My purpose is that of introspection. I am trying to understand what an inherently dishonest idea is.
First, I don’t know how that relates to your goal of qualifying the idea. Unless you mean quantifying it, but even then this is not a numeric property so quantifying inherent dishonesty doesn’t mean anything. Or are you thinking that some ideas might be more egregiously dishonest than others? Let me assume that’s the direction you’re going. In that case, I suppose the way of quantifying degree of dishonestly is the extent to which contradictions must be accepted to hold the idea. But second, I urge you to limit your use of introspection, when it comes to things about reality – you can’t introspect what communism says, but you can study it to learn what it says. Or, you can observe its effects. (The visible contrast between eastern and western Europe, post-liberation, was a clear demonstration of that effect which anyone can appreciate).
An inherently dishonest idea is one that a rational person cannot both grasp and integrate with everything else they know, without ignoring a contradiction. Take Burgess’s example of Andrei – he did not actually grasp what communism was. Karl Marx, on the other hand, did, since he created communism. Lenin, Stalin and Mao also fully understood communism. They understood the central ethical demand of communism, that no man has any purpose in existing except as a tool to serve an undefined and non-existent abstraction, “the people”, and that your primary ethical obligation is to sacrifice your life for – nothing. Andrei did not understand this (and the consequences of his non-comprehension were tragic).
I understand that it is not an “intrinsic property of the sound” that defines the ‘honesty’ of a concept. My quetion is: Is it possible for two people to hold a specific concept as a result of two different processes (error/evasion)?
Yes – above is an example. Let me give you another example. As you know, taking the writings of another person and presenting them as your own without attributing them to the author is plagiarism, which is a serious form of intellectual dishonesty in our culture. In some (Asian) cultures, copying without attribution is not considered a serious offense. Now, in my first teaching job, a foreign student plagiarised some material, and when I said “But that’s plagiarism!”, the student said “I see. What is ‘plagiarism’. How do you spell it?” An innocent error. Any American student who has grown up being lectured for years on plagiarism and the value of intellectual property cannot honestly hold. The distinction really comes down to what you know. In the western context, personal intellectual achievement is a value that is to be rewarded, and a specific form of reward is recognition, following rules established by society. If you don’t know that there is such a rule, it is an error to break that rule, and not evasion.
Burgess’s identification, in terms of concept stealing (using reason to reject reason) boils the issue down to its essential.