Dr. Peikoff on which party to vote for: GOP or Democrat

I am in favor of a Democratic congress proposing big spending and having it vetoed by a Republican president, as against a Republican congress proposing big spending and having it waved through by a Republican prez. So maybe it would be ok the Dems won back congress.

That’s fine as long as the Repugnants can take back Congress when Hilary moves back to 1600 Pennsylvania. Otherwise we’d have a Democrap congress’ spending being waved through (hell, whipped along like a racehorse down the stretch) by a Democrap president. Ask anyone who was around during the Lyndon Johnson years what that’s like.

To me, “compassionate conservativism” is nothing more than the typical pandering the right does to leftist ideals.

Read the link to the Brad Thompson’s essay. What if it’s no longer pandering, but an indicator of a shift in ideas? You may be right, but then who would I expect to spot a real idea shift earlier, but someone who believes in the Objectivist theory of history, and has studied it himself in depth. For this reason, I give Peikoff some leeway.

I’m not sure about a “polarization that began with Reagan and is fueled by talk radio”. That sounds to me like an effect. Things don’t just polarize by themselves without a cause, right? What’s the cause? Actually, Rand hated Reagan specifically because of his religiosity. One would wonder if that doesn’t bolster my point.

It’s a tough issue, no doubt. Brad Thompson’s essay convinced me.

A friend of mine who votes Democrat and I (who vote Republican) have this argument. He says to me “I vote D because the Republicans want to legislate morality.” To which I say “I vote D because I look at my tax bill every year and realize that the left is already doing it.” :lol:

Even in a Republican dominated congress the left is still managing to usher their liberal, tax-and-spend, agenda through! There is no stopping these guys! (sarcasm). Of course, I am sure that you were referring to a time when there were more Democrats with legislative power but I still wanted to be silly.

Otherwise, good posts. I am still voting Democrat this November in terms of choosing a Senator because Katherine Harris is running for the Republicans in the state where I am registered to vote.

Actually, Rand hated Reagan specifically because of his religiosity.

I daresay that if she were alive today, her opinion of him would be that his positives far outweigh his negatives.

I daresay that if she were alive today, her opinion of him would be that his positives far outweigh his negatives.

I daresay that you are wrong on that point.

Rand died before the Reaganomic revolution and before the downfall of the Soviet Union, in which he played so instrumental a part. Whatever flaws Reagan had with regards to religion are dwarfed by the economic good that he did for this country, not to mention the fall of the Iron Curtain.

Organization based question here, if Peikoff is the legal and philisophical heir to Ayn Rand, and considered the foremost authority on the topic, why does his most recent statement about voting Democrat (and how not doing so would demonstrate that you have “no understanding of the practical role of philosophy in man’s actual life—which means that he does not understand the philosophy of Objectivism”) get posted on capmag.com but not on the ARI website? What are the factors in the ARI that are preventing him from making that statement in that venue?

I’m more worried he’s seen a trend the rest of us have not, than that he is losing grip. He’s at that age in his life where is able to perform very wide integrations.

For my love of Dr. Peikoff and his work, I hope you’re right. For the welfare of myself and others in this country, I hope you’re wrong.

Organization based question here, if Peikoff is the legal and philisophical heir to Ayn Rand, and considered the foremost authority on the topic, why does his most recent statement about voting Democrat (and how not doing so would demonstrate that you have “no understanding of the practical role of philosophy in man’s actual life—which means that he does not understand the philosophy of Objectivism”) get posted on capmag.com but not on the ARI website? What are the factors in the ARI that are preventing him from making that statement in that venue?

The Ayn Rand Institute is incorporated as a 501©3 non-profit educational foundation. As such, it is prohibited by law from engaging in direct political advocacy, which would include the endorsement of one slate of candidates over another in an election.

Otherwise, good posts. I am still voting Democrat this November in terms of choosing a Senator because Katherine Harris is running for the Republicans in the state where I am registered to vote.

Yikes, I heard her on Medved the other day. Yikes. Here is an example of the religious right taking over. If I was in Fla, I’d vote Democrat just to keep her out of office.

Michigan goes as Detroit votes, so my little republican vote is not enough to change our democratic senators, who are avowed socialists (Stabenow and Levin). Luckily my representative district is dominated by my company, and therefore always goes pro-business (“Goldwater”) Republican.

I’ll probably end up voting Republican. Yeah, Republicans suck. But I shudder to think of the things the Democrats would do to economic freedom, were they to get control of Congress.

If that means I don’t understand the prinicples of philsophy and whatnot, so be it. I’ve finally secured a real-world job and will be in a financially precarious situation for the first few years. Those are years when I sure as hell don’t want those Bush tax cuts “rolled back.”

I’ll probably end up voting Republican. Yeah, Republicans suck. But I shudder to think of the things the Democrats would do to economic freedom, were they to get control of Congress.

If that means I don’t understand the prinicples of philsophy and whatnot, so be it. I’ve finally secured a real-world job and will be in a financially precarious situation for the first few years. Those are years when I sure as hell don’t want those Bush tax cuts “rolled back.”

If I was to vote, I’d go with Libertarian, just to send a message to the other two parties. Anyone but the demoncrats and the republicans!

I’m actually considering that. Their foreign policy makes me not want to, b/c I don’t want to send the message that my vote is an anti-war vote. Then again, the anti-war vote goes to the Democrats, so I figure a Libertarian vote might be perceived as a vote for smaller government.

And I bet Peikoff would call voting Libertarian worse than voting Republican! I kid, I kid.

I’m more with Trachinski and the “Cox and Forkum”-type of us. But again, all politics is local.

I can see where Peikoff and Tracinski are coming from as regards national Congressional elections, but what about the local elections? Ohio, for example, has a gubernatorial election this year where the Republican incumbent (who was convicted of major improprieties a few years ago) is at his term limit. Ohio was pivotal in the last Presidential election. The candidates for governor are Ken Blackwell (R, former Sec’y of State, was accused of rigging the Presidential election because, while sitting as sec’y of state, he was also chair of the “Committee to Re-Elect George W. Bush”) and Ted Strickland (D, deep blue, whose running platform consists of promises to force through minimum wage increases and socialized medicine for Ohioans at a time when Ohio’s economy is tumbling, and is favored to win). There’s also a Libertarian writ large on the ballot who has some 1% of the polls and whose major campaign strategy consists of complaining publicly and loudly about being left out of the formal debates.

The Democrats are watching this election closely, because Ohio has had a Republican governor since 1991, and is considered a Presidential swing state. They’d be giddy with delight to pick up Ohio’s gubernatorial. Strickland is already billing his potential win as a ‘mandate’ to push through his major socialist reforms here. Frankly, I’m frightened of him. But Blackwell’s a real slimebag who totally botched his job as Sec’y of State (not just with the 2004 Presidential election thing, but a bunch of other minor scandals and major lawsuits).

I’m disinclined to vote for Strickland. He poses a more direct and immediate threat to me. On the other hand, not enough Ohio General Assembly seats are up for grabs to affect the Republican majoritiy there (both houses have or nearly have a 2/3 Republican majority). Strickland could be all puff and no stuff.

Luckily the national senate race is less troubling. Mike DeWine (R, Inc.) v. Sherrod Brown (D). Brown is favored in the polls. The campaign has been very muddy and very expensive. It makes me feel dirty to do it, but I’ll probably vote for Brown. DeWine’s a major power broker for the Republicans.

Whose argument do you think applies better to local elections: Peikoff’s, or Tracinski’s?

-Q

And I bet Peikoff would call voting Libertarian worse than voting Republican! I kid, I kid.

You may be kidding, but you’re absolutely right. He would consider it worse. That’s one Objectivist stance I can’t understand. For all their flaws, the Libertarians are exponentially better than either of the major parties, and I would love to see them start winning some national elections.

Exponentiallly better? Badnarik ran on a platform of paying reparations to Iraq. The LP also believes in dismantaling the CIA and FBI, and refusing ever to fight a war except to repel an enemy from our borders.

I would love to see some Libertarians in public offices as well, but that’s not happening any time soon in my area.

If only I could justfy voting Libertarian for my state’s gubernatorial this year… but I can’t. Not in Massachusetts (historically blue) where the Democratic candidate is promising driver’s licenses and public schooling for illegal immigrants… I will do everything I can to keep him out of that office. The Republican party is the only one with a chance of keeping him out, so that’s the way I’m going on this one. Haven’t decided yet for the national elections, though.

This is one of those rare times when I wish there was a divine being just so I could pray to someone for help. **Puts on eyepatch and pirate hat** O Flying Spaghetti Monster, please extend Your noodly appendages towards the state of Massachusetts on November 7th, and turn it as light pink as a thin coating of the sauce You live in… rAmen.

I would love to see some Libertarians in public offices as well, but that’s not happening any time soon in my area.

I don’t think it would make a damn bit of difference. The 1998 Libertarian candidate for President, Ron Paul, has been elected to Congress from a district in Texas several times now. His net impact on national politics has been exactly zero.

With all due respect, I think Dr Peikoff is losing his grip on reality.

In other words, without the slightest shred of respect at all.

I’m in strong agreement with Dr. Peikoff for reasons that I’ll articulate on NoodleFood in the next few days. In the meantime, is it really necessary to point out the huge difference between strongly disagreeing with Dr. Peikoff and publicly suggesting that he’s going senile or nuts?!?

Dr. Peikoff has longstanding reasons for his views going back twenty years. If you listen to his “DIM Hypothesis” course, as well as his lecture on “America Versus Americans,” you might glean some slight understanding of them. That’s what changed my mind on the matter, as well as reading and listening to Yaron Brook, Craig Biddle, John Lewis, and Bradley Thompson. (Or maybe they’re all “losing their grip on reality” too?)

In utter disgust,

Diana Hsieh