This is one I’ve been struggling with lately. In AS, during the first scene where Rearden first meets Francisco, there’s a point where Rearden – at the time believing that Francisco is the bad guy – makes the following comment to Francisco:
I can forgive all those others… But you – You’re the kind who can’t be forgiven.
And Francisco’s response:
It is against the sin of forgiveness that I wanted to warn you.
Now, I do agree that there are certain contexts in which forgiveness is inappropriate. If I confront someone about an offense they’ve committed, and they don’t own up to it, then of course I shouldn’t just let it go. And of course this particular excerpt is a reference a comment that’s to the world AS is taking place in, where people like Rearden are being forced to sacrifice themselves for everyone else, while the rest of the world feeds off them. I do not believe that life in the world today is this way for most people.
But at what point should you forgive someone? I don’t think it’s fair to hold a grudge against someone forever, or that it’s in your own self-interest – especially if it’s someone close to you. Everyone screws up sometimes, so if you hold everything against everyone forever, then you’re going to end up alienating everyone in your life.
And if it’s when they take responsibility for their actions after being confronted, what about before you confront them? I guess the answer would be that you should judge their actions objectively, and make an appropriate judgment of the degree to which you should hold it against them, until you’ve talked to them. But anyway, what does everyone else think?