The gist I get about Facebook is nothing more than “everyone else is doing it!” Connecting with people from the past is only plausible based on the idea that everyone else is doing it. Not because Facebook is somehow amazingly unique, but because it’s popular. There is little incentive to get into Facebook beyond that reason. I in fact use my google mail account for contact lists, instant message, photo album, etc. If I want a place to show a resume, I’ll either email it, or make a web page. So that point is quite irrelevant. Message board features are irrelevant to me; I’d much prefer to have a moderated forum to discuss topics most interesting to me.
The only essential feature to Facebook is the sharing, and that’s what really drives me *away* from Facebook. Otherwise, I’d be indifferent. I’m not even sure I’d call it sharing as much as a narcissistic announcement that people are automatically interested in what you have to say. When personal information is simply laid out like that, there is a decreased incentive to get to know someone if they tell you what they like and dislike before you even say a word. I’m not opposed to people filling out profiles like those on this site, but with Facebook, the purpose of the site *is* the profile. At least on a forum like this, or on every other forum I know of, the purpose of a profile is really just to indicate some additional interests to people who likely already share some similarities with. For some, a forum/website/whatever is common interest enough so sometimes a profile isn’t even needed at all.
I very much see it as an individual vs. collective thing. Faceborg (no, I didn’t come up with that term) comes across as a way to merge into the hive mind. It isn’t so much about being an individual as much as it is trying to be a part of something. Personally, I have no need or desire to let anyone know very much about me beyond what I have already listed on my profile here. I’d much rather people *ask* me questions. I’d gladly share music tastes with someone, but I don’t want anyone to know what those tastes are unless I’m asked, since it implies interest in me as an individual. What Facebook does is simplify and de-personalize that process. Friends of mine still have more to learn about me, and not all friends know the same things about me. I discriminate the information I tell people to a high degree because there are friends who I value more than others. I don’t believe there are multiple “levels” of friendship on Facebook; either someone is a friend, or they’re not. In truth, there are many categories of friendship. To post things on Facebook - even if you set it so only “friends” can view - suggests a lack of discrimination about friendships. I see that as very destructive, and promotes egalitarianism implicitly.
Plus, the medium promotes shortening of thoughts, when that is a *main* method of communication. Even if full sentences are involved, you don’t need to think in a manner of organizing a lengthy chain of thought. Most Facebook posts I’ve see are no more than a few sentences. If you wondered how to make Newspeak a real language, and make Idiocracy a reality, Faceborg is the first step. And Twitter, can’t forget Twitter…
What I would love is to see more of is people connecting on an intellectual level, rather than on the simplistic level of what kind of movies and tv shows you like - the only thing Faceborg is really any useful for.