Conflicting Conclusions and therefore Conflict of Interest

17 hours ago, 2046 said:

In evaluating a philosopher’s conclusion or doctrine on something, you generally want to know what they mean when they say things. Otherwise it’s a fallacy of equivocation. So if Merlin wants to say “well maybe on Rand’s premises there aren’t, but on my premises there are!” that is either completely uninteresting contribution to the discussion on Rand’s philosophy, or it’s a fallacy of equivocation. If Merlin is only playing around with his own premises, then he can do that without my participation. If he’s making logical fallacies then he is unworthy of discourse. The question for everyone else is on Rand’s premises, are there any conflicts of interest in the sense she means of conflicts, interests, and “among rational men” in the essay?

Your big ifs posit false alternatives. Rand’s premises ignore a lot. Reality isn’t just about John Galt vs Wesley Mouch, Orren Boyle, or James Taggart. Reality isn’t just about the individual vs. government, or the virtuous vs. the far from virtuous.

Is the following a bad premise? There is a general harmony of interests among rational men. Most interactions are cooperative and peaceful. It’s not perfect. Some conflicts rise, but they are rare and they tend to be mild. Rational men settle them with negotiation and persuasion rather than coercion.

In the business world, all producers aren’t self-employed who only trade with others. In fact, a minority are. Many workers in today’s world work in an organization of many other workers. They work as part of a team. They need to cooperate. They may think independently, but they may not act independently. They act not solely for themselves, but for the good of the organization or their part of it. One can ask, do conflicts of interest ever arise in such an environment? Or one can dismiss it as “completely uninteresting” or a “fallacy of equivocation.”

In the real world, there are many conflicts of interest as described here. One can ask, are there some questions worth asking about them? Or one can dismiss them because Ayn Rand had nothing to say about them.

 

14 hours ago, MisterSwig said:

This is a curious conclusion to Rand’s essay. Her entire argument appears to rest on the final claim that in a free society we don’t have to deal with irrational people and in a non-free society it’s impossible to pursue our interests. So does her position fall apart if it turns out that in a free society sometimes we do have to deal with irrational people, and in a non-free society it’s possible to pursue our interests?

Indeed, a theory built on a giant IF. In other words, a theory built on Ayn Rand’s ideally rational men, not real rational people.

39 minutes ago, merjet said:

In the real world, there are many conflicts of interest as described here. One can ask, are there some questions worth asking about them? Or one can dismiss them because Ayn Rand had nothing to say about them.

Just scanning the highlights, this was found:

Related to the practice of law.

Conflict of interests have been described as the most pervasive issue facing modern lawyers. Legal conflicts rules are at their core corollaries to a lawyer’s two basic fiduciary duties:

The lawyer’s duty of loyalty is fundamental to the attorney-client relationship and has developed from the biblical maxim that no person can serve more than one master.

What if that master were reason?

A person who keeps reason forefront, and allows nothing higher than the judgement of their own mind is of Miss Rand’s ideally rational man. Is this not an achievable attribute of real rational people?

31 minutes ago, dream_weaver said:

The lawyer’s duty of loyalty is fundamental to the attorney-client relationship and has developed from the biblical maxim that no person can serve more than one master.

What if that master were reason?

A person who keeps reason forefront, and allows nothing higher than the judgement of their own mind is of Miss Rand’s ideally rational man. Is this not an achievable attribute of real rational people?

For the context I submit that reason is not a person. “Master” seems to call for a person.

41 minutes ago, merjet said:

For the context I submit that reason is not a person. “Master” seems to call for a person.

I think the biblical reference (Matthew 6:24) offers god or mammon, where mammon is wealth. While wealth is man-made, it is typically not regarded as a person.

19 minutes ago, dream_weaver said:

I think the biblical reference (Matthew 6:24) offers god or mammon, where mammon is wealth. While wealth is man-made, it is typically not regarded as a person.

Sorry. The context I meant was the attorney, client, and loyalty. “The lawyer’s duty of loyalty is fundamental to the attorney-client relationship and has developed from the biblical maxim that no person can serve more than one master.”

1 Like

55 minutes ago, merjet said:

Sorry. The context I meant was the attorney, client, and loyalty. “The lawyer’s duty of loyalty is fundamental to the attorney-client relationship and has developed from the biblical maxim that no person can serve more than one master.”

What of justice? It is not a person either, although it relates to the basis for evaluating people. Is the lawyer’s loyalty to the client to disregard justice. Another basis for movies and books is where those viewed as serving the cause of justice come to know that their client is guilty and what they choose to do with that knowledge.

1 hour ago, dream_weaver said:

What of justice? It is not a person either, although it relates to the basis for evaluating people. Is the lawyer’s loyalty to the client to disregard justice[?]

No. The lawyer’s role in to do the best he/she can for his/her client. Justice is the primary responsibility of the judge(s) or jury if it gets that far, or an arbitrator.

10 hours ago, merjet said:

No. The lawyer’s role in to do the best he/she can for his/her client. Justice is the primary responsibility of the judge(s) or jury if it gets that far, or an arbitrator.

I get what you are saying. I don’t like it. It seems that if a lawyer knows his client is guilty, it amounts to them trying to ‘con’ the legal system. 

While the presumption of innocence until proven guilty is due process, the proof in the case of a guilty client is actively being circumvented, suppressed, or etc., by his counselor. 

The onus of proof is being upheld and thrust where it belongs if the case isn’t solid enough to see through a ‘con’ then.

There is still something I don’t like about it, even though I can tease it out to this point.

19 hours ago, merjet said:

In the real world, there are many conflicts of interest as described here. One can ask, are there some questions worth asking about them? Or one can dismiss them because Ayn Rand had nothing to say about them.

Let us take this opportunity to discuss the metaphilosophical issues confronting the way you are required to do philosophy, before I turn to my usual dismissiveness. And yes I am choosing my words purposefully, philosophy is normative and has requirements. You are required (in the sense that you can be held to it) to do (at minimum) alternatively 1-7 below in order to do philosophy well. If I turn in a paper that doesn’t follow these methods (among others), I get a bad grade. (This list is not intended be exhaustive.)

In the OP, ET says he “can’t integrate” the conflicts of interest idea. Weirdly, I presume he’s talking about Rand’s philosophy. Philosophy assignments generally ask you to consider some thesis, usually a thesis or argument that has been presented by another philosopher. Given the thesis or argument of the philosopher being presented, you may be asked to:

  1. Explain what the thesis is, to include what the philosopher means by the relevant terms and concepts used by the philosopher in the text.

  2. Offer an argument in support of the it.

  3. Offer an objection to it.

  4. Defend the argument against an objection.

  5. Evaluate whether the thesis succeeds, or arguments and concepts employed make sense or are valid.

  6. Discuss the consequences of accepting or rejection the thesis.

  7. Determine what other positions or concepts might commit one to it, or be held consistent with it. 

Sometimes you may be asked to complete only some of these tasks. One could do 2 without doing 3-7. But no matter which of 2-7 one is attempting to do, one has to meet 1 as a structural requirement, because failing to understand a text, and reading into it one’s own meaning is called the fallacy of equivocation. If I don’t demonstrate 1, to include being precise with what the philosopher I’m analyzing’s meaning is (and sharply differentiate it from what my own version or meaning of terms may be), my paper gets rejected and I have to redo it.

An example of good philosophy would be something like this:

You are tasked to evaluate Smith’s argument in the Treatise on Free Will that people lack free will. At the beginning of your paper you state something like: In this paper, I will refute Smith’s argument against the existence of free will. I will counter what I will call Smith’s “argument from chance” by showing that indeterminism does not mean mental acts are random. I will analyze and clarify several concepts, including necessity and possibility, chance or randomness, and determinism and indeterminism.

All of this requires that you show that you understand what Smith means when Smith uses a term and don’t substitute your own meaning and then judge Smith by that meaning. If you did that, your paper would be returned and you would have to redo it. You, of course, may disagree with Smith’s usage of terms, or the way he conceptualizes things. But you have to demonstrate that you know, in the first place, what he means by the terms, and then in the second place you use arguments to show why your usage is better. You can’t just assert things. If you do that, your paper is returned.

Now it is certainly true that one studies philosophy not merely to find out what philosophers have said, but to get to the truth of the matter. But one will not get to the truth of the matter through poor reasoning. Of course there are a vast number of questions one can ask about conflicts of interest, or about any one given aspect, say what our interests are, or in what sense conflict is meant. And Rand is just one philosopher talking about this and has a certain way of looking at it. I don’t take anything she’s saying as an exhaustive treatment either.

ET or others can clarify what his/their questions may be. But I take it we’re discussing Rand’s chapter 4 of VOS. And since she isn’t talking about financial conflicts, principal-agent conflicts, conflicts of opinion or conclusion, then those things won’t help us understand her thesis, and thus makes evaluating it impossible. She uses “interest” unequivocally to describe the scope of one’s good or wellbeing in life. We know this because she uses the term “interest” in a specific way throughout her writing, especially in the introduction to that very same book. It may be, for example, that there could be “financial conflicts of interest” and not a conflict “amongst rational men” in Rand’s sense. Or it may be that there are conflicts of good-interests, but not conflicts of opinion-interests. Merely raising the question will not do. You have to show your work. And obviously this is not a paper and no one is trying to write a dissertation on here. But just as a paper differs from a dissertation, yet still follows the requirements of good reasoning, so a forum post differs from a paper, but still must follow the requirements of good philosophy writing. So while one would not be expected to reproduce a paper, the form or structure of the method or approach should be the same.

Thing is, I don’t think Merlin knows anything about 1-7, mainly because he’s not that good or smart. Most of his posts are a smattering of isolated assertions without argument, or question begging framing. Most can resolve to “begging all of the relevant questions and adopting my entire framework, that’s is not how X, Y, or Z works in the real world, bucko.” Well, no shit.

I pointed this out too with his discussion of Rand’s egoism. He basically says, I’m going to interpret statement P as X. Well what about all this preponderance of statements that seem to support not-X, but Y. Well I’m going to interpret it however I want, what are you some dogmatist not willing to look outside of Y? Unfortunately, this is the fallacy of equivocation and bad scholarship. 

So, to that, I will paraphrase a quotation from Thomas Reid: It is as useless to argue about some proposition in geometry with someone who rejects the axioms of geometry as it is with a man that believes he is made of glass. Such a person who will not grant the requirements of good reasoning is unfit to be reasoned with.

On 10/6/2020 at 10:43 AM, Eiuol said:

It’s not really that rational thought prevents all conflict, but that rational thought tells us that “conflicts of interest” don’t exist in any genuine sense. I’m just checking though, by all conflict, do you mean even preventing conflict with irrational people? I didn’t think you did, but I’m not sure.

Any conflict of interest between rational people would not exist.

Translates to “all” conflict of interest would be eliminated. (so not including irrational people except that … irrationality is part of the most rational amongst us )

I’m trying to make your explanation convince me, but there is an immediate emotional reaction like: This is a dangerous idea, telling everyone to be rational so that we don’t have any more conflicts (about what we should want) … ever.

But as 2046 says, if we took all contexts into account, then yes, I would agree that we would eliminate conflict of interest.

But we won’t always take all contexts in mind even if we took an oath to rationality (in any genuine sense). If we were Vulcan’s, maybe. Or if Harry Potter gave us the right incantation to use, sure.

 

8 hours ago, 2046 said:

Let us take this opportunity to discuss the metaphilosophical issues confronting the way you are required to do philosophy, before I turn to my usual dismissiveness.

You got the part after the comma right, along with resorting to plenty of ad hominem.

 

8 hours ago, 2046 said:

Thing is, I don’t think Merlin knows anything about 1-7, mainly because he’s not that good or smart.

Thing is, 2046 failed to acknowledge that my previous posts met 1-7, likely because he’s not that good or smart or honest. “He is free to evade reality, he is free to unfocus his mind and stumble blindly down any road he pleases, but not free to avoid the abyss he refuses to see.” - Ayn Rand

2 hours ago, merjet said:

2046 failed to acknowledge that my previous posts met 1-7

That’s just the thing. You really believe your posts at least met 1, but they didn’t. And unfortunately, you felt insulted when you were told that your reasoning sucks. Do you want to have a better discussion, or do you prefer to insist on discussing things the same way?

ET, I don’t see any issue with saying that there would be “no more” conflicts of interest between rational people, mostly because the conflicts of interest don’t actually exist in the first place. It’s not that they go away, it’s that people realize they were never there in the first place. As was mentioned before, you may initially get the impression that a conflict of interest exists with another rational person. All you have to do is pause for a moment, and reflect on the situation. Maybe even consider that you were the irrational person. We can get into some of Swig’s ideas if you’d like, but to me those are more about why it’s difficult to figure out how to evaluate everything correctly. 

1 Like

1 hour ago, Eiuol said:

All you have to do is pause for a moment, and reflect on the situation. Maybe even consider that you were the irrational person.

I would say that Merjet and 2046 are having a “conflict of interest”. And these are two highly rational people.

The disagreement is about “the best way of interacting that we should want”.
I’m replacing the word interest with “the best way of interacting that we should want” to see if that will make a difference.

Both are okay with attacking each other personally.

Now, one way or the other, if they disengage, the answer to the question will not be discovered (sooner or ever). Yet, “when an interaction hurts, one should leave” is in fact a “good way of interacting”.
In other words “each person should take care of themselves” is in fact easily proven to be the best way of interacting.
But the answer to the question will be gone or delayed. 
So then one could argue that “not hurting others is a better way” because I will gain the answer faster.

This is the complexity that I see muddying the water. As Branden would say (paraphrasing), when there are high emotions, irrationality will appear. Which means the best practice is to let the emotional dust settle and then try again.
But in the heat of the moment, in midst of an emotional storm, free will may be limited.

2 hours ago, Easy Truth said:

I would say that Merjet and 2046 are having a “conflict of interest”.

I say we are having a dispute about the meaning of “conflict of interest.” 2046 insists the only one worthy of discussing is what Ayn Rand meant by it. I disagree. 

16 minutes ago, merjet said:

I say we are having a dispute about the meaning of “conflict of interest.” 2046 insists the only one worthy of discussing is what Ayn Rand meant by it. I disagree. 

You need me to believe that to maintain your worldview

5 minutes ago, 2046 said:

You need me to believe that to maintain your worldview

What you believe has absolutely nothing to do with my worldview.

4 hours ago, Easy Truth said:

I would say that Merjet and 2046 are having a “conflict of interest”. And these are two highly rational people.

The disagreement is about “the best way of interacting that we should want”.
I’m replacing the word interest with “the best way of interacting that we should want” to see if that will make a difference.

Both are okay with attacking each other personally.

Now, one way or the other, if they disengage, the answer to the question will not be discovered (sooner or ever). Yet, “when an interaction hurts, one should leave” is in fact a “good way of interacting”.
In other words “each person should take care of themselves” is in fact easily proven to be the best way of interacting.
But the answer to the question will be gone or delayed. 
So then one could argue that “not hurting others is a better way” because I will gain the answer faster.

This is the complexity that I see muddying the water. As Branden would say (paraphrasing), when there are high emotions, irrationality will appear. Which means the best practice is to let the emotional dust settle and then try again.
But in the heat of the moment, in midst of an emotional storm, free will may be limited.

Maybe this will actually help provide clarity. I don’t think we’re having a conflict of interest, at least not in Rand’s sense. I take Rand’s sense of interest from the VOS introduction and “The Objectivist Ethics” to refer to ones good as a human being. (Or more precisely, to refer to the scope of one’s good.) I take this because she uses self-interest and selfishness interchangeably (or as selfishness as concern for ones own interest), and refers to them as “the values required for man’s survival qua man.”

I don’t think my good and Merlin’s good are in conflict. We don’t have to agree to pursue our good. This because we have different goods. If you think our natural or ultimate end is something like a “dominant end” where Merlin and 2046 are merely loci in such a good, then if we have different conclusions about what that is, we might be said to conflict. But if you think of our ultimate end as an “inclusive end” that is only made real through our individualized natures, it’s possible to understand the form of my “survival qua man” and Merlin’s “survival qua man” to be particularized in different ways. So Merlin and I don’t have to agree to not be in goods-conflict. Opinion-conflict is distinct from that.

Also, were not “interacting” strictly speaking. (interaction here, I mean act in some way whereby we must have some effect on the other.) And our disagreement over some thesis, or over what methods one should take in considering a thesis, has nothing to do whether or not I think, say Person A, B, or C is not a high-quality philosophy writer, or person in general. Or at least they are disjunctive with such things. And that is perfectly normal and healthy. In fact, I think 99% of the people that post on here are roughly as low-quality as Merlin’s posts are. That’s just part of internet intellectual junk-food. But I do think my posts about method can be helpful to some people, even if they don’t like me or think I’m a jerk. Which is also perfectly reasonable.

But I think this relates to the bit about “in a free society” that Swig brought up. She does seem to qualify the whole discussion, that her thesis only applies to a free society. I take it she means something like the following: Merlin and I can just dismiss each other, each one thinking the other is silly, in a free society. A free society is based on individual rights, including private property rights. And part of private property rights is that people aren’t forced to interact, because they can draw a boundary around each. Respect for boundaries is a solution for conflict. Thus, in a free society, a solution to every potential goods-conflict exists: each person can ignore the other and go their own way (see last paragraph in the chapter.)

What’s interesting is she says “no interests are possible” in an unfree society. I’m not sure what she means by this. Presumably, the initiation of force makes human flourishing impossible, is her point in We the Living and so forth. But that’s a really authoritarian regime? What about a semi-free society? She doesn’t really address those questions. I think one could use examples of a limited kind of flourishing people are able to achieve in places like even gulags and prisons to argue against the idea that “no interests are possible.” The case of Admiral James Stockdale provides an interesting example. But I take it that her point is that if Merlin and I were forced to interact, now we have a zero-sum game where our goods are both diminished, at least compared to us just going our own ways, or if one or the other just didn’t exist.

1 Like

1 hour ago, merjet said:

2046 insists the only one worthy of discussing is what Ayn Rand meant by it. I disagree. 

I mean, you’ve been asked a few times exactly why you have a different view. You began the discussion by suggesting that Rand didn’t understand the “common meaning”, and/or was really only talking about something trivial, so you gave examples that you thought would easily make us call into question what she was talking about in her essay. So people corrected you that you were missing the point, or were misinterpreting her, or otherwise not reading her essay carefully. Fair enough. Then you gave a hypothetical. Great. But when you were given analysis, you were combative, didn’t answer clarifying questions, even going as far as to say it was impossible to demonstrate that your example was a conflict of interest among rational people. Then went back to repeating your first post, and accusing 2046 of refusing to talk about what anyone else means by conflict of interest (need I remind you that the whole thread is about what Rand meant?). But you yourself refused to answer what you meant by conflict of interest when I asked why you thought you thought experiment demonstrated a conflict of interest! 

4 hours ago, Easy Truth said:

I would say that Merjet and 2046 are having a “conflict of interest”. And these are two highly rational people.

Just for looking at things carefully, we can see that Merjet has failed to be rational. Is he rational most the time? Maybe. It’s not as if Rand was saying that normally rational people will never fail to be rational. When they fail to be rational, they will see what they believe to be conflicts of interest, and probably think they are being rational at the time. Merjet might believe that here, it is in his interest to argue as he has so far. Arguing in a manner that other people think is poor form. The conflict of interest would be that 2046’s interest is to argue in a relatively precise and academic way, but also by introducing other information that we can clarify our own thinking or find a point to argue with, while Merjet’s interest is trying to argue about this other meaning of conflict of interest, without meeting the context of the original question, and focusing on a particular narrow dispute about definitions.

A way to resolve this of course is Merjet to admit some error and that 2046 has a better way, or at least admit that a different course of discussion is better. Unless of course his wider interest is just to “win the argument”, in which case the conflict of interest remains. Getting to the truth is the rational course of action. That might take some time, but in either case, we know that getting at the truth can and should be a mutual interest here. When we realize that, we also realize that there actually is no genuine conflict of interest exists if we hold rational interests. 

4 hours ago, Easy Truth said:

Now, one way or the other, if they disengage, the answer to the question will not be discovered (sooner or ever).

The difficult thing might be figuring out the difference between irrational and not smart enough. If somebody is having a bad day, and you just need to engage them tomorrow when things settle down, that’s a case of irrationality. Sometimes a person is characteristically irrational, and they will routinely use appeals to emotions, or threats, or lies. Other times, neither applies because the person is not capable of understanding the concepts in question. It doesn’t matter how patient you are with them, they just won’t get it, no arguments will sink in, and you’ll actually look stupid in their eyes precisely because what you say doesn’t make any sense. Or could go the other way, that you’re the one who is not smart enough to understand.

Imagine a chess grandmaster against an amateur chess player. The chess grandmaster thinks on such a higher level that they simply do not compare. The amateur chess player is not even capable of understanding what the grandmaster does except at the very basic level of how the pieces move. I’m not saying that the amateur is stupid about everything, I only mean stupid about chess. The same can apply to philosophical arguments, or anything else in life. Even then, general intelligence is somewhat of a thing, or at least several related measures. There might be a minimum level of intelligence someone needs to be able to comprehend certain ideas. It wouldn’t matter how rational they are. Can everyone understand the mathematics of quantum physics? I don’t think so. 

 

 

1 Like

43 minutes ago, Eiuol said:

Rand didn’t understand the “common meaning”, and/or was really only talking about something trivial

This is another good point. I have a bit of a soft spot for the ordinary language school. I think it’s a perfectly reasonable question to ask whether the everyday common sense usage of “conflicts of interest” comports with the meaning Rand employs here. And if it does not (which it definitely doesn’t) what motivates our moving from the one usage to the other?

And the answer to that lies in the answer to the question: why does Rand need there to be no conflicts of interest? What work is this doing in her overall system? I mean what’s the cash value of the thing? Suppose she’s wrong, sometimes my good will just conflict with other people’s, and that’s just a pervasive fact of reality? So what?

I think she needs it due to her political philosophy. She needs a free society that does not, at least structurally, prejudice some people’s good over others. And she needs that because she needs it to be entirely up to you whether or not your good is achieved. That’s why taking a wider view of the context of your interests refocuses you on what’s in your control vs not. That’s why the ending is not weird or odd that she take it to politics at the end of the day. (What’s weird to me is that she gives it two sentences and ends right there.)

1 Like

The Principle of Two Definitions, From Leonard Peikoff’s course: Unity in Epistemology and Ethics

Transitioning from a  colloquial usage of “conflict of interest” to a particular application under a particular philosophic context would benefit from identifying and understanding the process. Peikoff laid some groundwork in this talk starting with “value” as his first example.

After identifying the purpose that a lawyer defending a client he knows is a criminal could serve in a free society, the onus of remaining free lies with those who desire it. Just as in 1776, maybe a third of the citizen bought the gift of liberty by grasping the intellectual foundations and implementing it politically. As long as no rights are violated, the described lawyer is providing a value to his client.

Those desiring the objective administration of justice would find it in their own selfish interest to discover and establish a method of maintaining quality control in its implementation.