Now, enlighten me…
I’ll do my best.
When we are born, the mere fact that we need water and food to survive doesn’t entitle us to water and food. By that, I mean that we aren’t entitled to objects (food that farmer’s grow, apple trees, lakes, etc). We don’t have a right to an object just because we’re alive and need it to continue being alive. I think we can agree on this.
We do have the right to act in order to gain those objects that we need or want for our survival. This means that if I want to own a lake, I have to buy it from its current owner. If I went up to a lake-owner and said, ‘I’m entitled to the water in your lake because I’m alive and need it,’ he would laugh at me and say, ‘Michele, don’t be silly. I bought this lake from the previous owner with my own hard-earned money. If you want any of it, you’re going to have to pay for it.’
Now what if I tried to trap that lake-owner, by saying, ‘Where did the previous owner get the lake? And the one before him, and the one before him? You see, lakes existed before men, and will probably go on existing after men. The first man who owned this lake had no right to take it for himself and profit off of it, because it’s a natural resource.. so you don’t have any right to own this lake and profit off of it, either’? The lake-owner would probably look at me and say, ‘All I know is that I paid for this lake with the fruits of my own labor. It’s mine, and that’s all I need to know.’
Now it’s an interesting question: what gave the first owner the right to own the lake? That’s something I don’t know- my guess is as good as yours.
But what I do know is that: 1) common pool goods are overused precisely because they are common pool goods. 2) If all natural resources (land, lakes, trees, mines, etc) were common pool goods, no one would privately own anything. Further, no one would be able to improve anything. We wouldn’t be able to buy clean, purified water, because the man who invented water purifiers would only be able to take enough water to sustain himself. We wouldn’t have pipes to pump that water into our kitchens and bathrooms, because pipes are made with a lot of metal ores, and those are natural resources that cannot be exploited. I wouldn’t be able to make my living creating & selling dressers, because trees are natural resources that cannot be exploited.
That is my line of reasoning. Let me know if I’ve misunderstood anything.