19 hours ago, merjet said:
In the real world, there are many conflicts of interest as described here. One can ask, are there some questions worth asking about them? Or one can dismiss them because Ayn Rand had nothing to say about them.
Let us take this opportunity to discuss the metaphilosophical issues confronting the way you are required to do philosophy, before I turn to my usual dismissiveness. And yes I am choosing my words purposefully, philosophy is normative and has requirements. You are required (in the sense that you can be held to it) to do (at minimum) alternatively 1-7 below in order to do philosophy well. If I turn in a paper that doesn’t follow these methods (among others), I get a bad grade. (This list is not intended be exhaustive.)
In the OP, ET says he “can’t integrate” the conflicts of interest idea. Weirdly, I presume he’s talking about Rand’s philosophy. Philosophy assignments generally ask you to consider some thesis, usually a thesis or argument that has been presented by another philosopher. Given the thesis or argument of the philosopher being presented, you may be asked to:
-
Explain what the thesis is, to include what the philosopher means by the relevant terms and concepts used by the philosopher in the text.
-
Offer an argument in support of the it.
-
Offer an objection to it.
-
Defend the argument against an objection.
-
Evaluate whether the thesis succeeds, or arguments and concepts employed make sense or are valid.
-
Discuss the consequences of accepting or rejection the thesis.
-
Determine what other positions or concepts might commit one to it, or be held consistent with it.
Sometimes you may be asked to complete only some of these tasks. One could do 2 without doing 3-7. But no matter which of 2-7 one is attempting to do, one has to meet 1 as a structural requirement, because failing to understand a text, and reading into it one’s own meaning is called the fallacy of equivocation. If I don’t demonstrate 1, to include being precise with what the philosopher I’m analyzing’s meaning is (and sharply differentiate it from what my own version or meaning of terms may be), my paper gets rejected and I have to redo it.
An example of good philosophy would be something like this:
You are tasked to evaluate Smith’s argument in the Treatise on Free Will that people lack free will. At the beginning of your paper you state something like: In this paper, I will refute Smith’s argument against the existence of free will. I will counter what I will call Smith’s “argument from chance” by showing that indeterminism does not mean mental acts are random. I will analyze and clarify several concepts, including necessity and possibility, chance or randomness, and determinism and indeterminism.
All of this requires that you show that you understand what Smith means when Smith uses a term and don’t substitute your own meaning and then judge Smith by that meaning. If you did that, your paper would be returned and you would have to redo it. You, of course, may disagree with Smith’s usage of terms, or the way he conceptualizes things. But you have to demonstrate that you know, in the first place, what he means by the terms, and then in the second place you use arguments to show why your usage is better. You can’t just assert things. If you do that, your paper is returned.
Now it is certainly true that one studies philosophy not merely to find out what philosophers have said, but to get to the truth of the matter. But one will not get to the truth of the matter through poor reasoning. Of course there are a vast number of questions one can ask about conflicts of interest, or about any one given aspect, say what our interests are, or in what sense conflict is meant. And Rand is just one philosopher talking about this and has a certain way of looking at it. I don’t take anything she’s saying as an exhaustive treatment either.
ET or others can clarify what his/their questions may be. But I take it we’re discussing Rand’s chapter 4 of VOS. And since she isn’t talking about financial conflicts, principal-agent conflicts, conflicts of opinion or conclusion, then those things won’t help us understand her thesis, and thus makes evaluating it impossible. She uses “interest” unequivocally to describe the scope of one’s good or wellbeing in life. We know this because she uses the term “interest” in a specific way throughout her writing, especially in the introduction to that very same book. It may be, for example, that there could be “financial conflicts of interest” and not a conflict “amongst rational men” in Rand’s sense. Or it may be that there are conflicts of good-interests, but not conflicts of opinion-interests. Merely raising the question will not do. You have to show your work. And obviously this is not a paper and no one is trying to write a dissertation on here. But just as a paper differs from a dissertation, yet still follows the requirements of good reasoning, so a forum post differs from a paper, but still must follow the requirements of good philosophy writing. So while one would not be expected to reproduce a paper, the form or structure of the method or approach should be the same.
Thing is, I don’t think Merlin knows anything about 1-7, mainly because he’s not that good or smart. Most of his posts are a smattering of isolated assertions without argument, or question begging framing. Most can resolve to “begging all of the relevant questions and adopting my entire framework, that’s is not how X, Y, or Z works in the real world, bucko.” Well, no shit.
I pointed this out too with his discussion of Rand’s egoism. He basically says, I’m going to interpret statement P as X. Well what about all this preponderance of statements that seem to support not-X, but Y. Well I’m going to interpret it however I want, what are you some dogmatist not willing to look outside of Y? Unfortunately, this is the fallacy of equivocation and bad scholarship.
So, to that, I will paraphrase a quotation from Thomas Reid: It is as useless to argue about some proposition in geometry with someone who rejects the axioms of geometry as it is with a man that believes he is made of glass. Such a person who will not grant the requirements of good reasoning is unfit to be reasoned with.