This topic is particularly interesting to me, as it explores foundational premises derived from existence (natural reality) that support ethical standards for living and acquiring personal possessions (private property). For my part, I have come to consider moral reciprocity as the truest barometer of just social interactions, where the standard is life, and the sovereignty of one’s life depends on non-coercive interactions with other lives. In this regard, I identify the following statements as best representing just ethics derived from reality…
–
“Sec. 25. Whether we consider natural reason, which tells us, that men, being once born, have a right to their preservation, and consequently to meat and drink, and such other things as nature affords for their subsistence…” ~ John Locke, 2nd Treatise of Civil Government, Chap. 5, Of Property
“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator* with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness**.” ~ Declaration of Independence; *Creator being previously referred to as: Laws of Nature and of Nature’s God; **the pursuit of Happiness alternately referred to as property
“The standard of value of the Objectivist ethics—the standard by which one judges what is good or evil—is man’s life, or: that which is required for man’s survival qua man.” ~ ARL, Morality
–
In order to remain ethically consistent, and therefore just, one’s sovereignty cannot be maintained unilaterally, i.e. it cannot depend on others having a lesser right to life and the property necessary to preserve it. Therefore the just preservation of ones life depends not only on rational thought and action, but on having some natural resources, as yet unclaimed, to work with; making a right to private property ethically delimited to the property of ones creation. In terms of natural resources, e.g. those things nature provides and maintains independently of man, there can be no justification for the legal exclusion of one party by any other party to that which neither party created.
Reference to “life boats” and “emergency situations” are rationalizations of the ethics of “first come - first served” and “might makes right”, neither of which ethically support an equal (just) opportunity to preserve ones life by means of acquiring property necessary to accomplish that purpose; there must remain some unclaimed property to acquire. Where Nature provides that property, no man is ethically justified to claim it as his own to the exclusion of others.