On 11/21/2022 at 2:51 PM, Boydstun said:
Lancet estimates of lives saved by Covid vaccines
Lockdowns saved lives, but not a go-to strategy moving forward
I wonder how a proper Objectivist would report on the data, but I propose the following:
It would be 100% fact based, no shred of anything for a. personal financial gain b. political gain c. institutional or political reputation or d. with the intent to cajole or persuade people to any so called desired behavior i.e. no social engineering of sentiment or action of any kind.
It would look at medical interactions in society from the individual’s perspective, and individual rights, the individual’s freedom, health, and very lives. This is in many senses opposite to the so-called “public good” of public health approaches. I.e. the data would be looked at in the sense of treating individuals, how individual people fared, their health, their freedoms, their mental well being etc. not merely the so-called health of a collective… using who knows what as statistical standards. A herd which is “treated” and “managed” be said to be more healthy, even when enslaved, or if part of the heard are disadvantaged or sacrificed (culled) for the sake of the collective whole. Herd mentality is not how an Objectivist would think of it or deal with it. Sacrifice of the innocent for NO MATTER HOW MANY other individuals IS EVIL.
Lives saved?
I wonder if anyone has done the analysis thusly:
How many people under the age of 50, how many CHILDREN would have died or suffered irreparably educationally, physically, mentally, had nothing been done, no vaccines, no imprisonment, no mandates, no muzzling.
Then how many were affected because of the measures taken.
Then doing the same for people over the age of 50, no measures… versus measures taken.
I wonder whether in the end, in the pursuit of sheer numbers of “survivors”, many of the young with their whole lives ahead of them have been brought low and in some cases died for no good reason. That whole lives were sacrificed on the altar of public good in return for survivability of the very old, good numbers, and political and institutional reputation.
I have said it before, if you ask your doctor whether any proposed action is better for yourself (or your child) PERSONALLY, given all possible benefit and risks, and he/she hesitates or looks confused… THAT is no doctor, that is an agent of the State who has forsaken the sacred duty to treat you PERSONALLY for your benefit, for your life and health… and you should find yourself a new doctor as fast as possible.
You see, no matter how mundane and saccharine and academically philosophical the trolley problem seems, its purported utilitarian or arithmetical solution we now see in full. For the herd, all that really matters are the numbers, whether one arrived at it by sacrificing innocents is beside the fact… the so-called public good has nothing to do with individuals… the greatest “number” of survivors.
I believe Rand solved the “trolley problem” with the idea of every person being an end in himself, which already requires no purposeful act to cause the sacrifice of anyone, much less children, who knew no better, some of whom (those so called “rare” few) died because of it.
Public health is inimical to individual rights and is an evil, as evil as any of the other proposed Globalist, centrally planned erosions of our freedoms, or what is left of them.
I am ashamed most prominent Objectivists are going along for the ride with not so much as a peep.
The only brave and outspoken Objectivist pushing back on the madness I can think of currently, is Alex Epstein.