Foreign Policy

I’ve been struggling with identifying a government’s proper role when it comes to foreign trade, with what historians call “commercial diplomacy”–the practice of reaching trade agreements with other nations.

A major reason why the founders called for a constitutional convention was to give the federal government a stronger hand in dealing with the punishing commercial practices of war-time Europe. In ratifying the constitution, the founders established the concept of “supremacy,” giving the federal government the power to impose foreign trade agreements on all states and to establish tariffs.

I’m having difficulty identifying if, based on the proper definition of good government, a government should have the power to establish foreign commercial trade agreements at all times, or whether it should be a power valid only during wartime?

The founders established supremacy as a way to keep trade going while France and England were at war. However, this power remained after the end of war in Europe and possibly lead to the constitutionally suspicious growth in power of the executive branch. Should a government still have this power during peace time?

I suppose, essentially, my question is: When, if ever, does a government have the power to impose foreign trade agreements, and if it ever _ does _ have this power, what is the connection between this power and the protection of individual rights?

I suppose, essentially, my question is: When, if ever, does a government have the power to impose foreign trade agreements, and if it ever _ does _ have this power, what is the connection between this power and the protection of individual rights?

This is an excellent question. I too have wrestled with this and really can’t offer any precise answer. I will draw attention to a sub-point contained in that question: how to deal with trading issues involving dictatorships. I have heard two general arguments put forth by Objectivists and one stock and trade argument put forward by libertarians. The libertarian argument is always the same: the government should never interfere with international trade because it is that trade which will eventually spread freedom and liberty. I disagree with that and I think most Objectivists do also.

The Objectivist arguments have a range. I’ve heard on one hand that no trade should be allowed with dictatorships because any material trading povides the income via taxation to support the tyrannical government and thus the threat to the US. The weaker form of this argument is that only non-military trade should be allowed; ie only products that will not advance the military capability of the country in question.

I can’t say which version I agree with. Perhaps, it all depends on the context of the country involved. Some countries might warrant total trading bans and other might warrant only partial restrictions. Also there is the issue of how effective trade bans are. For example, the US has a trade ban on Cuba, yet all of Europe and Canada trades with Cuba freely. How effective is the US trade ban? There is enough money pumped into the Cuban economy via European and Canadian tourism to sustain Castro for the immediate future. Which is why I feel if the policy is to end the threat that a communist dictatorship poses in the form of Cuba which is just 90 miles off the coast of Florida then the solution should have been some sort of military invasion.

Anyway I consider the question an excellent one and one which the answers are not immediately apparent. I look forward to an interesting thread.

It seems then that the answer depends on context.

In the context of trade with enemy-nations, it is clearly a government’s responsibility to protect its citizens from those nations via at least the prohibition of trade (if not all-out war) whether foreign or domestic in origin.

But suppose the context is of trade with friend-nations run by governments that impose tariffs on foreign goods. Should America retaliate by imposing tariffs of its own?

Trading with friend-nations that impose tariffs does not threaten anyone’s individual rights, so it seems clear that American retaliation is inappropriate. People should thus be cognizant of the fact that these countries may, perhaps on a whim, impose tariffs. Long-term business deals would likely be made with the caveat that any tariffs should be absorbed by the traders living in the tariff-imposing nation. But, this is wandering into the business aspect of things instead of the governmental.

It terms of Cuba, it seems to me that the proper foreign policy is to force an embargo on all trade with Cuba, whether our so-called friends like it or not.

In terms of my original example with the founders and their attempt at “neutral trade” with England and France, I’m not sure whether this was an act of pragmatism (gaining wealth in the short term but assisting our enemies in the long term) or just a shrewd way of using England and France to gain strength so that one day the new nation would be self-reliant enough to withhold trade from her enemies. Jefferson and Madison attempted to act on the principle of no-trade with enemies at all cost through the Embargo Act, but this suffocated our economy and tarnished their presidencies–imposing an embargo at a time when we were so dependent on foreign trade and on countries that could win a war with us if they really wanted to, was not in the spirit of protecting individual rights. Here again, the answer seems to be dependent on context.

Am I making sense with all of this?

Retaliatory tariffs are not only self-destructive, but are an initiation of force. The only policy consistent with capitalism is unconditional and unilateral free trade with all peaceful nations.

In regard to trade with totalitarian regimes, this is from the China thread:

There are two criteria to decide whether the trade is immoral: (a.) will the gains from the trade be used to initiate force against you (b.) was the value you are getting obtained by force, such as by slave labor. In the case of a communist regime such as Soviet Russia, both of these conditions were true – in the case of today’s China, neither will be, unless you are trading with prison camps or selling technology with military applications.

There are other cases – such as the companies that sell China censorship technology and the American companies that censor the services they provide in China.

On a related note, the citizens of a free country are not entitled to have their foreign assets protected from nationalization or any other kind of seizure abroad – that is outside the jurisdiction of government.

So America would be right to meet the initiation of force on its citizens abroad via foreign tariffs with an act of force in defense?

So America would be right to meet the initiation of force on its citizens abroad via foreign tariffs with an act of force in defense?

No, a government is not obligated to protect its citizens or their property in anyway abroad – at least as long as they are not performing some diplomatic function. Doing this creates some bad incentives, as the billions in U.S. property nationalized in Cuba, and the subsequent attempts to use the U.S. military to get it back show.

One could argue that American companies would not invest nearly as much in China, Vietnam and other developing countries if they didn’t have the assurance than our government would bring pressure to bear if those countries attempted to nationalize the investments. Just as my money should not be confiscated to cover failing airlines, I shouldn’t forced to be cover the very real risks of investing in corrupt regimes.

So then the only context which warrants the forceful stoppage of trade from a peaceful country to an enemy country is if a] and/or b] above are satisfied? Do you think the founders had this criteria in mind?

So then the only context which warrants the forceful stoppage of trade from a peaceful country to an enemy country is if a] and/or b] above are satisfied?

Yes, though the criteria is even more narrow, since it should be legal to trade with a country even though it may be immoral – such as selling censorship technology to China. The fundamental question is whether you are in fact trading, or aiding a criminal.

Do you think the founders had this criteria in mind?

I know they did not, since Hamilton advocated protectionary tarrifs, and tarrifs were in fact enacted very early on.

This is an excellent question. I too have wrestled with this and really can’t offer any precise answer. I will draw attention to a sub-point contained in that question: how to deal with trading issues involving dictatorships.

It would be most helpful if we had, at some point in the discussion, a specific definition of “dictatorship.” If it means simply non-democratic rule, then there were very few countries that the new American republic would have been able to trade with in the first few decades after its founding.

Even today, refusing to permit trade with any non-democratic country would mean choking off access to most of our current foreign petroleum suppliers. It is difficult to see how restricting imports of vital energy sources would foster national security.

Furthermore, does it automatically follow that any and all dictatorships are a threat to American freedoms? Should the president and the Congress of the United States, in say 1900, have forbidden trade with Tsarist Russia? While the Russia of Alexander II was freer than the Russia of Lenin, it was still an autocracy, with a ruthless secret police, torture chambers and virtually no formal protections of human rights. How would American citizens have benefited from being denied the right to trade with Russian buyers and sellers in the years before the Bolshevik Revolution?

I agree that the U.S. government shouldn’t be insuring the risk of expropriation, as it does directly through the Export/Import Bank and indirectly via the IMF and World Bank. But on the other hand, I thought that I remember Ayn Rand and/or L. Peikoff speaking of Middle Eastern as being the rightful property of Western oil companies, and suggesting that force should be used to recover that property. (This may be my faulty perception, I don’t recall where I saw this). How to square these views, in principle?

^^I remember something similiar. I can see GC’s argument if a company invests in a country that is already communist and has no private property rights. But if a company invests in a country like pre-revolution Iran and then revolutionaries expropriate their property, should our government just tell the companies “sorry”?

No, a government is not obligated to protect its citizens or their property in anyway abroad – at least as long as they are not performing some diplomatic function. 

So if terrorists blows up a bus full of American tourists visiting Israel, our government should just tell the families “sorry”? What about the Lockerbie airliner bombing, which led to action against Libya? Do you really think it is a good idea to announce to terrorists that they can kill all the Americans they want, as long as they are outside the US and not diplomats (or soldiers, presumably)?

Perhaps you are right, but I would appreciate it if you could explain your thinking further.

Getting back to the original question, I find all the various complex trade negotiations and treaties we engage in pointless. We should just declare free trade unilaterally and be done with it. Tariffs are essentially a tax on our consumers and thus immoral regardless of what trade rules other countries have.

Another element of any discussion of the foreign policy of a free republic is keeping in mind the distinction between what that republic should, in principle, do and what it can do.

An individual has a right to do many things for which he may not have the resources.

Likewise, a free republic has a right to protect its citizens outside its borders – e.g., on the open sea – but may not have the resources to do so. In the case of the latter, the republic should make clear the ground rules: e.g., if you invest in Arabia and the Saudi family seizes your property, then you are on your own, except for filing suit in our courts for recovery.

A free republic the size of Costa Rica might have a right to protect its citizens in China – but could it without resorting to initiation of force (such as taxation)? And if it can’t, shouldn’t it tell its citizens that ahead of time?

Yes, though the criteria is even more narrow, since it should be legal to trade with a country even though it may be immoral – such as selling censorship technology to China.  The fundamental question is whether you are in fact trading, or aiding a criminal.

The important thing to note here is that free trade does not normally take place between two countries per se- it takes place between two business entities.

However, when a company does business with a foreign power, i.e., Boeing selling weapons to the State of Israel, then such questions ensue.

While the issue of a company sourced in America doing business with a company based in China is clearly a capitalist venture, the question arises whether a company based anywhere trading directly with a foreign power also comes under the category of laissez-faire capitalism.

I agree that the U.S. government shouldn’t be insuring the risk of expropriation, as it does directly through the Export/Import Bank and indirectly via the IMF and World Bank. But on the other hand, I thought that I remember Ayn Rand and/or L. Peikoff speaking of Middle Eastern as being the rightful property of Western oil companies, and suggesting that force should be used to recover that property. (This may be my faulty perception, I don’t recall where I saw this). How to square these views, in principle?

Because government, by definition, has a legal monopoly on force within a certain geographical area, attempting to regulate the actions of another government will inevitably lead to resentment and conflict –as the history of Latin America and the Middle East demonstrate. If the citizens of a free country wish to protect their property abroad in a region that lacks an agency to do so, they should either establish their own government there (as the modern State of Israel did), or extend the territory of their own government by colonization and eventual annexation (as the USA did). However, attempting to control the native regime by installing puppet leaders can only lead to the native population to revolt against it. I’m not sure what the proper solution for the Middle East was – but you can’t practice diplomacy with regimes that don’t respect individual rights – they should either be left to their own devices or dismantled.