Deriving Ethics from Reality

Not a paralegal. Columbia Law alum and practicing attorney.

If I say X knowing that it will induce Y actions, Y is what is important to me. Truth and lie are less important concepts to me than the responses that the stimuli will produce. Of course, everyone knows the story of the “Boy Who Cried Wolf.” Saying things that are perceived as untrue tends to get you ignored when you say things.

@Grames: I’ve already discussed my understanding of axiom above as an assumption that an abstract argument relies upon. If Objectivism has a specialized definition, I wasn’t aware of it. Could you please quote and cite any specialized definition for me?

This is an important item to be unaware of, so I infer from this that your study of Rand and Objectivism is not near completed. I hope you continue your readings and study.

Ayn Rand contested the justification of traditional fundamental philosophical issues and even the justification of methods of justification. In order to sort out an issue she usually had to re-conceptualize the elements involved, and had to come up with a method of forming valid, justified concepts. Introduction to Objectivist Epistemology (ITOE) is the key work to study in order to understand Rand. The Ayn Rand Lexicon is useful as a compilation of her definitions and arguments on many topics.

Anaxiom is a proposition in which the subject and predicate are axiomatic concepts. Axiomatic concepts are:

An axiomatic concept is the identification of a primary fact of reality, which cannot be analyzed, i.e., reduced to other facts or broken into component parts. It is implicit in all facts and in all knowledge. It is the fundamentally given and directly perceived or experienced, which requires no proof or explanation, but on which all proofs and explanations rest.

The first and primary axiomatic concepts are “existence,” “identity” (which is a corollary of “existence”) and “consciousness.” One can study what exists and how consciousness functions; but one cannot analyze (or “prove”) existence as such, or consciousness as such. These are irreducible primaries. (An attempt to “prove” them is self-contradictory: it is an attempt to “prove” existence by means of non-existence, and consciousness by means of unconsciousness.)

This then leaves axioms as:

An axiom is a statement that identifies the base of knowledge and of any further statement pertaining to that knowledge, a statement necessarily contained in all others, whether any particular speaker chooses to identify it or not. An axiom is a proposition that defeats its opponents by the fact that they have to accept it and use it in the process of any attempt to deny it.

On the issue of reality, what you’re saying is true but I think it misses my point. What I am discussing is the usefulness of living on the razor’s edge of the intersection between myself and the outside world. Everything outside of me is stimulus for me to choose how to react to. How that stimulus filters into my brain is my reality. I can’t perceive “objective” reality in the sense that you mean it. You have set it up as something fundamentally distinct from my subjective experience. In order to separate these two things you must rely on the false concept that humans are fundamentally flawed and imperfect. In order for “objective reality” to have meaning to me, I have to accept that my perception is inherently inferior to something greater outside me. I don’t understand why I would do that.

Because it is a truth that human knowledge is fundamentally finite and fallible. This is not that same as saying flawed, because being finite is a necessity imposed by the law of identity while being fallible is self evident and sometimes an unavoidable consequence of the finiteness of human understanding. Omniscience and infallibility are varieties of infinity and so we know they contradict the law of identity.

On the issue of memory: this depends on how you define memory. I would bet most people define memory as an internal verbal narrative. I would define my memory of my past as what is implied by my current actions, not as defined by something as highly inaccurate as an internal verbal narrative. My real memory is integrated into my understanding, instincts, and skills. It does not rely on imprecise language. When I construct a narrative about what happened 5 seconds it is likely to be more accurate than when I construct one about what happened 5 days ago. Not constructing a narrative at all is the most useful. You don’t need to think verbally in order to solve a math or physics problem. You just do it successfully based on skills that have become instinctual once you have trained yourself correctly. Charlotte Joko Beck has a great piece about how all functional thinking is immediate and how non-functional thinking (useless worry about unlikely hypothetical problems) is what we need to clear away. Rand’s heroes are extremely functional grounded thinkers.

I have solved plenty of math and physics problems in the course of earning my degree and practicing electrical engineering. I would not characterize such problem solving as instinctual or even non-verbal but as learning a specialized language to precisely capture the elements of the problem conceptually. Visualizing shapes and their rotations or transformations is the only aspect of that work which is purely non-verbal.

On psychology: you criticize me for not defining a specific psychological standard as a basis for ethics by saying pure physical health is superior.

No, you misunderstand, but you can’t help but misunderstand at this point as you are unfamiliar with Rand’s epistemology. The argument to be made is that some concepts are logically prior to other concepts because they unavoidably embedded in the derivation and justification of later concepts. It is therefore an error, a kind of logical fallacy, to attempt to move logically from the more advanced concept to the more fundamental.

Physical force does not compel. This is a huge error made by most people who call themselves Objectivists and a complete misreading of Rand’s work. Even if she said those exact words, this is inconsistent with the behaviors of her novel’s heroes. Physical force can stimulate certain responses in certain people, but it requires the consent of an individual to make a choice to act based on that stimulus. Galt’s ethics did not permit him to choose behaviors inconsistent with them despite torture and the imminent possibility of death. A person’s internal moral code always trumps any stimulus, including physical force, when it comes to causing that person to take certain actions.

Physical force:

Man’s rights can be violated only by the use of physical force. It is only by means of physical force that one man can deprive another of his life, or enslave him, or rob him, or prevent him from pursuing his own goals, or compel him to act against his own rational judgment.

Physical force is what caused Galt to be imprisoned and tortured at all. Galt cannot be said to have consented to imprisonment and torture by refusing to cooperate with his captors. A mind cannot be forced, but a body certainly can be.

In my alternate ending to Atlas Shrugged, my hero would take charge when they asked him/her to and issue a series of decreasingly ridiculous and increasingly plausible bad orders that no one would ever follow, starting with something like “Go commit mass suicide.” Then, “Go hook yourself up to automated torture machines you can’t escape and turn them on.” Eventually, people would get frustrated with him and start telling him to issue “serious” orders. So he’d ask them to define a serious order and then issue the worst order possible consistent with that definition. Every time his orders were disobeyed this would bring into sharper relief people’s internal moral compasses. They would acquire highly functional ethics and independence in spite of themselves.

By the end of the book, instead of having a handful of very creative people in Galt’s Gulch who were really bad at getting along with [other?] very psychologically damaged people and enjoyed hoarding gold coins and infinite electricity generators, you’d have a very large society of self-respecting, competent creators who would naturally want to engage in mutually beneficial relationships because they’d realize it’s the only rational thing to do.

But rationality itself was under attack, so people couldn’t be self-respecting without the arguments to defend the integrity of their minds. Epistemology is logically prior to ethics and so therefore also of psychology, which in turn depends on ethics.

A society of subsistence farmers dealing with a finite amount of arable land is a society where property is a zero-sum game, where there is a “conservation of value” principle at work guaranteeing that for every winner there is a loser. Fortunately we do not live in that society.

Our society is a mixed bag of subsistence farmers and innovators, but the surface area our society lives on remains finite. Locke’s principle speaks more to the acquisition of unclaimed frontier as property, however there are ethical parallels to the acquisition of intellectual property as well. Creating waste as a means of promoting a scarcity of resources, for the purpose of artificially driving the value of those resources higher, is essentially the same as claiming too much land. The implementation of a right to life doesn’t imply a right to all life, or to have it all because one was the first to discover it.

@Grames: I particularly like the last sentence of Rand’s definition of an axiom that you cited. I have read virtually everything published in book form of Rand’s and ITOE is one of my favorite essay compilations. However, it has been some time since I last read it.

I am going to table this debate for a while and hone in on that definition as well as probably reread all of ITOE. My gut tells me there is a core truth in my argument that can contribute towards Objectivist thinking, but I need to refine what that is exactly.

To me it is self-evident that people act to fulfill their needs to the best their level of competency allows. In psychology we recognize higher and lower functioning individuals, and I see those designations as inherently tied to philosophical maturity.

My main point is that as Objectivists it is in our self-interest to focus more on gradations of functionality and philosophical development as well as on how best to assist others and ourselves in climbing the neverending ladder of personal growth.

I don’t think anyone ever argued that we need to create long term goals that can’t be adjusted according to circumstance.

Objectivist ethics stress principles, which help achieve any decent goal, however the goals themselves do need to be changed according to a change in context.

If you get sick for instance, you may need to stop a low carb diet. However I don’t think anyone ever argued that you shouldn’t. However gettin sick doesn’t really make it any more advantageous to lie to people or to compromise your values for other people’s approval.

I am failing to see where there is any controversy here in your over all point.

For instance I want to be a RN. I am a student and have a job. I really don’t think about being an RN much though since that is pretty far off. Instead I worry about managing my time studying and working along with other errands during my days and weeks. However these decisions are still integrated with my goal of becoming a nurse, and my even longer term goal of having a family one day.

What does affect my decision making however is my principles, which apply in the short term as much as a the long term. I can’t go arround lying to people or ignoring people’s flaws or not working hard. Everything fall to pieces pretty quickly no matter what my goals are.

I don’t see how my method of thinking contradicts Objectivism or your suggestions here.

@Hairnet: I don’t think it does at all. I am really just trying to say that psychological health as measured by mental health professionals can be demonstrated to be directly tied to philosophical development. Effective psychological treatments actually tend to bring people more in line with Objectivism despite the philosophical underpinnings of those treatments not being identified as Objectivist.

Since one of my main intellectual interests is in relating Objectivist ideas to non-Objectivists I am interested when useful mental tools are not explicitly Objectivist. I can better positively influence someone with a background in mindfulness therapy, for example, by helping them refine what is useful in that approach without needing for them to have read Rand as a precondition to useful discussion.

I suppose my theory boils down to this: if Objectivism is philosophically perfect or quite close to it, then we should never need to discuss it explicitly as distinct from any other field. We should just have conversations about whatever non-Objectivists are interested in and demonstrate our philosophy’s effectiveness with our words and actions on a level others can relate to.

@Hairnet: I don’t think it does at all. I am really just trying to say that psychological health as measured by mental health professionals can be demonstrated to be directly tied to philosophical development. Effective psychological treatments actually tend to bring people more in line with Objectivism despite the philosophical underpinnings of those treatments not being identified as Objectivist.

Since one of my main intellectual interests is in relating Objectivist ideas to non-Objectivists I am interested when useful mental tools are not explicitly Objectivist. I can better positively influence someone with a background in mindfulness therapy, for example, by helping them refine what is useful in that approach without needing for them to have read Rand as a precondition to useful discussion.

I suppose my theory boils down to this: if Objectivism is philosophically perfect or quite close to it, then we should never need to discuss it explicitly as distinct from any other field. We should just have conversations about whatever non-Objectivists are interested in and demonstrate our philosophy’s effectiveness with our words and actions on a level others can relate to.

There’s an interesting aspect of property rights, as proposed by Locke, that one can only claim as much property as one can use without waste; waste being an infringement on other individuals use and appropriation of common resources. In this context, property rights remain legitimate with limitations based on recognizing that all individuals require some ability to acquire property in order to validate private ownership as an individual right. Essentially, an individual right to property presumes additional property remains for other individuals to acquire.

A society of subsistence farmers dealing with a finite amount of arable land is a society where property is a zero-sum game , where there is a “conservation of value” principle at work guaranteeing that for every winner there is a loser. Fortunately we do not live in that society.

DA- I don’t understand how that would work in practice. Would I only be able to buy a small amount of property so that everyone else also has the opportunity to buy land? That makes me wonder… who is ‘everyone else’? What is each individual’s limit? Wouldn’t that depend on each individual’s earnings (ie: you can buy as much as you want or as much as you can afford)? As a seller, I don’t care who buys my property, as long as the person who buys it can afford it. I don’t see how a buyer who pays for a large amount of land is infringing upon other individuals rights. If other individuals wanted the land and could afford it, they should have bid higher and bought it.

It seems that Locke is saying, ‘It’s okay to take a little sliver of cake for yourself. But make sure you leave plenty for everyone else. You don’t want to overindulge.’ Overindulge is only defined as ‘not leaving enough for everyone else,’ and ‘everyone else’ is defined as all the people in the world who don’t have cake.

Grames- Can you explain how property can be a ‘zero-sum game’?

Grames- Can you explain how property can be a ‘zero-sum game’?

It can’t, it is the faulty premise behind certain theories. In general what is important is value, and value is never zero-sum even on a desert island, or in a society of subsistence farmers. Not only do we not live in that society now, no one ever did or ever will.

Locke’s theory that one can only claim as much property as one can use without waste assumes a certain natural pre-industrial limitation to the amount of land one man could put to plough or to graze. Technology has greatly increased the ratio of farmland per farmer so that it not even remotely plausible today that everyone can be allocated as much land as one can use without waste.

Equating property entirely or for most part with land is also obsolete.

It seems that Locke is saying, ‘It’s okay to take a little sliver of cake for yourself. But make sure you leave plenty for everyone else. You don’t want to overindulge.’ Overindulge is only defined as ‘not leaving enough for everyone else,’ and ‘everyone else’ is defined as all the people in the world who don’t have cake.

Locke’s goal was to prove a natural right to property which established a legitimate claim and an ethical limitation. He begins by claiming we are naturally entitled to the preservation of our lives, which implies a right to acquire property in order to live…

“Sec. 25. Whether we consider natural reason, which tells us, that men, being once born, have a right to their preservation, and consequently to meat and drink, and such other things as nature affords for their subsistence…”

… and later suggests that legitimate acquisition implies a duty not to claim so much that others are left without an ability to acquire property for their preservation…

“Sec. 31. It will perhaps be objected to this, that if gathering the acorns, or other fruits of the earth, &c. makes a right to them, then any one may ingross as much as he will. To which I answer, Not so. The same law of nature, that does by this means give us property, does also bound that property too…”

“Sec. 33… No body could think himself injured by the drinking of another man, though he took a good draught, who had a whole river of the same water left him to quench his thirst: and the case of land and water, where there is enough of both, is perfectly the same.”

So yes, there is an ethical limitation to how much property, i.e. objects of nature that sustain life, one can legitimately acquire without undermining the very legitimacy of acquiring it. However, Locke isn’t implying a duty to calculate acquisition based on the availability of common resources, so much as pointing out that one’s own right to acquire property largely depends on everyone having a similar right to acquire property. His argument is worth reading in its entirety, and holds up well by substituting reference to God, as Nature’s God (a la Jefferson), or simply Nature, as in, “to be commanded, must be obeyed”

http://www.constitution.org/jl/2ndtr05.htm

Locke’s theory that one can only claim as much property as one can use without waste assumes a certain natural pre-industrial limitation to the amount of land one man could put to plough or to graze. Technology has greatly increased the ratio of farmland per farmer so that it not even remotely plausible today that everyone can be allocated as much land as one can use without waste.

I believe Locke’s point was that “Life, Liberty and Property” isn’t justified to the exclusion of others. Within his argument, he also accounts for methods of plowing, grazing, harvesting, but more importantly getting one’s goods to market to avoid waste, thereby increasing one’s wealth (property).

I was thinking about how to respond to this while I was having a convo with Eiuol. Maybe it will be of some use- we tried to play Devil’s Advocate. :stuart:

Edit: Link to part of the convo on pastebin. (Puns included)

I was thinking about how to respond to this while I was having a convo with Eiuol. Maybe it will be of some use- we tried to play Devil’s Advocate. :stuart:

Edit: Link to part of the convo on pastebin. (Puns included)

OK, so that was an interesting conversation, but neither of you got around to actually refuting Locke’s point that a right to acquire finite (perishable) property, founded on a premise of survival (right to life), implies that waste infringes on others same right to survive.

Unless you’re prepared to argue that a right to life is unilateral, e.g. first come - first served, then taking more than you need to survive, such that finite (perishable) life sustaining property is wasted, infringes on others same right to acquire life sustaining property. There’s no duty to provide for others; just not to get in the way of their ability to provide for themselves according to the _ same _ _ right _ you claim for yourself. In your desert example, if someone arrives first and claims all the available water by some right to survive, e.g. “I got here first and figured out how to take it all”, and proceeds to tell other arrivals, “Sorry, it’s all mine now; go find another desert”, the right being claimed isn’t just (justified) if there’s more than enough water to sustain other lives.

I’d be more curious to hear where you are going with this argument. Exactly how do you propose to institute Locke’s argument into a LFC society?

As I said elsewhere, the finite argument falls flat since everything is finite. The fact that all resources, goods, and capital are finite is what defines economics. If something was infinite there would be no supply or demand, no pricing, no economics, and someone would have immediate gratification of a want.

So I do not understand why you are categorizing certain things as being finite in a special way separate from everything else that is finite. Are we giving them special consideration in economics? Under the law? Who gets to decide that? Who gets to add or remove things from this list as technology advances?

I’d be more curious to hear where you are going with this argument. Exactly how do you propose to institute Locke’s argument into a LFC society?

OK, I’ll give it a shot, but first… what’s a LFC society?

Here’s a summary of Locke’ argument for reference:

All individuals have a right to the property of their own person, and a right to their own preservation.

Natural life sustaining resources, e.g. air, water, edible plants and animals, are common to all individuals because they are not created by individuals.

The labor required for one individual to obtain a particular common resource, e.g. a nut, fruit or rabbit, being their own labor, is sufficient to claim that particular resource as their own property, because it isn’t possible to obtain every individual’s consent to a particular common resource prior to taking it. However taking a common resource and allowing it to go to waste, i.e. not using it to preserve ones own life, infringes on the same right of others to claim that same resource by their labor to preserve their life.

The issue of waste is avoided by bartering perishable goods for durable goods, e.g. fruit for nuts, olives for olive oil, surplus land for gold or silver. Therefore a legitimate title to property, founded on ones right to life and preservation, is made illegitimate by intentionally wasting common resources, thereby impeding the life and preservation of others.

http://www.constitution.org/jl/2ndtr05.htm

I’m going to go out on a limb here and guess that your LFC means Laissez Faire Capitalism…

As I mentioned to Grames, Locke’s point is that “Life, Liberty and Property” isn’t justified to the exclusion of others. In order for a right to life to legitimize a right to property, said property must necessarily be identifiable as life sustaining, and common to all. It means little to assert a right to life and property that excludes life and property from others. In terms of Laissez Faire Capitalism, it means little to assert a “free market” that excludes others from participation.

As I said elsewhere, the finite argument falls flat since everything is finite. The fact that all resources, goods, and capital are finite is what defines economics. If something was infinite there would be no supply or demand, no pricing, no economics, and someone would have immediate gratification of a want.

We can agree that nothing is infinite, but some goods are perishable, e.g. meat, vegetables, etc., and some are durable, e.g. lumber, masonry, rare metals, etc. Locke points out that where resources are plentiful, no one really cares how much a particular person claims for their own use. But where life sustaining resources are limited, i.e. finite, claiming more of a common resource than one can use and allowing the surplus to rot, impedes the right of others to sustain their lives by their own labor, by reducing or eliminating an otherwise common resource. One can easily avoid this by bartering away perishable goods for durable ones in a free market.

Again, Locke isn’t promoting a Marxist theory of transfer from ability to need, but simply recognizing that a legitimate right to life and property cannot be maintained to the exclusion of others. So it’s OK to claim personal property from common resources by laboring to sustain your life, but not OK to prevent others from doing the same.

That is what I meant by LFC.

I get the base idea but I’m getting the direction here, or should I say I’m coming up with a direction but I don’t think it is what you intended.

A right to your life legitimizes a right to property because property rights are a consequence of man’s need to live. It is man’s need to take his thoughts and recreate it in realty as life sustaining action. If man doesn’t have a right to his effort, he does not have a right to the purpose of that effort – His life – Since you are restricting his ability to use his tool of survival (his mind) and the result (property). The argument for a right to property is not because the property needs to be life sustaining, but because the actual use man’s mind being recreated into reality is itself life sustaining.

It’s the process and result, not simply the utility of the object.

Next, how does “wasting” affect another’s right to life? If living is thinking and working to create the means of survival (property) then if I waste my means of survival it does not translate into wasting another’s means of survival. If I grow an orchard of apples and my neighbor grows a field of wheat, and I waste some of my land by not using it I don’t see how it can be construed to hurt my neighbor. He can use his property to live just the same no matter what I do with mine. Only I’m hurt since I underutilized my own property.

Are you claiming that this hurts my neighbor because they could utilize the land better than me? Like they have a priori claim to it and I violated a contract by not fulfilling an obligation? This would appear that everyone has “a right” to property up front but only gets to have it based on a promise of use, like some social contract, which can be nullified since someone else could have used it better than you.

Who gets to decide what is the “proper utilization” of property? Who gets to decide who gets it after confiscation? Outside of the morality of such an idea, which is very bad if you are entering in social contract territory, I still don’t see how you could even begin to start or manage such a concept without going down a very slippery slope whose destination is the exact opposite of LFC.

Thoughts?

In your desert example, if someone arrives first and claims all the available water by some right to survive, e.g. “I got here first and figured out how to take it all”, and proceeds to tell other arrivals, “Sorry, it’s all mine now; go find another desert”, the right being claimed isn’t just (justified) if there’s more than enough water to sustain other lives.

Well, in that conversation I wasn’t trying to refute Locke at all. Refutation would take a different approach. I am pointing out what I see to be what leads to the welfare-state. What I quoted here is exactly the point, as there is no justification to deem what is “enough” for others. Isn’t a claim to surplus food then unjustified by your reasoning because that deprives people starving in Africa of food that they’d love to have? Or in your own town?

There’s no duty to provide for others; just not to get in the way of their ability to provide for themselves according to the _ same _ _ right _ you claim for yourself.

From the source listed, these arguments from Macpherson make the most sense:

"On Macpherson’s interpretation, Locke is thought to have set three restrictions on the accumulation of property in the state of nature: 1) one may only appropriate as much as one can use before it spoils (Two Treatises 2.31), 2) one must leave “enough and as good” for others (the sufficiency restriction) (2.27), and 3) one may (supposedly) only appropriate property through one’s own labor (2.27). Macpherson claims that as the argument progresses, each of these restrictions is transcended.

The spoilage restriction ceases to be a meaningful restriction with the invention of money because value can be stored in a medium that does not decay (2.46–47). The sufficiency restriction is transcended because the creation of private property so increases productivity that even those who no longer have the opportunity to acquire land will have more opportunity to acquire what is necessary for life (2.37). According to Macpherson’s view, the “enough and as good” requirement is itself merely a derivative of a prior principle guaranteeing the opportunity to acquire, through labor, the necessities of life. The third restriction, Macpherson argues, was not one Locke actually held at all. Though Locke appears to suggest that one can only have property in what one has personally labored on when he makes labor the source of property rights, Locke clearly recognized that even in the state of nature, “the Turfs my Servant has cut” (2.28) can become my property." [Source]

One can easily avoid this by bartering away perishable goods for durable ones in a free market.

That’s true- If you’re a farmer growing vegetables, it’s likely that you’ll eat some and sell the excess at the market in order to buy other goods/supplies. But should you be forced under law to sell your excess perishables? No. And are you being immoral if you don’t? No.

Another thought: Even if you are forced to sell your excess perishables, who decides the price? I can comply with the law by selling my organic onions for $100 a piece- but if no one wants to buy them, they will all go to waste. Under Locke’s theory, I would be infringing on others “rights to life” (food) by selling my onions at a price higher than anyone can pay. This is a problem you’d have to sort out in this society. I don’t see any other way to do it except to regulate prices (or apply price caps)- which itself would be immoral.

Well, in that conversation I wasn’t trying to refute Locke at all. Refutation would take a different approach. I am pointing out what I see to be what leads to the welfare-state. What I quoted here is exactly the point, as there is no justification to deem what is “enough” for others. Isn’t a claim to surplus food then unjustified by your reasoning because that deprives people starving in Africa of food that they’d love to have? Or in your own town?

The only justification of what is enough, is conservation of a natural resource that others, like yourself, depend on to live. A claim to surplus food (which is allowed to waste) from a common resource,and by “common” Locke means that which is was created by Nature without anyone’s effort, is unjustified if results in people starving who otherwise (by their own labor) could have claimed food to survive.

In my town, for example, there are some community gardens, in which the property owner consents to the use of an otherwise vacant lot so that neighbors can plant vegetables, and the harvest is distributed according to labor spent maintaining the garden. I doubt if anyone would starve for want of these gardens, but everyone involved certainly has a greater respect for the land, and the effort it takes to produce goods. I consider this to be a good example of Locke’s principle in action.