So how do words get their definitions, application range, and set-in-stone-ness?
Words start by being the symbols that represent a concept (every concept must be united under a symbol). So you sort of have to start with how the concept is formed. We don’t have a specific concept “white reindeer”, we just have the concepts “white” and “reindeer”. In a totally mythical world, things could get cold and reindeer could elsd up being more important to our lives. At a certain point, it could become important to distinguish “white reindeer” from “general reindeer” (they fetch a higher price). We can then say “Hey, Aslat, go cut the white reindeers out of the herd”, or we could economize and form a specific concept “gabba” (don’t ask why that word), and now we have a new word.
Many definitions especially of “natural kinds” are ostensive, that is, it amounts to the knowledge “that is one, this isn’t”. You really can’t “define” dog, though you can explain what one is and even translate it into Latin. Explicit verbal definitions become important when talking about higher order concepts, such as “rights”, “law” or “sacrifice”. As we have seen, the very boundaries of the concept “rights” have been shifted by people using the word “right” to refer to “the entitlement to receive stolen goods”.
One extreme view of the matter is to demand an extremely etymological use of words, so that we should use words the way they were originally used. One problem is that we actually have no idea how that was (one example is “dog” which we think referred to just one specific kind of canine but we don’t know which one, and “hound” which use to mean “any dog”). “Meat” used to mean simply “food”. The fact is, though, that due to changes in how words are used, “meat” now refers to “flesh” and “dog” now refers to “domestic canines”.
Usually, words start out pretty clear and well-defined, but they become murky when people ignore the established meaning of words and start talking metaphorically or worse. The best way to combat that problem is to carefully study word meaning, and not stray from the meaning given in a good printed dictionary. And, I must add, to gently but firmly correct misuses by other people (but please do your homework before doing so). In the case of “sacrifice”, observe those instances where a person is claimed to be “sacrificing”, and challenge whether it is a sacrifice. That is especially tough, because it often comes up in the context of heroism, where a soldier is killed in the line of duty. Generally, these guys are aware of Patton’s speech to the troops in May 1944: “Now I want you to remember that no bastard ever won a war by dying for his country. You won it by making the other poor dumb bastard die for his country”. Generally, heroes who “sacrifice” have no intention of dying, it just unfortunately works out that way.