Deriving Ethics from Reality

–

“Sec. 25. Whether we consider natural reason, which tells us, that men, being once born, have a right to their preservation, and consequently to meat and drink, and such other things as nature affords for their subsistence…” ~ John Locke, 2nd Treatise of Civil Government, Chap. 5, Of Property

“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator* with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness**.” ~ Declaration of Independence; *Creator being previously referred to as: Laws of Nature and of Nature’s God; **the pursuit of Happiness alternately referred to as property

And here is the rationalization of the rights to goods, rather than rights to actions.

Everything man-made is derived from natural resources that existed prior to man’s existence. To put it another way, everything that exists, exists through the modification of existence. The water I’m drinking right now is a natural resource, but it’s been modified by man- purified, pumped through drains, and eventually pouring out of a faucet into my glass. The glass I’m holding came from minerals and sand, all natural resources that have been modified by man- stirred together, heated up, and molded into a cylindrical shape. My wooden dresser came from trees, a natural resource that has been modified by man. The metal knobs on it came from ores, a natural resource that has been modified by man- extracted, processed, and refined… etc. So when I pay my water bill each month, I know that I’m not paying for water in it’s natural form: it’s been modified by man to better suit my needs.

So when you say this:

Therefore the just preservation of ones life depends not only on rational thought and action, but on having some natural resources, as yet unclaimed, to work with; making a right to private property ethically delimited to the property of ones creation.

…there must remain some unclaimed property to acquire. Where Nature provides that property, no man is ethically justified to claim it as his own to the exclusion of others.

what do you mean? Do you mean I can’t buy a forest in order to log trees, so that I can create dressers? Do you mean I can’t buy land to mine for ores, in order to create metal knobs?

And here is the rationalization of the rights to goods, rather than rights to actions.

I see no rationalization of a right to goods in either of the statements I cited that you are pointing to… A right to the acquisition (or pursuit) of property is a right to action, is it not? The statement you omitted pointing to identifies the same ethical standard that the other two statements identify: man’s life and his efforts to sustain it. You can argue that a right to preserve life and acquire property is inherently equal, or unilateral… Which is it?

Furthermore the goods in question clearly fall into two distinct categories: natural and man made. Who owns by right what nature produces without any man’s action? The first to plant their flag on it?? If that were the case then the moon would be the property of the United States, and the remaining planets up for grabs. There is a clear distinction of property to be made between a naturally formed lake and a man made reservoir. In terms of just recognition of a man’s action to acquire private property, lakes and reservoirs are not one and the same.

Logically there must be some unclaimed goods available for men to work to acquire, or your position becomes that all men are born into debt and must work their way out of it prior to claiming any personal property of their own.

Everything man-made is derived from natural resources that existed prior to man’s existence.

Correct

To put it another way, everything that exists, exists through the modification of existence.

OK…

The water I’m drinking right now is a natural resource, but it’s been modified by man- purified, pumped through drains, and eventually pouring out of a faucet into my glass. The glass I’m holding came from minerals and sand, all natural resources that have been modified by man- stirred together, heated up, and molded into a cylindrical shape. My wooden dresser came from trees, a natural resource that has been modified by man. The metal knobs on it came from ores, a natural resource that has been modified by man- extracted, processed, and refined… etc. So when I pay my water bill each month, I know that I’m not paying for water in it’s natural form: it’s been modified by man to better suit my needs.

So everything that exists is man-made? :huh:

what do you mean? Do you mean I can’t buy a forest in order to log trees, so that I can create dressers? Do you mean I can’t buy land to mine for ores, in order to create metal knobs?

Did the individual you bought the forest from plant it? Are the ores you mine deposited by the individual you purchased the land from??

Who owns Nature, mdegges? And what exactly did they do to acquire it that justifies their right to sell it to some and deny it to others??

… or to waste it???

So everything that exists is man-made? :huh:

No- I was providing examples of items that men have created through the modification of natural resources. Most things that I use on a daily basis have been made possible by men, through the modification of natural resources: my bed, washing machine, dryer, stove, food, water, pens, paper, laptop, etc.

Did the individual you bought the forest from plant it? Are the ores you mine deposited by the individual you purchased the land from??

Ex nihilo nihil fit: out of nothing comes nothing.

Who owns Nature, mdegges? And what exactly did they do to acquire it that justifies their right to sell it to some and deny it to others??

… or to waste it???

Property rights had to start with someone, somewhere.

Where is my pocket-grames when I need it? :fool:

A better question, I think, is ‘what would happen in an open access area?’ A prof at my school wrote a paper about this back in 1954, about an open access fishery. He showed that if people are free to use a fishery, they will overuse the resource, due to the trail of thought: ‘if I don’t catch the fish someone else will.’ Anthony Scott developed this further. ‘He agreed with Gordon that when ‘everybody’s property is nobody’s property’ too much effort is likely to be devoted to fishing. He showed, however, that if there was sole ownership of the fishery as well as private ownership of fishing boats, then the fishing effort will be socially optimal.’ [1] This shows that private ownership is socially optimal, whereas open access areas are not.

Just last year a paper was published showing that weak property rights can kill the economy. ‘Suppose you took a freely available resource, but now anyone can contest your ownership of that resource. Depending on the consequences, you may not want to extract in the first place. It thus matters in which way the state is weak. If it is weak in that it gives away rights to natural resources, then there will be over-exploitation. If it is weak in that it cannot enforce property rights in general, and in particular when it comes to bringing products to the market, then it is the Wild West and under-exploitation may ensue. Theft is a powerful mechanism to kill markets.’ [2] You can see the same idea here: if everyone has rights to natural resources (ie: open access areas), there will be over-exploitation.

Property rights had to start with someone, somewhere.

… as did ethics, however if the initial claim is unjustified then whatever follows is built upon a false premise. Let us step back a moment to what we can agree on…

  1. Everyone is entitled to their own preservation.

  2. Preservation requires source material, e.g. air, water, food, etc.

  3. Ones own preservation doesn’t imply a duty to the preservation of others.

  4. The justification for private property depends on;

4a) being acquired by ones own labor, or

4b) being inherited as property acquired by a predecessor’s labor.

  1. There is no justification for acquiring private property by theft.

Unless we disagree on points 1-5, all that remains is to haggle over the ethics of the initial transition of common resource to personal property. So, what would happen in an open access area where everyone recognized each others right to the preservation of their own lives? Isn’t this just another way to question the ethics of a free market society?? Who owns the market, and who grants access to it???

Locke suggests, and I’m inclined to agree, that open access to natural resources works fine, so long as there remains enough for others to claim by their own labor for the preservation of their own lives: “No body could think himself injured by the drinking of another man, though he took a good draught, who had a whole river of the same water left him to quench his thirst.” Furthermore, individuals in an open access area wouldn’t want to draw the enmity of their neighbors by claiming resources beyond what was needed for self-preservation, or wasting resources others needed for self-preservation.

Thanks to the intervention of the State, we have yet to see true open access to natural resources, let alone true laissez faire capitalism. Over fishing of fisheries occurs because of the perception that one is cheating a bureaucracy rather than infringing on his neighbors right to acquire property. When dealing with bureaucracies, one adopts the policy of “use it or lose it”.

Where is this “First Come – Take all!” Did we discover a new continent when I wasn’t looking? Are the Feds giving away land to those who get there first?

When I say emergency situation I’m referring to the ethics of emergencies. The point is you keep building hypothetical situations that do not happen, not even periodically let alone on a daily bases, then want to rethink ethics and property rights to cater to this hypothetical situation. You build ethics around real day-to-day life, because that is how you live, not make-believe constructs that will never happen.

If you live for the unseen and likely-to-never-happen situation then you’ll be waiting a long time to live.

When I say emergency situation I’m referring to the ethics of emergencies. The point is you keep building hypothetical situations that do not happen, not even periodically let alone on a daily bases, then want to rethink ethics and property rights to cater to this hypothetical situation. You build ethics around real day-to-day life, because that is how you live, not make-believe constructs that will never happen.

As a computer programmer, I routinely check for the robustness of a system. Emergency situations test whether or not a particular code is fail-safe. To say that a code for living is only dependable for the day to day stuff, and can’t be relied on in a crisis, falls short of any ethical standard I’d care to bet my life on.

Locke’s premise avoids avoids the moral hazard of wasting or excluding others from life sustaining natural resources, and Objectivism appears to dismiss this as irrelevant; that someone who finds an oasis in the dessert is entitled to turn others away, or pour the water into the sand, as a demonstration of their right to own something nature provided. Locke suggests barter is ethically preferable to waste; Objectivism suggests waste is the ultimate proof of a property right.

We are copacetic regarding property rights of man-made objects, but we’ll just have to disagree as to which code for living is ethically justifiable regarding ownership of objects provided by nature.

I am a little confused about the argument in the first place. It seems both ‘sides’ are here using the concept property to justify positions as it concerns ethical or nonethical principles of society. The term property implies ‘society’ in the first place. Or more specifically civilsed society. In nature a lake is a lake, in a civilsed society the idea of individual ownership of the lake as a resourse would have to be delineated. And if ownership were then defined in such a way as to actually do detriment to the owner one assume rational people would not work to become “owner”.

I am a little confused about the argument in the first place. It seems both ‘sides’ are here using the concept property to justify positions as it concerns ethical or nonethical principles of society. The term property implies ‘society’ in the first place. Or more specifically civilsed society. In nature a lake is a lake, in a civilsed society the idea of individual ownership of the lake as a resourse would have to be delineated. And if ownership were then defined in such a way as to actually do detriment to the owner one assume rational people would not work to become “owner”.

I am questioning the justification of a claim to a naturally produced resource. I presume the ownership of lakes, forests, mineral deposits, etc., is worth the effort to aquire them, and I presume no one would object to owners who acted as caretakers of natural resources, e.g., privately owned parks… However, I question the “ethical” principle that allows one to claim property provided by nature, for the purpose of intentionally wasting it. The closest approximation of the principle at work is a scorched-earth policy, which I consider to be an act of war against ones neighbors.

  1. Everyone is entitled to their own preservation.

  2. Preservation requires source material, e.g. air, water, food, etc.

  3. Ones own preservation doesn’t imply a duty to the preservation of others.

  4. The justification for private property depends on;

4a) being acquired by ones own labor, or

4b) being inherited as property acquired by a predecessor’s labor.

  1. There is no justification for acquiring private property by theft.

Is everyone entitled to their own preservation, or the right to think and act in the manner that they choose?

Locke suggests, and I’m inclined to agree, that open access to natural resources works fine, so long as there remains enough for others to claim by their own labor for the preservation of their own lives.. Furthermore, individuals in an open access area wouldn’t want to draw the enmity of their neighbors by claiming resources beyond what was needed for self-preservation, or wasting resources others needed for self-preservation.

Thanks to the intervention of the State, we have yet to see true open access to natural resources, let alone true laissez faire capitalism. Over fishing of fisheries occurs because of the perception that one is cheating a bureaucracy rather than infringing on his neighbors right to acquire property. When dealing with bureaucracies, one adopts the policy of “use it or lose it”.

Economists, correct me if I’m wrong (I learned this in econ last year so it’s a bit fuzzy): ‘Common pool goods’ are not excludable (meaning that anyone can take the goods) and are rivalrous in consumption (meaning that if I fish all day and catch 100 fish, that leaves less fish in the water for everyone else). Because the price of the good is too low (or in this case, free) there’s no incentive for people to limit their intake of the good. They can take as much as they want, and it’s free!! Unless there’s some sort of regulation (ie: a lake owner limits the number of people who can fish in his lake, the number of hours they can fish, etc.) then the lake will quickly run out of fish, due to overfishing. The reason this overuse occurs is not because people think they’re cheating a ‘bureaucracy’ - it’s because 1) each person is acting in his own self-interest, and 2) the price of the good is too low. Further, people understand that if they don’t fish today, other people will, and the total amount of fish available for them to catch tomorrow will be reduced.

Where is this “First Come – Take all!” Did we discover a new continent when I wasn’t looking? Are the Feds giving away land to those who get there first?

DA said: “… if the initial claim is unjustified then whatever follows is built upon a false premise.”

How did property rights begin in America? Was it by the ‘first come - take all’ motto?

Is everyone entitled to their own preservation, or the right to think and act in the manner that they choose?

I don’t see this as a case of either/or; one implies the other.

Economists, correct me if I’m wrong (I learned this in econ last year so it’s a bit fuzzy): ‘Common pool goods’ are not excludable (meaning that anyone can take the goods) and are rivalrous in consumption (meaning that if I fish all day and catch 100 fish, that leaves less fish in the water for everyone else). Because the price of the good is too low (or in this case, free) there’s no incentive for people to limit their intake of the good. They can take as much as they want, and it’s free!! Unless there’s some sort of regulation (ie: a lake owner limits the number of people who can fish in his lake, the number of hours they can fish, etc.) then the lake will quickly run out of fish, due to overfishing. The reason this overuse occurs is not because people think they’re cheating a ‘bureaucracy’ - it’s because 1) each person is acting in his own self-interest, and 2) the price of the good is too low. Further, people understand that if they don’t fish today, other people will, and the total amount of fish available for them to catch tomorrow will be reduced.

The end result of this line of reasoning always legitimizes the regulation of morality; that people on their own can’t be trusted to do the right thing. Do people really need a benevolent tyrant, or landlord, in order to survive?

DA said: “… if the initial claim is unjustified then whatever follows is built upon a false premise.”

How did property rights begin in America? Was it by the ‘first come - take all’ motto?

Spot on.

I am questioning the justification of a claim to a naturally produced resource. I presume the ownership of lakes, forests, mineral deposits, etc., is worth the effort to aquire them, and I presume no one would object to owners who acted as caretakers of natural resources, e.g., privately owned parks… However, I question the “ethical” principle that allows one to claim property provided by nature, for the purpose of intentionally wasting it. The closest approximation of the principle at work is a scorched-earth policy, which I consider to be an act of war against ones neighbors.

Again the arguement seems almost specious, would not intentional wasting require effort(labor, money ect) , what rational person would purposely exort effort for absolutely no gain?

The North American aboriginies used resources provided by nature though without the concept of private property. They used force to protect their hunting and fishing grounds from rival tribes. The hobbesian nature of the premises of this arguement seem to show through.

As the derivation of ethics as a whole; morality is a set of principles needed to guide man’s actions. Morality should be seen as a set of ‘rules’ that if followed should help man achieve attainment of values. The ultimate value being the happiness of a life lived morally. Ethical arguements should not proceed from the premises of what is not permitted. True ethical behaviour is concerned with actions that are consistent with achieving values.

Again the arguement seems almost specious, would not intentional wasting require effort(labor, money ect) , what rational person would purposely exort effort for absolutely no gain?

The point is that not all property owners are rational, thus some consideration towards the ethical justification of a right to claim exclusive ownership of a natural resource is appropriate.

The North American aboriginies used resources provided by nature though without the concept of private property. They used force to protect their hunting and fishing grounds from rival tribes. The hobbesian nature of the premises of this arguement seem to show through.

I’ll have to brush up on my Hobbes, but initially I don’t see a contradiction with his view, “the true doctrine of the Lawes of Nature is the true Morall philosophie”.

As the derivation of ethics as a whole; morality is a set of principles needed to guide man’s actions. Morality should be seen as a set of ‘rules’ that if followed should help man achieve attainment of values. The ultimate value being the happiness of a life lived morally. Ethical arguements should not proceed from the premises of what is not permitted. True ethical behaviour is concerned with actions that are consistent with achieving values.

Ethically, I’m an advocate of moral reciprocity; “Do unto others…” being a positive declaration, and “Don’t do unto others…” being a prohibitive declaration. Depending on how you evaluate your ethical expectation, what is not permitted is essentially rephrasing what is permitted to achieve the same value. For example, “Don’t steal from others, because you wouldn’t want others to steal from you”, is just another way to say, “Respect others property, because you want others to respect your property.”

In terms of this topic I’m saying, it’s not appropriate to claim property one hasn’t labored to create, as private property, when the result is to deny others the same right to claim property. Someone laboring to create a reservoir is one thing; someone being the first to arrive at a lake is another.

The position you are in, however, is that if you are going to institutionalize this moral reciprocity so that leaves you with the task of explaining how you will do that. Who gets to decide what is acceptable, who gets to be judge and jury on this, and who gets to decide who will be punished or rewarded in this system?

I get where you are making the moral argument and in your oasis/desert scenario I think we would be working together quite well if it came down to helping some poor guy get water from some thug playing king of the hill. But if I were to accept the argument for this social contract as terms of entry into society then I would like to know how you intend to implement this requirement for people to “use it or lose it”. I have an image of Obama picking winners and losers dancing through my head so naturally you can see the concern.

The point is that not all property owners are rational, thus some consideration towards the ethical justification of a right to claim exclusive ownership of a natural resource is appropriate.

I’ll have to brush up on my Hobbes, but initially I don’t see a contradiction with his view, “the true doctrine of the Lawes of Nature is the true Morall philosophie”.

One of the main criticisms of Oism is that much of what Rand said was tautology.(not a position I hold). That being said, I do not think Oism has in it the concept of an unethical right. And given the Hobbs reference you stated in a sense I would agree that morality is metaphysical , as in the metaphysical nature of man.

What would be the disposition of a newly discovered, but heretofore unknown resevior constucted by someone but then abandoned, or would this fall back into the quality of natural resource?

The position you are in, however, is that if you are going to institutionalize this moral reciprocity so that leaves you with the task of explaining how you will do that. Who gets to decide what is acceptable, who gets to be judge and jury on this, and who gets to decide who will be punished or rewarded in this system?

The short answer is that I believe the institution of moral reciprocity in any given society is the recognition that all members of a community are personally responsible for the consequences of their own actions.

I get where you are making the moral argument and in your oasis/desert scenario I think we would be working together quite well if it came down to helping some poor guy get water from some thug playing king of the hill. But if I were to accept the argument for this social contract as terms of entry into society then I would like to know how you intend to implement this requirement for people to “use it or lose it”. I have an image of Obama picking winners and losers dancing through my head so naturally you can see the concern.

The principle of “use it or lose it” responds primarily to authoritarian bureaucracies. Members of even the toughest neighborhoods I’ve lived in tend to get along well enough, because knowing where you live and living where you live promotes a sense of live and let live. The premise I’m primarily arguing against, is the notion that a proprietor in the form of government or private enterprise is essential to managing natural resources in the first place. Neither entity labored to create the resource, so what actually justifies either claim to it?

In a true republic, the real threat is coercion; and one good way to avoid coercion is to promote information in lieu of regulation. Having a free press simply identifying deteriorating conditions, and naming the persons responsible, would be sufficient to generate the concern necessary for a community to manage their own resources; particularly if it was apparent there wasn’t some bureaucracy responsible for cleaning up after them.