Dr. Peikoff on which party to vote for: GOP or Democrat

Here’s something interesting from Donald Luskin’s Web page. It boils down to priorities, really, when it comes to voting. Mine is prosperity and national security. The rest is collateral. The left will rob us of prosperity and weaken America so I don’t vote for leftists. The right is not perfect. One should vote according to one’s priorities.

In particular interest to me is that I’d be paying, as a middle-income head of a family of four, about $2,500 more in income taxes annually without the GOP tax cuts. That’s a lot even for an upper-middle income family. As one of the 93 million American individuals who own a piece of our markets and our businesses, I also consider the power of that money when it is invested for the long-term and compounding takes effect. We as individuals can spend or invest that $2,500 more efficiently than government.

http://www.poorandstupid.com/2006_10_15_ch…117823731413421

FACTS ARE STUBBORN THINGS Our friend Dan Clifton at the American Shareholder Association sends along this “Harpers Index”-style look at the “Bush tax cuts by the numbers.” What more should any citizen or legislator need to know?

* $14,374,330,000,000 Total Increase in Household Wealth Since April 2003

* $5,700,000,000,000 Total Increase in Shareholder Wealth Since May 20, 2003

* $863,654,000,000 Total Amount of Tax Cuts Enacted Since Fiscal Year 2003

* $783,890,000,000 Total Amount of Additional Tax Cuts to be Returned to Taxpayers Through 2010

* $625,000,000,000 Total Increase in Federal Tax Revenues Since FY 2003

* $207,788,000,000 Reduction in the Deficit in the Past 29 Months Due to Stronger Economic Growth

* $98,600,000,000 Combined Income Gains for Shareholders From Dividend Increases & Tax Savings 03-05

* $62,000,000,000 Surplus of Capital Gains Tax Revenue Not Accounted For By Revenue Estimators

* $60,000,000,000 Deficit REDUCTION Since the Tax Cut Was Signed Into Law

* 300,001,643 Total Number of Americans benefiting from President Bush’s Tax Cut

* 91,000,000 Number of Individuals Owning Shares of Stock in America

* 23,000,000 Number of Small Businesses Benefiting from Income Tax Reductions

* 6,600,000 Number of Jobs Created Since the Tax Cut Was Signed Into Law

* 12,000 The Magic Number of the Dow Jones Industrial Index is an Arms Length Away

* $2,092 Tax Increase for a Family of Four With $50k of Income if Tax Cuts Are Repealed

* 200 Number of House Members Who Voted Against This Growth Generating Tax Cut

* 50 Number of US Senators Who Voted Against This Growth Generating Tax Cut

* 25 Number of Years Dividend Paying Companies Declined Prior to the 2003 Tax Cut

* 164.0% % Increase in the Dividend Tax Rate if the Income and Dividend Tax Cuts Expire

* 123.0% % Increase in Dividend Income and Share Repurchases Since 2003 Tax Cut

* 91.0% % Increase of Stock Ownership in the Bottom Quintile of Income Distribution Since 1995

* 74.0% % Increase in S&P 500 Companies Boosting Their Dividend Since 2002

* 65.0% % of Voters Who Were Investors in the 2004 Elections

* 51.2% % of Total Tax Cut “Cost” That Has Been Recouped From Higher Levels of Growth

* 14.0% % Margin of Victory for Republicans From Investor Voters in 2002 Elections

* 4.6% Unemployment Rate Which Continues To Disprove the Constant Economic Pessimism

* 3.7% % Average Quarterly GDP Growth Since Tax Cut Was Enacted (long run average is 3.3%)

Another point is that even though socialism has been discredited, environmentalism has not. So maybe the left do have some intact philosophical base.

This points in the correct direction, though I would not limit the concern to just classical socialist political matters. There is a vast world of leftist views that are just waiting to be exploited – multiculturalism, environmentalism, veganism, epistemological nihilism. And not just exploited, but made into law. While the right may, for the most part, stand for evangelical Protestantology, that is a well-defined evil. Leftists are predominantly anti-ideologists – the other name for them is nihilist. Combatting nihilism is vastly harder that nailing jelly to a tree. The danger of the left is their little-appreciated non-political base, namely their rejection of the idea “philosophical base”.

Antonio, your attacks on Dr. Peikoff are unwarranted and unjust. Peikoff is expressing a view (one I disagree with), but he is offering reasons for that view; he is not saying, “I’m Leonard Peikoff, and I say vote for the Democrats so you should do so on my authority.” Peikoff is not the “Pope” of Objectivism, and never claims to be.

I think it largely depends on what positions you’re voting for and the specific people that are running for those positions. Since Democrat and Republican (not to mention “right” and “left”) are not really ideological terms, you’re not going to be able to support an ideological position by voting consistently one way or the other.

I think it largely depends on what positions you’re voting for and the specific people that are running for those positions. Since Democrat and Republican (not to mention “right” and “left”) are not really ideological terms, you’re not going to be able to support an ideological position by voting consistently one way or the other.

I think the former idea (that it matters about the specific people) is correct only insofar as you consider all of the specific people running; and not for particular positions, but for positions in a particular governmental unit. If you can integrate the totality of Democrats, or Republicans, running for US House, and conclude that the Democrat House “position” is better than the Republican one, then it would make sense to vote for the Democratic party House candidate regardless of the candidate’s individual beliefs. I don’t generally expect a Democrat to vote contrary to the party position (nor do I expect that from a Republican); so while there is no ideology behind being a Democrat vs. a Republican, there is a convenient position, which you can decide if you can support. Assuming, of course, there’s a relationship between what’s said this year during the campaign vs. how the brands are distinguished the following year.

Another point is that even though socialism has been discredited, environmentalism has not. So maybe the left do have some intact philosophical base.

Beyond that, the Left has embraced environmentalism as a form of religion. Michael Crichton has some interesting thoughts on the issue: http://www.michaelcrichton.net/speeches/sp…es_quote05.html

I can’t agree with his blanket condemnation of people who vote Republican or abstain from voting. Didn’t Rand, at one point, abstain from voting?

I also can’t agree that religious conservatism is more of a threat. Socialism is a much bigger and more immediate threat, IMO.

It is too late to modify my initial response but after further contemplation, I am not sure if I agree wholeheartedly with the second to last sentence from Dr. Peikoff, considering that prominent Objectivists like Harry Binswanger endorsed President Bush in 2004. But even then I found Dr. Peikoff’s argument to be more persuasive than Dr. Binswanger’s.

That statement also rubbed me the wrong way. It comes across as arrogant and sophmorist, rather than measured and philosophical. Sort of like “if you don’t believe the way I say you should, you’re an ass”. (I can’t believe I’m disagreeing with the Good Doctor, but his statement a few years ago that he voted for Kerry did put me on that path).

While there are many that feel that G.W.B. is on a transparent mission to grab power, and that his latest proposals to suspend habeus corpus are nothing more than a return to Nazism in our time, we have seen what physical harm the Demoncrats have wrought on this nation’s citizens, including the folks at Waco, TX, and Ruby Ridge, and others. There were more high profile abridgements of human rights during the Clinton/Reno years than any other year since the Japanese internment during WWII.

If these things are true about Mr. Bush and his attempt to dismantle our constitutionally protected freedoms, then the Good Doctor might wish to be more careful and less direct with his attacks on Bush, lest he might have another Library of Congress type of experience, only worse. If Bush is that dangerous (and there are some who swear that he is the Devil incarnate), then more subtle means of educating the public about dictatorships and the dangers of theocratic government need to be done, Ayn Rand style, not this mudslinging style that Dr. Peikoff seems to have stooped to of late.

I fail to see how making Nancy Pelosi the third most powerful member of the federal government and Harry Reid the majority leader of the US Senate helps our cause.

I don’t think either party will do much to curtail Islamist attacks, but I also don’t think either will do so little as to really put me at terrible risk… the Islamists simply don’t have that kind of power; yet. Yes, the war is a threat, but the fact is that our enemy is still quite weak. It is simply that we do not properly fight back. If I lived in France or Sweden it would be a different matter…

I don’t think either party will do much to combat the growth of the welfare state; Bush has grown it more than Clinton ever did. Read Decline and Fall and you will know it is pointless to vote republican to protect your pocketbook.

There is a vast world of leftist views that are just waiting to be exploited… multiculturalism, environmentalism, veganism, epistemological nihilism.

This is my major concern. Dr. Peikoff’s states that Socialism has had its day, but I need only look across the Atlantic to England to see what it would be like to live under the Democratic party. They disarm the populace and let criminals loose in the streets. Anyone who attempts to defend himself against crime - even in his own home - will suffer the wrath of the law, while the criminal will go free. That sort of situation is a real danger to my very life.

What I need to know is: what does he mean when he declares the left’s ideologies to be dead? How does he know this? He says Socialism is dead, but what about all the other ideologies of the left? And if they are also dead, how does this make them less threatening when the evidence I see is that they are perfectly capable of making European nations into miserable hell-holes?

I need to know more. When is his DIM book coming out?!?

Oh, and I’ll second Lazlo’s comment that Antonio’s accusations are inappropriate.

If my understanding is correct, intrincism too is based on the “primacy of consciousness”. Intrincism is disguised subjectivism because it is ultimately based on whims rather than reality.

Perhaps I should not have described my substitution of “primacy of consciousness” for “intrinsicism” as an error when being imprecise would have been sufficient. However, intrinsicism is definitely distinct from subjectivism. Intrinsicism would be assuming faulty premises that might not necessarily have a basis in reality and then using (sound) deductive reasoning to glean knowledge. Prime examples of intrinsicists are Plato and Leibiniz. On the other hand, subjectivism is just being plain inconsistent. For example, the idea “that may be true for you, but that is not true for me.”

With all due respect, I think Dr Peikoff is losing his grip on reality.

What happened to all the ominous changes the last election was supposed to bring? Where is the public swing towards theocracy?

I think gay marriage is an interesting indicator of the threat of theocracy. From March 1996 to June 2006, support for gay marriage rose from 27 to 39%. 35% of republicans and 37% of democrats support civil unions of some sort. Support is dramatically higher among younger people. Since Bush’s anti-gay marriage amendment, several states now recognize civil unions or domestic unions.

Where’s the proof? North Korea has the bomb, and I have more faith in the incompetence of George Bush than Kim Jong-Il. Really, I think it comes down to incompetence – who’s most likely to screw up at radical changes while good ideas have a chance to spread through our culture.

By the way, the #10 and #11 bookson the New York Times nonfiction best seller list argue for atheism.

Dr. Peikoff’s states that Socialism has had its day, but I need only look across the Atlantic to England to see what it would be like to live under the Democratic party.

But compare this to Republican theocracy and its foreign analog, Iran.

Today, we talk about the threat of socialism - communism is so outmoded as to not even be a real consideration. Today, “liberal” is a pejorative term. Socialism isn’t dead, but it’s been beaten to a pulp.

On the other hand, theocratic ideals are thriving. Bible-based laws against abortion, homosexuality, for discretionary snooping, etc - these things “aren’t that bad” so long as the economy’s humming and no one’s attacking us…

Unlike Democratic socialism, Republican theocracy is rarely checked in our society, either ideologically or politically. I can’t speak for Peikoff, but this is why I think the Republican faults are more dangerous right now.

I don’t think either party will do much to curtail Islamist attacks, but I also don’t think either will do so little as to really put me at terrible risk…

Agreed.

I also agree with some of Peikoff’s points, but not all of them. How can I (as a NJ resident) pull the lever for Menendez - a corrupt, tax raising, anti-war sleezebag - over Tom Kean Jr. who voted for tax cuts and privitization of SS reforms?

Like a previous poster wrote: the economy is great. I give (as well as others like Larry Kudlow) credit to the Bush tax cuts which have juiced economic growth in America that isn’t occuring other Western nations. Seems like we are the best of the worst, which isn’t that bad.

I vote with my pocketbook, not because Im afraid of crosses and praying. Perhaps Dr. Peikoff has to be reminded that the Democrats have their own version of the “religious left” and morality police which potentially is much worse than what a neo-conservative has to offer.

Also, I agree that politics is local. Most of what effects you is at the township or county level. I’m a firm believer that national politicans are pretty much centerists that float wherever reelection will push them. If cutting taxes is popular, then even the liberals will vote for taxcuts. But, property taxes - for instance - are really controlled by state and local government entities. What about enforcement of the law? Again, another local issue.

With all due respect, I think Dr Peikoff is losing his grip on reality.

I was going to say something like this, but figured I would get flamed for it. I remember thinking this when he endorsed Kerry. He’s in his mid-70’s after all…it’s about the right time for him to start suffering from dementia and senility.

With all due respect, I think Dr Peikoff is losing his grip on reality.

I’m more worried he’s seen a trend the rest of us have not, than that he is losing grip. He’s at that age in his life where is able to perform very wide integrations.

What happened to all the ominous changes the last election was supposed to bring? Where is the public swing towards theocracy?

If one of the biggest government spending increases on socialized medicine - prescription drug plan, under the guise of “compassionate conservatism” doesn’t convince you I’m not sure what will. Peikoff isn’t talking about an overt swing, but it’s clear to me that when something like compassionate conservatism, which is nothing more than leftist socialist altruism recast in CHRISTIAN terms, can gain enough hold that such a bill as prescription drugs can be passed by Republicans, then the signs are there.

I was of the same “aw, the Republicans aren’t so bad” attitude until OCON this year and Brad Thompson’s talk on neo-conservatism. His follow up essay at TOS carries similar themes. Republican inability to control govt spending is not an accident. It is very much idea driven. I notice the details of this more and more.

There is a religions swing that is starting to take hold, and you can see it in mainstream conservative culture. Talk radio now has Medved and Ingraham, both avowed religionists. And the neo-conservatives are cooperating. As I’ve said, I don’t think Peikoff is off his rocker, he is dead on about the trends. This is just a debate about when, not if. Yes, I’m still voting R this year, but there will come a time…

What if conservatives got everything they wanted?

  • No gambling

  • No drinking

  • No pornography

  • No blasphemy

  • No abortions

  • No contraception

  • Prayer in schools

It wouldn’t be great, but it wouldn’t be the end of the world.

A friend of mine who votes Democrat and I (who vote Republican) have this argument. He says to me “I vote D because the Republicans want to legislate morality.” To which I say “I vote D because I look at my tax bill every year and realize that the left is already doing it.” :lol:

On another forum (now closed) we had a running list of bills and law enforcement examples where liberal politicans or cities (San Fran, Seattle) took “moral stands” against “social ills”. One, IIRC, wsa a stand against lapdances in Washington by a liberal politican that cited some religious moral reasoning.

The right-wing does not have the monopoly on religiousity in America. Look through any bookstore and you’ll find probably dozen books in the current events and religious sections on liberal politics and religion (one that stands out is “God’s Politics”). After all, Christianity isn’t “conservative”. It’s a great base for socialism, and Christianity has replaced Marxism as the new reasoning for increased government control.

At the same time, we should look to thwart Republican whack-jobs like Santorum from PA but support good Republicans like Kean Jr. and George Allen (at least as good as they get… I’m a fan of Allen). Again, how can a free-marketer vote for Menendez, a corrupt, anti-market, anti-war, anti-reform dirtbag that was appointed to the Senate by his crony Corzine (who both happen to live in the same apartment building in Hoboken, NJ)? I mean, I know an informed Democrat who says that Menendez is as dirty as they come.

If one of the biggest government spending increases on socialized medicine - prescription drug plan, under the guise of “compassionate conservatism” doesn’t convince you I’m not sure what will.

To me, “compassionate conservativism” is nothing more than the typical pandering the right does to leftist ideals.

There is a religions swing that is starting to take hold, and you can see it in mainstream conservative culture.

I see this as more of a polarization that began with Reagan and is fueled by talk radio. It may have ominous overtones, but what has it achieved? On the plus side of the polarization, the secular side is radicalizing as well:

http://www.wired.com/news/wiredmag/0,71985-0.html

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/14638243/site/newsweek/

http://www.religioustolerance.org/chr_prac2.htm