Deriving Ethics from Reality

… If you’re a farmer growing vegetables, it’s likely that you’ll eat some and sell the excess at the market in order to buy other goods/supplies. But should you be forced under law to sell your excess perishables? No. And are you being immoral if you don’t? No.

The issue of force is double edged, but I certainly agree that forcing someone to relinquish perishables earned by their own labor is unjustified. However withholding perishables obtained from a common resource with the intent to allow them to rot rather than bartering them away for durable goods is unethical, because it willfully destroys that which others, by their own labor, depend on to survive.

It’s the process and result, not simply the utility of the object.

Hmmm… I get your point, and agree, but let’s be more specific about “utility of the object”…

A lake for example, represents a natural object not produced by man, the utility of which contains water and fish people depend on to survive, but again no one but Nature creates the “utility of the object”. We can agree that an individual may own the lake as property, but that person certainly didn’t create the lake, much less the water and fish it contains (not talking about man made reservoirs now). Add into the mix water and fish being delivered by a river from mountains, both of which are outside the property of the lake. Now consider a drought which deprives neighbors from obtaining water and fish from the river, and the lake owner’s refusal to barter water or fish from “his” lake, because he can “legitimately” do so by law…

Does the lake owner’s right to impede his neighbors’ efforts to obtain life sustaining property by their own labor from a natural resource (privately owned) remain justified ethically??

Does the lake owner’s right to impede his neighbors’ efforts to obtain life sustaining property by their own labor from a natural resource (privately owned) remain ethically legitimate??

Yes. Unless your scenario rises to an end-of-the-world emergency, but in that case all that matters is how long the lake owner’s ammo supply holds out.

Lifeboat ethics are deprecated.

Yes. Unless your scenario rises to an end-of-the-world emergency, but in that case all that matters is how long the lake owner’s ammo supply holds out.

Lifeboat ethics are deprecated.

I had edited the word “legitimate” and replaced with “justified” in order to change the focus from “by legal statute” to “what is morally right and fair”; that may alter your response…

However, I would point out that ethics that depend on one’s ammo supply holding out, imply a policy of Might Makes Right. I believe Locke’s premise is superior because it recognizes that a right to life and property cannot be maintained by dismissing the same right to others; starving, destitute neighbors invite war…

I had edited the word “legitimate” and replaced with “justified” in order to change the focus from “by legal statute” to “what is morally right and fair”; that may alter your response…

However, I would point out that ethics that depend on one’s ammo supply holding out, imply a policy of Might Makes Right. I believe Locke’s premise is superior because it recognizes that a right to life and property cannot be maintained by dismissing the same right to others; starving, destitute neighbors invite war…

I would not change my response as it was centered on ethics already. Lifeboat emergency situations teach nothing that can be generalized to everyday ethics.

The threat of the starving and destitute neighbors is itself a recourse to ‘might makes right’, so the question as to who would be initiating force in this situation has to be ‘the neighbors’.

A lake for example, represents a natural object not produced by man, the utility of which contains water and fish people depend on to survive, but again no one but Nature creates the “utility of the object”. We can agree that an individual may own the lake as property, but that person certainly didn’t create the lake, much less the water and fish it contains (not talking about man made reservoirs now). Add into the mix water and fish being delivered by a river from mountains, both of which are outside the property of the lake. Now consider a drought which deprives neighbors from obtaining water and fish from the river, and the lake owner’s refusal to barter water or fish from “his” lake, because he can “legitimately” do so by law…

Does the lake owner’s right to impede his neighbors’ efforts to obtain life sustaining property by their own labor from a natural resource (privately owned) remain justified ethically??

No, people create the utility of an object. Utility is only possible if you figure out how to use what you find. You are right that an individual didn’t create the lake, but an individual figured out how to use the lake. The lake owner can impede in any manner, as it is a judgment of how to use the lake. The lake owner can fish in any manner he sees fit, whether with fishing nets, fishing poles on a rowboat, or using a spear. During a drought, using the property may include not allowing anyone to use water or fish from his lake, in order to maintain a delicate ecosystem. Whether you, the starving neighbor, thinks this is irrational is a separate question, but the lake owner has a different context of knowledge. From the your (the neighbor’s) perspective, the lake owner might be impeding on a right to obtain life sustaining property during a drought. From the lake owner’s perspective, the you might be impeding on a right to maintain life sustaining property - if the ecosystem collapses, not even the lake owner gets fish. Because no one is omniscient, we ought only make judgments of violating rights based on preventing someone from using their mind as they see fit. Unless you’d like some philosopher kings (and onward to tyranny).

I would not change my response as it was centered on ethics already. Lifeboat emergency situations teach nothing that can be generalized to everyday ethics.

The threat of the starving and destitute neighbors is itself a recourse to ‘might makes right’, so the question as to who would be initiating force in this situation has to be ‘the neighbors’.

I would argue that the “threat” is created by the owner of the lake mismanaging his “property”; he is in effect forcing his neighbors into the lifeboat. The lake owner may recognize his neighbors’ equal right to preserve their lives without surrendering his right to property and profit from it, or he can pick them off as they are forced to cross his property line in order to eat and drink. The former way acts to prevent war; the latter invites it.

No, people create the utility of an object. Utility is only possible if you figure out how to use what you find. You are right that an individual didn’t create the lake, but an individual figured out how to use the lake. The lake owner can impede in any manner, as it is a judgment of how to use the lake. The lake owner can fish in any manner he sees fit, whether with fishing nets, fishing poles on a rowboat, or using a spear. During a drought, using the property may include not allowing anyone to use water or fish from his lake, in order to maintain a delicate ecosystem. Whether you, the starving neighbor, thinks this is irrational is a separate question, but the lake owner has a different context of knowledge. From the your (the neighbor’s) perspective, the lake owner might be impeding on a right to obtain life sustaining property during a drought. From the lake owner’s perspective, the you might be impeding on a right to maintain life sustaining property - if the ecosystem collapses, not even the lake owner gets fish. Because no one is omniscient, we ought only make judgments of violating rights based on preventing someone from using their mind as they see fit. Unless you’d like some philosopher kings (and onward to tyranny).

So… this guy finds a lake and it’s filled with something wet, and he thinks, “hmm… I bet I could figure out a way to drink this stuff, that no one has thought of before…”

Is that your justification for excluding everyone else from a natural resource as a right to property? Really??

How is that different than simply adopting a policy of first come - first served, enforced by might makes right??

So… this guy finds a lake and it’s filled with something wet, and he thinks, “hmm… I bet I could figure out a way to drink this stuff, that no one has thought of before…”

Is that your justification for excluding everyone else from a natural resource as a right to property? Really??

How is that different than simply adopting a policy of first come - first served, enforced by might makes right??

Might makes right is when a right to property derives from the ability to defend what you have. If someone overpowers you, too bad. Simple as that.

My position is different because the right to property derives from the ability to use what’s in front of you, and in large part if you reach it first. We can get into how *much* of a lake you can claim - just fishing in Lake Erie doesn’t mean you own all of Lake Erie - but what you can claim is based on your ability to know how to use the lake. Knowing how to use something in a particular way also implies some amount of planning long-range, so even if people cry that denying access to water is unfair, that doesn’t mean they’re being denied a right to life. Other people determining how you must use your property infringes on your ability to think (i.e. they’ll raid your lake in response to a perceived rights violation), while your possession of the only well or lake during a drought doesn’t infringe on another person’s ability to think if they’re not allowed to use it.

To clarify, I’m using Locke’s premise applied to the lake owner example to demonstrate an ethical limit to acquiring ownership of a natural resource…

The lake in question is replenished with fish and water from a common natural resource (a river). Clearly the lake owner benefits from this natural arrangement without laboring to discover or maintain any use of his lake. Additionally, he has benefited from his neighbors not constructing a dam or rerouting the river’s course to avoid his property. No one cares or challenges the lake owner’s title to property because river water and fish are plentiful until a drought occurs, resulting in a real threat to the neighbors ability to survive by their wits and labor, which the lake owner remains exempt from… Without any innovation or property improvements on his part, he now has title to surplus property that his neighbors will perish for want of.

Either the lake owner can allow access to his neighbors, even profit from it, or he can maintain his right to deny access, thereby relying on his neighbors to respect his right to surplus property at the expense of their own lives. Don’t try to wriggle out with some excuse about life boats and neighbors being able to wander off into the desert in search of more natural resources; scouts have been dispatched and none have survived the search. Of course it will rain again some day, but the neighbors will be dead by then…

So… at what point, if ever, does a legal title to surplus natural resources justify denying the right of others to their preservation by wasting it?

Might makes right is when a right to property derives from the ability to defend what you have. If someone overpowers you, too bad. Simple as that.

This is a tyrant’s claim, is it not?

Either the lake owner can allow access to his neighbors, even profit from it, or he can maintain his right to deny access, thereby relying on his neighbors to respect his right to surplus property at the expense of their own lives.

How would you know that either is true? How are you so sure the neighbors will die if they can’t access the lake? Maybe there is an aquifer deep inside the ground, someone just needs to tap into it. How do you know if the lake owner can profit, anyway?

How would you know that either is true? How are you so sure the neighbors will die if they can’t access the lake? Maybe there is an aquifer deep inside the ground, someone just needs to tap into it. How do you know if the lake owner can profit, anyway?

This is the choice presented by example… either the lake owner chooses to barter (and profit from) surplus natural resources, or not. Locke’s premise suggests the former, Objectivism seems to argue for the latter. May be a meteor will fall from the sky and put them all out of their misery, but until then, which is the more ethical choice? And why??

Are you suggesting the neighbors must respect the lawful owner’s title until their last breath, because there may be another resource yet to be discovered? That seems like an argument for faith to me… pray for rain??

DA, the reality is if someone did own the only lake around it would not mater. We have rivers, wells, water-levels to dig down to, rain water to collect, and even chemistry to use. When I went to college for a short time (a looong time ago) I worked for as an assistant in the Chem department for extra cash. One of my jobs was to generate purified water for the experiments. It isn’t that hard to collect water and make it useful, and I could easily do it today despite no additional understanding of chemistry (or a degree). In the long run the owner of the lake would only hurt himself from isolation while the rest of us dug/collected/created our own water and traded with each other everything else we created as well.

Now, if you want to build a sci-fi tale around this and the consequences to human life that would be an interesting story. How would man cope on a terra-formed planet if the person running the water purification process went into business himself as some “Water-Baron”? But this is not applicable to real life. Human’s can easily produce their survival from the environment no matter how much someone owns of the infinitesimally small portions available (this is one huge planet after all) of resources that could possibly be construed as “essential” to life. The only way we could not is if you create an emergency situation or hypothetical construct that we are to accept as an argument, but in the first case all bets are off and in the second that is fiction.

Remember, freedom creates options and expands the availability of resources and wealth, not limits them.

http://www.prodos.com/archive011coercionandconsciousness.html

No time for a bigger response right now, but here is a discussion I found very useful about rights and the Objectivist position.

DA, the reality is if someone did own the only lake around it would not mater. We have rivers, wells, water-levels to dig down to, rain water to collect, and even chemistry to use. When I went to college for a short time (a looong time ago) I worked for as an assistant in the Chem department for extra cash. One of my jobs was to generate purified water for the experiments. It isn’t that hard to collect water and make it useful, and I could easily do it today despite no additional understanding of chemistry (or a degree). In the long run the owner of the lake would only hurt himself from isolation while the rest of us dug/collected/created our own water and traded with each other everything else we created as well.

Ever been to Death Valley :wink:

I don’t consider the example to be that much of a stretch, given that I know some property owners who rely on well water that diminishes to nothing in drought conditions… however I do concede there remains some options the neighbors might use, similar to those employed in survivor shows, e.g. Survivor Man and Dual Survival. The point is, is it ethically justified for a owner of a natural resource to withhold goods he hasn’t labored to create, to waste them, such that his neighbors’ equal right to preserve their life is impeded?

I agree that such a property owner wouldn’t be popular, or particularly interested in his own preservation given the stress such a position would create… but doesn’t such a position actually justify trespassing by his neighbors? I honestly don’t see how it avoids it. It seems to me that Locke’s premise avoids this moral hazard without pushing some ill-intentioned right to waste natural resources as the ultimate expression of a right to property.

This reminds me of the ‘takings clause’ in the constitution, which says “nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.” Meaning, the government can seize private property for public use, as long as they pay for it. I haven’t looked into it, but I assume Objectivists completely disagree with this clause due to the nature of property rights.

Ever been to Death Valley :wink:

Yes. And if I am ever dumb enough to move there Darwin will hand me my just deserts :wink:

I don’t consider the example to be that much of a stretch, given that I know some property owners who rely on well water that diminishes to nothing in drought conditions… however I do concede there remains some options the neighbors might use, similar to those employed in survivor shows, e.g. Survivor Man and Dual Survival. The point is, is it ethically justified for a owner of a natural resource to withhold goods he hasn’t labored to create, to waste them, such that his neighbors’ equal right to preserve their life is impeded?

I agree that such a property owner wouldn’t be popular, or particularly interested in his own preservation given the stress such a position would create… but doesn’t such a position actually justify trespassing by his neighbors? I honestly don’t see how it avoids it. It seems to me that Locke’s premise avoids this moral hazard without pushing some ill-intentioned right to waste natural resources as the ultimate expression of a right to property.

Diminishing resources on your property does not give you a claim ticket to someone else’s property. That’s just an “emergency” backdoor to central planning, which now that I think about it is pretty much what has been going on since Clinton expanded the roll of FEMA.

Morality is individual based, self-conceived and self-implemented. It is one person’s choice to provide for his own life. Morality is not derived from others (altruism) but you (egoism). The only way you can deprive someone else of heir ability to live is to deprive them of their ability to produce or confiscate the result of that effort. Equality means equal opportunity, not equal outcomes. By trying to claim that people need to do a preapproved amount of work with natural resources you are inadvertently making the egalitarian outcome argument repackaged as an argument about opportunity. It is not, unless once again you invoke an emergency situation.

And really, just to demonstrate how this can go pear-shaped fast, just ask yourself who gets to decide what is acceptable use of property, who will get to enforce it, who will decide the beneficiary of confiscated property, and ultimately who will get it.

Ask yourself, who wins in that situation, Rearden or Boyle?

Morality is individual based, self-conceived and self-implemented. It is one person’s choice to provide for his own life. Morality is not derived from others (altruism) but you (egoism).

Subjective morality is by definition non-objective. By claiming that, “It is one person’s choice to provide for his own life”, you are in effect arguing against subjective morality. If morality is everyone choosing to provide for their own lives, then morality is objective, and life is the standard. Locke makes the same argument, that everyone is entitled to their own preservation, and to claim by their own wit and labor that which is necessary to live from common, natural resources. I believe laissez faire capitalism depends on it.

The only way you can deprive someone else of heir ability to live is to deprive them of their ability to produce or confiscate the result of that effort. Equality means equal opportunity, not equal outcomes.

… or deprive them of a natural resource, that being created by no man’s wit or labor, and enforced by a tyrant’s claim, “Might makes right”. There’s no equality in, “First come - take all”.

By trying to claim that people need to do a preapproved amount of work with natural resources you are inadvertently making the egalitarian outcome argument repackaged as an argument about opportunity. It is not, unless once again you invoke an emergency situation.

If life is the standard, and everyone is entitled to their own preservation, then “pre-approved” only means that which is necessarily removed by one’s wit and labor from common, natural resources to preserve one’s life. Emergency situations only arise by natural disaster, or by one man’s claim to a natural resource when it creates an artificial scarcity of that resource.

If my moral claim to a plentiful natural resource depended on denying it to others who are willing to barter for it; if the ultimate expression of my right to property, I didn’t create by wit or labor, was demonstrated by pouring my water into my sand while others perished for want of it… because I could… then I’d check my moral premise, and prepare for war.

* edited for clarity *

This topic is particularly interesting to me, as it explores foundational premises derived from existence (natural reality) that support ethical standards for living and acquiring personal possessions (private property). For my part, I have come to consider moral reciprocity as the truest barometer of just social interactions, where the standard is life, and the sovereignty of one’s life depends on non-coercive interactions with other lives. In this regard, I identify the following statements as best representing just ethics derived from reality…

–

“Sec. 25. Whether we consider natural reason, which tells us, that men, being once born, have a right to their preservation, and consequently to meat and drink, and such other things as nature affords for their subsistence…” ~ John Locke, 2nd Treatise of Civil Government, Chap. 5, Of Property

“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator* with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness**.” ~ Declaration of Independence; *Creator being previously referred to as: Laws of Nature and of Nature’s God; **the pursuit of Happiness alternately referred to as property

“The standard of value of the Objectivist ethics—the standard by which one judges what is good or evil—is man’s life, or: that which is required for man’s survival qua man.” ~ ARL, Morality

–

In order to remain ethically consistent, and therefore just, one’s sovereignty cannot be maintained unilaterally, i.e. it cannot depend on others having a lesser right to life and the property necessary to preserve it. Therefore the just preservation of ones life depends not only on rational thought and action, but on having some natural resources, as yet unclaimed, to work with; making a right to private property ethically delimited to the property of ones creation. In terms of natural resources, e.g. those things nature provides and maintains independently of man, there can be no justification for the legal exclusion of one party by any other party to that which neither party created.

Reference to “life boats” and “emergency situations” are rationalizations of the ethics of “first come - first served” and “might makes right”, neither of which ethically support an equal (just) opportunity to preserve ones life by means of acquiring property necessary to accomplish that purpose; there must remain some unclaimed property to acquire. Where Nature provides that property, no man is ethically justified to claim it as his own to the exclusion of others.