Some have taken this story to be evidence that Wright was lazy or undependable. In fact, I would suggest that Wright had not forgotten the project at all but was letting the idea gestate. The client’s phone call was simply a cue to commit the plans to paper.
<{POST_SNAPBACK}>
You are right and it was more than that:
By 1934 he had done hundreds of houses, many foreshadowing Fallingwater in Form. It was a House looking for the correct site and found it at Bear Run. There was a definite progression of the Prarie Houses in plan and elevations that led to his magnum opus but also to his future works such as the Guggenheim Museum.
Wright had the heroic side of him that loved to tell the Kaufmann story in order to show the ease in which he “shook from his sleeves” numerous designs. Of course, it was from sheer practice of his talents that he, at 65 yrs old, was able to rotate the solutions in his mind, integrate them mentally for days before using paper and pencils in order to verify his thoughts and to communicate with others. Today,as belated research are comming out, we are able to understand his design process more than before. At the time, he did not care to reveal much much in this regard, prefering to project the mystical side of him to others. There was evidently a messianic side of him that came from the influences of reading 19th C. Romantic novels and transcendentalists such as Emerson, Thoreau and Whitman.
Recently, I was pleasantly surprised to read in a book on Wright’s philosophy of design that Victor Hugo’s Notre Dame de Paris had a deep effect on Wright during his earlier years.
From"Frank Lloyd Wright" by Robert Mc Carter (1997):
" In the chapter that was to have such a profound effect on Wright, entiltled ‘This Will Kill That’, Hugo, speaking directly to the readers, says that up until the fifteenth century ‘the material and intellectual forces of society all converged on that one point: architecture,’ and that ‘whoever was then born a poet became an architect,’ because
architecture was the principal registered of mankind, that during that period all ideas of any complexity which arose in the world became a building. And why?Because every idea, be it religious or philosophical, is concerned to perpetuate itself, because the idea that has moved one generation wants to move others, and to leave some trace.
In the fifteenth century, Hugo states that everything changed: with the invention of the printing press ’ the human mind discovered a means of perpetuating itself which was not only more lasting and resistant than architecture, but also simpler and easier…The book was to kill the building.’ Yet this new means of perpetuating ideas did not possess the place-making qualities of the monument after which Hugo’s story is named: ’ In the days of architecture, thought had turned into a mountain and taken powerful hold of a century and of a place. Now it turned into a flock of birds and was scattered on the four winds occupying every point of air and space simultaneously.’ Hugo goes on to tell what was to happen to architecture after this event:
And so you see how, starting with the discovery of printing, architecture gradually dried up, it atrophied, and was denuded…from the sixtheenth century on, architecture’s malady became apparent; it was no longer the essential expression of society; it turned miserably into a classical art; once it had been Gallic, European, indigenous, now it became Greek and Roman; once it had been true and modern, now it became pseudo-antique. This was the decadence we call the Renaissance…It was the setting sun which we all take to be the dawn.
At this point in the narative all seem lost: ‘Let there be no mistake, architecture is dead, dead beyond recall, killed by the printed book.’ Yet in the very next paragraph, Hugo holds out a last hope with this strange prophesy: ‘The great accident of an architect of genius might occur in the twentieth century just like that of Dante in the thirteenth’. In his paraphasing of this chapter in his 1901 lecture ‘The Art and Craft of the Machine’, Wright makes a revealing modification to Hugo’s time table: ‘if architecture rise again, reconstruct, as Hugo prophesies she may do in the latter days of the nineteenth century…’ (author’s emphasis). …Did Wright, as is suggested by his change in Hugo’s prophesy, to make it better fit his own biography, see himself as the ‘architect of genius’ who was to revive architecture? " (p.23,24,25)
I would say that with Fallingwater he was the heroic architect that revived the building. (His wonderful mother had alot to do with this heroic trait, but that is another story.)
I would also say that the revived building after Wright was short lived and is now in delirium.
Will it be the book that is going to revive the building this time?
Kien