Tonight I have been reading an essay written by Andrew Bernstein, “Villainy: An Analysis of the Nature of Evil.” You can read it here on his website.
During my reading I had found something that I had ever encountered before in the O’world - “the metaphysics of evil” or “the ethics of evil” :
If the morality of sacrifice is the ethics of evil, then the primacy of consciousness is the metaphysics of evil.
We know from Bernstein’s essay here and also from OPAR that there are three versions of the primacy of consciousness: the supernatural, the social, and the personal.
All three versions of the self-sacrifice ethics rest upon what Ayn Rand calls the primacy of consciousness approach to metaphysics."
Correct, his essay shows why they are and so did OPAR before it. Objectivism rejects the primacy of consciousness view entirely, because it is the ONLY philosophic system in the history of philosophy that has consistently upheld that view throughout all of the branches of its philosophy:
There were once Western philosophers who upheld the primacy of existence; notably, such ancient Greek giants as Parmenides and Aristotle. But even they were not consistent in this regard. (Aristotle, for example, describes his Prime Mover as a consciousness conscious only of itself, which serves as the cause of the world’s motion.) There has never yet been a thinker who states the principle explicitly, then applies it methodically in every branch of philosophy, with no concession to any version of its antithesis. This is precisely what Ayn Rand does. Her philosophy is the primacy of existence come to full, systematic expression in Western thought for the first time.
And in OPAR Dr. Peikoff shows us the primacy of existence in every branch in Objectivism. I never noticed that before either until I searched it tonight.
Has anyone heard of the primacy of consciousness being referred to as the metaphysics of evil? I absolutely agree with that identification. The ethics of evil is self-sacrifice: altruism.
Also in the article (which is also available at ARI Bookstore in audio version) he says that of the three types of parasites (which are all fashioned from the three versions of the primacy of consciousness) the collectivist one is the most evil type of parasite there is of the three, because the others are not “complete attacks” against man’s mind as this type is. What are your thoughts on that? I do not see Bernstein in error, but I have been thinking a little more about our upcoming election after reading this, and still think that what Dr. Peikoff has said previously about the last election and what little he has said so far on his site specifically about the upcoming Pres. election, I still agree with. I see no problem with agreeing with either at the same time. Your thoughts?