cultures. The rise of Communism in China has its historical roots, but not the cultural roots.

Although historically China’s intellectuals did shun merchants and commerce, in the pop culture, “fa cai” or “getting rich” has always been the most popular good-wishes that people say to each other and hoped for themselves. Next week will be Chinese New Year. If you go to any Chinese shop, you will see all the New Year goodies with wordings like “Have savings year after year!” “Wish you get rich in New Year!” printed on them. In the Communist China, we used to think that these kinds of things were extremely vulgar and un-revolutionary. But now I’ve already got myself a “Money collecting bucket” and I’d like to say to you all “Get rich in the New Year!”

Labrat, though I disagree with your assertions that Emperor worship isn’t a form of collectivism, I see where you are coming from when you say Socialism and communism aren’t original chinese ideas. Those actually have their roots in Kant and Plato.

But the point A.West was trying to make is that your culture has an unfortunate history of collectivism, AKA Emperor worship, so was more receptive to Communism than others. Many cultures have bad habits which go back a long way. Spain and the old Spanish colonies, for example, have their roots in Hapsburg mercantilism, which is why Spain remains one of the more economically weaker powers of Europe, and why most of South America remains mired in poverty. The South American countries were also very receptive to communism and welfare statism.

By contrast, Britain and her colonies have had a history of free will, and generally resisted the lure of Communism. Though that love for free will is slowly eroding, it will be up to us to preserve that.

I am actually of the opinion that one day China may be able to evolve into a system more Capitalistic than any nation before it. I think every nation has that potential. Trust me, I am not a racist. :thumbsup:

But remember what Ayn Rand once said: Those who fight for the future live in it today.

China is either becoming more capitalistic, or its just being more pragmatic for the short term of course. The communist themselves have admited that communism has failed. They are now just plain old post-modernist that don’t stand for anything.

If you dont believe me read these interesting quotes, from the linked article below. Its old but sill applies.

“In previous years Chinese communist ideology has abandoned its economic ideology as, “…unable” to produce the standard of living desired for the Chinese people,” as the Communist Party put it. ”

“‘The Communist Party of China is trying to find a philosophical underpinning for Jiang Zemin Thought and has been trawling through Europe’s Postmodern Marxist tracts for inspiration.’”

“In his speech marking the Communist Party’s 80th anniversary this year…,” “He surprised his audience when he said there was no fixed truth or meaning even in Marxist texts such as the Communist Manifesto.”

“The denial that there is any eternal or scientific truth embodied in the writings of Marx,Lenin, Stalin, Mao or even Deng Xiaoping, resembles the path pioneered by the generation of

1960’s Marxist philosophers in Europe.”

“Mr. Jiang said there was now just ‘a scientific thinking system’ created by the great Marxists.Marxism is reduced to a method of analysis, not a programme of political action.” “Freed from any

binding commitments other than raising living standards, the Communist Party has now undermined

its own rationale for a Leninist dictatorship.”

“A year ago, the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences organized a two-day international symposium which brought together 80 foreign and domestic philosophers from Australia, Britain, Germany,Italy and Japan to look at the new Marxist philosophy.” “The father of the school of deconstruction, French academic Jacques Derrida, is on a lecture tour of China after the visitin April of Germany’s leading Marxist philosopher, Jurgen Habermas.”

Read this, for more examples…

http://web.archive.org/web/20021007164921/…irratphil.shtml

All in all, I still consider China a threat and I don’t think we should trade with them…AT ALL.

What will we do when they think that capitalism isn’t "practical"anymore and revert to their old ways.

How do you deal with post-modernists?

Some good things happening in China:

The Peasant Tiananmen Time Bomb

Intellectuals of the Austrian School in China

Sino Liberal

Then China joined the international copyright club. This meant there was no way for the translation to be published.

I’ve been in China for 3 years, and there is a BIG thirst for new ideas. Anyone know where I can get the Chinese Version of the “Virtue of Selfishness” The quote above represents the main issue I have with IP (Intellectual Property Rights), which have been addressed well here:

Intellectual Property Archive

Peer to Peer technologies could be used to bring down these collectivist/dictatorships down overnight by allowing people in general to download information without being censored. Too bad that the ideas that need to get out, are being kept in by IP Statist Luddites.

Luddite

Any of a group of British workers who between 1811 and 1816 rioted and destroyed laborsaving textile machinery in the belief that such machinery would diminish employment. 2. One who opposes technical or technological change.

ETYMOLOGY: After Ned Ludd, an English laborer who was supposed to have destroyed weaving machinery around 1779.–American Heritage Dictionary