So everything that exists is man-made? :huh:
No- I was providing examples of items that men have created through the modification of natural resources. Most things that I use on a daily basis have been made possible by men, through the modification of natural resources: my bed, washing machine, dryer, stove, food, water, pens, paper, laptop, etc.
Did the individual you bought the forest from plant it? Are the ores you mine deposited by the individual you purchased the land from??
Ex nihilo nihil fit: out of nothing comes nothing.
Who owns Nature, mdegges? And what exactly did they do to acquire it that justifies their right to sell it to some and deny it to others??
… or to waste it???
Property rights had to start with someone, somewhere.
Where is my pocket-grames when I need it? :fool:
A better question, I think, is ‘what would happen in an open access area?’ A prof at my school wrote a paper about this back in 1954, about an open access fishery. He showed that if people are free to use a fishery, they will overuse the resource, due to the trail of thought: ‘if I don’t catch the fish someone else will.’ Anthony Scott developed this further. ‘He agreed with Gordon that when ‘everybody’s property is nobody’s property’ too much effort is likely to be devoted to fishing. He showed, however, that if there was sole ownership of the fishery as well as private ownership of fishing boats, then the fishing effort will be socially optimal.’ [1] This shows that private ownership is socially optimal, whereas open access areas are not.
Just last year a paper was published showing that weak property rights can kill the economy. ‘Suppose you took a freely available resource, but now anyone can contest your ownership of that resource. Depending on the consequences, you may not want to extract in the first place. It thus matters in which way the state is weak. If it is weak in that it gives away rights to natural resources, then there will be over-exploitation. If it is weak in that it cannot enforce property rights in general, and in particular when it comes to bringing products to the market, then it is the Wild West and under-exploitation may ensue. Theft is a powerful mechanism to kill markets.’ [2] You can see the same idea here: if everyone has rights to natural resources (ie: open access areas), there will be over-exploitation.