Fleet of Worlds

I’ve just finished reading “Fleet or Worlds” by Larry Niven and Edward M. Lerner.

This book has few surprises for Niven readers. It’s set on the Puppeteer “Fleet” 200 years prior to the events fo “Ringworld.” As such it holds few surprises, although it does expand on some aspects of Puppeteer society. It’s not a prequel to “Ringworld,” either, although some revelations shown in “Ringworld” and its sequels are given in “Fleet,” such as the manner in which Puppeteers mate and reproduce.

The novel deals with the relationship between Puppeteers and a human colony existing in one of their worlds. Now, that’s ok, but the prologue does interfere with latter developments. The prologue takes place 600 years before the novel aboard a human starship, the “Long Pass.” So we already know why the humans are inhabiting a Puppeteer world and how they got there. When some humans begin to question their sparse history, we also know they’ve been lied to.

Another problem is that the novel attempts to stay faithful to other Known Space stories. That’s good, as SF readers are notorious nitpickers and would howl if the continuity were breached. So there’s mention of the Core Explosion, Sigmund Ausfaller (from the Beowulf Schaefer stories), Dr. Forward from “Borderlans of Sol,” and a few other things. No mention of the “Long Shot,” tough.

One of the novel’s protagonists is the Puppeteer Nessus, whom Niven readers should know well by now. The other is a human “Colonist” named Kirsten Quinn-Kovacs, who’s a math genius and who begins to question the Puppeteer version of human history. The two interact a lot, given Kirsten is part of a crew of the first Colonist scout ship; these are ships that scout ahead for the fleet. Puppeteers being cowardly, it makes sense for them to use humans instead. Of course the thing backfires.

In their first mission, three humans and Nessus scout a new species known as the Gw’oth(sp?). Niven outdoes himself in a new, strange species, but ultimately the Gw’oth and their impressive technological progress are of no consequence to the story. The real story is what happens when the Colonists learn about their past, and how they go about it. Plus a filling of Nessus’ back-story, including his work on Earth and his relationship to the Hindmost (I apologize if I’m talking about this book as though I were an avid Niven reader, but that’s just what I am).

Overall the novel feels like the setup for a bigger story. Hopefully that’s just what it is, as there is a second novel concerning this era, called “Juggler of Worlds.” I’ll know more when I read it. One thing about niven is that he does sequels and long series, but he doesn’t plan them ahead. That’s why there are decades between “Ringworld” and its sequels, and between “Mote” and its sequel. Most likely “Juggler” complements “Fleet” and that will be that.

Next I’m reading “Building Harlequin’s Moon” by Niven and Brenda Cooper, not a Known Space story.

I’m done with “building Harlequin’s Moon.”

Short version: save your money.

Slightly longer version: if you must read everything in Niven’s cannon, borrow it or get it at a library. If you must have it, get it second hand. It’s not worth the full price of a new paperback.

So here goes another review no one will read (that’s ok, I like to write them).

The problem with “Building Harlqeuin’s Moon” is that the most interesting parts of the story happened before the novel gets underway.

The basic back-plot is: the Solar System has been taken over by Artificial Intelligences (AI), rouge nanobots (nano) and human-machine hybrids (sometimes refered to as augmented humans), so a large group of humans flee to another star where they’ll build a new society. Well and good. However the first Starship, the John Glenn (nice touch), encounters a problem and has to expend all its anti-matter in order to keep radiation from killing everyone onboard. As a result they have to make a pit stop at a star system without habitable planets, where they’ll make more anti-matter.

The plot concerns the crew of John Glenn taking up 60,000+ years to 1) build a habitable moon (Selene) around the gas giant Harlequin. Why? Because they will need too many people to build the anti-matter plant (a giagantic particle collider), and they’ll need supplies to sustain them. Ergo they need to build a habitable world where they can grow food. In the meantime the two other starships in the expedition (I forget their names) pressumably will have reached their destination (avoiding Glenn’s troubles because they hadn’t launched when she encountered a problem) and will ahve built a proper world to live on.

So I see the necessity of fleeing the Solar system as interesting. Also their arrival at their intended destination, Ymir (whatever that is), because how ill the descendants of their partners take an influx of random strangers 60 millennia out of date? And won’t Ymir have developed its own set of problems?

But that’s not what the novel is about.

It’s about the relationship between three groups: 1) The Council of Humanity, 2) The Earth Born and 3) The Moon Born.

The Council financed the ships to flee Earth with. The Earth born want to flee Earth and come along, but they come as peniless immigrants, so tos peak, subject to the wishes of Council. The Moon Born are the offspring of Earth Born in Selene. They don’t know Earth and don’t much care about it. they will build the Moon (planting trees, crops, tending to machines) and in time they will build the anti-matter collider. Naturally they have little or no say on how things are run.

This all could have been interesting, too. The setup is a classic recipe for group conflicts. But mostly the novel plods along, slowly, with very passive Moon Born, self-involved Council and almost overlooked Earth Born.

Oh, there isn’t room in John Glenn to take along the Moon Born. So once the ship is refueled they’ll have to stay behind. But the Moon Selene is, for all of the 60,000 years it takes to build, an unstable and temporary world at best. The Moon Born will all die within a few centuries at most, and Council doesn’t want to give them the tools to survive (contrived, anyone?).

That is a monstrous thing to do and the Moon born should be, literally, up in arms about it. But that’s not what happens.

What does happen? Honestly I can recall a little. The whole book feels as though something is building up, but you never know quite what. Near the end two people die and then the plot quickens, but it goes too fast then. everything is then laid out and resolved in a less than 50 pages.

The novel’s focus moves around too much between a Moon Born girl named Rachel and various Council members, plus the one AI allowed on the ship.

Overall, I don’t recomend reading it.