Evasion, Honest Errors, And Justice

I could be COMPLETELY wrong in this, but I believe the basic question to be a matter of someone saying,

Honest “mistake”

Person 1- I believe in god because I was raised to do so.

Person 2 - There is no god because these reasons (proceeds to use reason/logic to explain to person 1)

Person 1- You may be right, I need to think more about this

Evasion/evil/immorality

Person 1- I believe in god because I was raised to do so.

Person 2 - There is no god because these reasons (proceeds to use reason/logic to explain to person 1)

Person 1- No! You’re wrong, YOu’re going to burn in Hell!

At least, that’s my interpretation of the question.

I could be COMPLETELY wrong in this, but I believe the basic question to be a matter of someone saying,

Honest “mistake”

Person 1- I believe in god because I was raised to do so.

Person 2 - There is no god because these reasons (proceeds to use reason/logic to explain to person 1)

Person 1- You may be right, I need to think more about this

Evasion/evil/immorality

Person 1- I believe in god because I was raised to do so.

Person 2 - There is no god because these reasons (proceeds to use reason/logic to explain to person 1)

Person 1- No!  You’re wrong, YOu’re going to burn in Hell!

At least, that’s my interpretation of the question.

You’re almost completely wrong. Either situation could be an honest mistake.

What makes it evil is if a person agrees that fact A is true, and at the same time denies that fact A is true (often, by means of skirting around fact A and avoiding it completely).

Like, for example: AqAd who has stated explicitly that God is supernatural, but then asserts that God is knowable through reason (which is only a property of something that is natural – supernatural means “unknowable through reason”) – clearly evading the contradiction in the two statements, despite having it pointed out to him in every way imaginable.

Unless the person has stated two contradictory facts as being true and then proceeds to ignore the contradiction, they can say “No! You’re wrong and will burn in hell!” and still be making an honest mistake.

Note that agnostics understand this implicitly and refuse to take a stand on pretty much ANY fact of reality so they always have a way out without stating a contradiction.

You’re almost completely wrong. Either situation could be an honest mistake.

What makes it evil is if a person agrees that fact A is true, and at the same time denies that fact A is true (often, by means of skirting around fact A and avoiding it completely).

Like, for example: AqAd who has stated explicitly that God is supernatural, but then asserts that God is knowable through reason (which is only a property of something that is natural – supernatural means “unknowable through reason”) – clearly evading the contradiction in the two statements, despite having it pointed out to him in every way imaginable.

This assumes that the “evader” understands the contradiction. If the evader isn’t

convinced of the logic of the “explainer”, then he’s still “innocent” (stupid perhaps,

but innocent of actual evil).

The “unconvinced innocent” is usually bewildered and confused after an encounter

like this.

The “evil doer” is usually VERY hostile..! :stuck_out_tongue:

Unless the person has stated two contradictory facts as being true and then proceeds to ignore the contradiction, they can say “No! You’re wrong and will burn in hell!” and still be making an honest mistake.

Note that agnostics understand this implicitly and refuse to take a stand on pretty much ANY fact of reality so they always have a way out without stating a contradiction.

Agnostics are defacto evil, as they knowingly evade ANY and every

contradiction.

See an agnostic, shoot an agnostic. That’s my policy.

(( “Shoot” is a metaphor, for the satiricaly challenged amongst you. :wink: ))

-Iakeo

Well, stupidly enough, that was what I meant. I apologize for my poor use of language to convey what I meant.

Well, stupidly enough, that was what I meant.  I apologize for my poor use of language to convey what I meant.

Nah,.. I was just agreeing with you. :slight_smile:

Your usage was fine. I’m the moron that had to reiterate the obvious that you stated so well.

Just my ego, I suppose.

But then,.. we LIKE egos here, don’t we..!!?

I love this place more every day..!! :slight_smile:

-Iakeo

You can never actually know what another person is thinking, only what they say, and what they do. Their actual thinking doesn’t affect you, only, again, what they say, and what they do. Endless efforts to infer what someone else is thinking can only make you confused and doubtful.

Someone that acts and speaks in accordance with bad philosophy is much worse than someone who merely has internalized some examples of it and acts in a different manner entirely.

You can never actually know what another person is thinking, only what they say, and what they do.  Their actual thinking doesn’t affect you, only, again, what they say, and what they do.  Endless efforts to infer what someone else is thinking can only make you confused and doubtful.

Someone that acts and speaks in accordance with bad philosophy is much worse than someone who merely has internalized some examples of it and acts in a different manner entirely.

“Just the facts, Ma’am. Just the facts.”

The essence of “Political Correctness”, and why we all (well, most) of us hate it so,

is the dishonesty and “appeasing of observed evil” that it embodies.

If you “make nice”, you are being evil. Pure and simple.

If you are attacking to harm without reasoned reason, you are being evil.

If you are stating and/or acting the truth, then you are acting properly.

Others will take anything you say or do as they will. And you have no way to

make them interpret it “as you want them to”.

But,.. why would you want to? It’d be a terribly boring world if you could. :slight_smile:

..though we might do with a LITTLE more of that type of boredom, I suppose.

-Iakeo