I should point out Alex Epstein is not active in the health fields, he is pushing back on the tide of ecoterrorism (in the guise of science and government “taking care of us”) attempting to hold the people of the world hostage.
Two other efforts that tend to be pushing in the right general direction. Jason Crawford has familiarity with Objectivism, while Human Progress holds a more benevolent sense of life approach per my esteem.
Neither are heath centric, though both might deal with it if it fell under their proposed umbrellas.
Wouldn’t it be better to get some evidence about the particular study or authors, rather than just making an assumption?
If I see that Lancet editorial staff has resigned , I’ll read the next Covid centric study by the Imperial College of London they publish.
But until then, there are multiple other sources of information and dismissing out of hand information from provably inaccurate sources is a time saver.
But until then, there are multiple other sources of information and dismissing out of hand information from provably inaccurate sources is a time saver.
You should share some of these other sources; their bottom line numbers and how they got them would be nice. I had been simply curious how many lives were estimated to have been saved by preventative measures that were taken against this contagious disease. And the links I shared here were simply what came up in the google.
I should mention that information provided for our own community here in Lynchburg—tracking the number of new cases, new deaths, and available ICU at our hospital—were useful to us in the decisions we made to protect ourselves during the pandemic. We are old and retired. We stopped going to the gym for many months. Many members did not renew their membership during that time. My husband did not leave home, as he has severe COPD. The Governor came around to closing gyms for several months. We have returned now, and we follow the routine of wiping down the contact points, even though we all know it was found that spread of that virus was mainly airborne, not contact. We continue that simply because it's a good habit, for other disease transmission, protective of self and others.
The "individualist" refusal to wear masks in our local grocery store during the pandemic reminded me of back when the AIDS pandemic was going on. Within the libertarian political press there was promotion of Dr. Duesberg's conjecture that AIDS was not caused by HIV (but by other factors such as poor diet, partying all night, running oneself down by taking "recreational" drugs, and assault of AZT [the only anti-HIV med at the time] on the body; stop doing those things and the whole problem will go away). This press was plainly not motivated by providing me with good advice on what I should do. It was motivated by politics, especially government-research expense. It was implausible to the educated on its face and morally obscene. People who could have had an eventual chance of being rescued died on regular schedule from taking such advice. I did not take that advice. I spat on it. I followed the information in my _Scientific American_ and the advice of my doctor (a scientific guy) and Dr. Fauci and his agency. Those researches and drug developments saved my life and preserve it to the present. (By the way, a vaccine has never been found for that virus; nature is a giant.)
I doubt there is any government program whatever that cannot be twisted into part of a design to control the lives of the citizens and curtail their freedom—from providing for the common defense to building interstate highways. I have property rights in my acreage. That is a bundle of specific rights. I have a right to fell any timber on our place that I please. I have a right against others felling them without my consent. I do not have a right to burn leaves under all wind conditions. That last is not an attempt by law to become master of my life. That thought is ridiculous, and if one believes that sort of thing, one needs to get a grip. Neither is it plausible that some despot in the future is going to come along and use the leaf-burning constraints to snuff my free life.
"Man—every man—is an end in himself . . . ." That is not, logically, in Rand's ethical system only the pylon for the moral rightness of self-interested action, but for respecting ends-in-themselves that are other people. Jackassery "individualism" is not helpful to the cause of constraining government in the big ways it infringes the rights of individuals. Providing for the common defense has passed, starting at least with FDR, on to protecting people from hurricanes and epidemics. And there is a regularization of the extensions as time goes by: Goldwater denounced Medicare and Social Security as socialism; Trump said no, only the Obama-Care addition was socialism. I suggest that what is horribly wrong are the massive outlays without adequate revenues and the ways in which government can take over particular lives seriously such as was done by the military draft or, less drastically, by wage and price controls or by denying people the right to go to work or keep the firm open during the pandemic—rather than letting our citizens volunteer to save their country or save others against totalitarianism in the war or letting them make their own decision on whether to stop going to work or school during the pandemic (thereby putting the blames for untoward consequences on nature, rather than on government).
The idea put about these days that every ill impact of government action on one's cherished freedoms is the main and evil objective of people behind the policy action is egocentric, subjectivist, and false. All over our acreage every year all the plants and all the animals are behaving as if their species was trying to take over the world, but there is no such intention; they have no such broad intentions or any intentions at all. Personifying cumulative bad results from our organized collective action that is the US government and writing a fiction of that evil personage is intellectually lazy and does not help in tuning to reality.
I do not have a right to burn leaves under all wind conditions. That last is not an attempt by law to become master of my life. That thought is ridiculous, and if one believes that sort of thing, one needs to get a grip. Neither is it plausible that some despot in the future is going to come along and use the leaf-burning constraints to snuff my free life.
If you obey the laws of nature, are these laws the master of your rights? (that was metaphorical but helps in making my point)
The law should protect your rights and everyone else’s rights. No one is being subjugated when a neighbor objects to you burning leaves when the situation is incendiary. The neighbor has a right to their property too. Protection of their rights is not the same as a government supporting your subjugation or slavery. And the idea that a supporter of individual rights wants to burn leaves whenever they want is simply a smear. A person who is not aware of anyone else’s rights can’t be aware of their own, it’s a description of a sociopath. Such a person is anti social and incapable of trade. That does not describe what an individualist is.
1 hour ago, Boydstun said:
Personifying cumulative bad results from our organized collective action that is the US government and writing a fiction of that evil personage is intellectually lazy and does not help in tuning to reality.
True enough. But the current way of governing is out of control as you would agree. The exact source or solution is nuanced and confusing. But at it’s core, treating innocents like they are guilty is a key indicator of evil.
Clicking on the article I didn’t see or could not easily find their methodology , I’d like to see how these studies determine counterfactuals based on their methods of estimation. Like, what r values did they use and or how that may compare historically with changes in the infection rate during a ‘normal’ viral infection course. And things like their findings/estimates being expressed in absolute risk vs relative risk statistics.
For me a strike against their scientific rigor is the groups firm commitment to antiracism practices , equitable healthcare solutions and public health policy seemingly leaving evidence based research as secondary.
I don’t know what weight to give the circumstance that the organization has a variety of social aspirations. Strictly speaking, it would seem falling into the circumstantial ad hominem fallacy to give that any weight not zero. Be that as it may, I think what could have most bearing on any slanting in this particular data would be a desire that people get vaccinated for this contagious disease and for contagious diseases more generally. Or anyway, that leaders not try to sabotage this effort.
As far as the merit of THAT social aspiration goes, I think it is fine. When I was a child in the 1950’s, we got various vaccinations in school, including vaccination against polio. I don’t recall my folks having any objection to it. As an adult, were I a parent of a schoolchild, I’d want them to have any vaccination our doctor thought good. Were there some sort of legal requirement (at what penalty?) to have schoolchildren vaccinated, I would not count it as a compulsion since I would want it to happen anyway. With respect to the Covid vaccines, I’ve not felt under any legal compulsion to get vaccinations, and I’ve not invested any time to learn whether there is any legal requirement for me to do so, because I simply wanted the vaccination, the sooner the better.
Stephen, I was offering my opinion of the weight I would give a study that purports to show the safety and effectiveness of the mRNA covid shots in general and by this specific group given their mission statement.
As a layperson my understanding of virology leads me to believe that ‘dead virus’ vaccines are the type I’m most comfortable getting for myself or my children. I expressed my concerns with the covid shots as they were available to my adult son and so far he holds the same estimation or at least has not yet been pressured to ‘just get one’ because x,y,z action would be ‘easier’ ie travel or job opportunity. My adult daughter is profoundly physically and mentally disabled and the risks of the experimental injections out weighed any advantage they might confer, advantages I’ve have yet to see clearly defined. My wife and I agreed that she would not be innoculated with mRNA platform covid jabs. When they were both school age children we followed the recommended vaccine schedules for their respective groups, and as our daughter aged she was required to have annual flu shots for participation in her daily adult care programs.
Aside from discussions of specific examples of scientific rigor, my point is to show the influence of ‘publishing’ as such and the propaganda surrounding all things Covid.
The all cause excess morality in the western world is running around 10% higher than the five year average for the last two years. No death ticker on CNN, FOX, or MSNBC .
tadmjones link is to a 9 minute video of Dr. john Campbell pointing out that excess deaths across the world remain high. In the UK, where he is, it is 9.4% above normal.
All cause excess death still above the five year average in most western countries , virtually no media stories as to any possible theories on cause/s. Blank out, mass evasion of reality.
All cause excess death still above the five year average in most western countries , virtually no media stories as to any possible theories on cause/s. Blank out, mass evasion of reality.
Could it be because there are still a lot of people dying from covid-19?
Could it be because there are still a lot of people dying from covid-19?
Nope, ‘all cause’ , I think deaths attributed to covid or covid adjacent deaths are in the lower single digit range , maybe 2 percent range. Who is dying ‘of covid’?