The scare quotes don’t answer the obvious question, though: are those self-styled libertarian anarchists libertarians or not? If they aren’t, then why don’t the ‘mainstream’ libertarians firmly denounce them for trying to hijack their movement?
They do. The history of the libertarian movement is full of factional disputes as bitter as any between ARI and TOC, over this and other issues.
Personally, I recommend that people who think the Libertarians are useful allies in the defense of liberty start attending meetings of their local party affiliates. That’s what I did, and what I saw there put me off the LP forever. If they’re our best defense of liberty, then I’m off to buy my jackboots because I know which side is going to win.
If by this you mean that the Libertarian Party has little hope of ever getting more than lunatic-fringe vote totals, I sadly agree. (Here in Orange County, CA, a special Congressional election yesterday generated 880 votes for the LP candidate. . . and 1242 for the Green Party!)
However, I don’t see Objectivists exerting any significant influence on the political process or the wider culture either. I take no pleasure in this observation; I fervently wish it were otherwise.
They do. The history of the libertarian movement is full of factional disputes as bitter as any between ARI and TOC, over this and other issues.
I’ll just say this doesn’t match my own observations of Libertarian events and party documents. The events I’ve attended were well-supplied with anarchists who seemed to feel quite at home, and the LP platform and remarks on the issue by the LP candidate in 1996 and 2000 seemed designed to sweep the issue under the table rather than show the anarchists to the door. It’s possible the party has improved on this since I last paid serious attention to it, but I doubt it.
However, I don’t see Objectivists exerting any significant influence on the political process or the wider culture either. I take no pleasure in this observation; I fervently wish it were otherwise.
It’s still early days, frankly. But there is a lot more going on now than there was, say, ten years ago.
Not long ago, Objectivist ideas were impossible to find in the media. Today millions of people see ARI spokespeople interviewed on TV news programs each year, and millions more read ARI op-ed pieces. Objectivist penetration of academia is proceeding more rapidly than I’ve ever seen, largely due to the good works of the OAC and the Anthem Foundation. There is a Fortune 500 company with an Objectivist CEO, who was once asked by Republican party leaders to consider a run for governor of North Carolina. (He declined.) The annual budget of the Ayn Rand Institute is currently larger than the annual budget of the Christian Coalition. (Granted, that’s because the CC has imploded, but it’s amusing nonetheless.)
We’re a long way from a majority, and I expect things will get worse before they get better. Nevertheless, I do think we are making progress.