Free State Initiative

Hi. I’m curious to know what the thoughts are of the people in this forum about the Free State Project (www.freestateproject.org). Please endulge me.

-Rich

Although I am against the Libertarian backing of this project, obviously I’d prefer an Objectivist backed Free State, I think, if everything goes well, New Hampshire will boom considerably. Any place that becomes freer will prosper. I would even consider moving there someday. This could very well turn out to be a very large step in the right direction, although keep in mind that this is what our founding fathers had in mind when the started this country.

As per your antagonizsm to its libertarian supporters (it is not a Libertarian organization as such), please see my other thread in the political philosophy section of this forum.

I’m glad to see you’d consider moving there someday…should I take this to mean you are willing to help in the creation of this free society by signing the statement of intent (https://freestateproject.org/members/join.jsp) or second-hand after all the work is done?

-Rich

P.S. I should have stated by bias earlier..I have signed the statement of intent and will be moving to NH.

Whether it’s a true Libertarian organization or not is irrelevant. What really matters is that this free society that is being created will not contain the rational ethical background required to sustain its existence as a free state. This is why I compared it to the USA, look at what this country was intended to be and look at where it is now, then look at which direction it is headed. This being said the USA is still the freest country in the world. So what I really think is that New Hampshire will become, if everything goes well, the freest state in the union and that is why I would consider moving there, but I will wait until it is to really consider it.

…and you will not work to instill in this society the “rational ethical background” you think it needs? You will sit by and do nothing and let this opportunity pass you by (and/or fail, as you think it will)? That doesn’t sound like something John Galt would do.

Galt talked the talk and walked the walk, that’s what made him awesome. I hear a lot of talk from Objectivists, but rarely, if ever, have I seen them walk the walk.

I imagine that’s pretty comfortable.

-Rich

Free State Objectivists:

http://www.galtfans.com/

I said I would consider moving there someday and if I do it will be because it is the freest place to live, enough said. John Galt did what he did because the world was in an unbearable state. Personally I do not think we are in the world of Atlas Shrugged quite yet. If I am free to build my life then that’s what I’ll do, once that freedom is gone so am I.

That doesn’t sound like something John Galt would do.

Signing a libertarian-sponsored statement is not something John Galt would do either.

CF - exactly. The project is just a blank-check support of an undefined and unidentified political platform that mouths vague platitudes about achieving ‘liberty’ - but without providing any intellectual basis (or even definition) for that liberty.

1 Like

Free State Objectivists:

http://www.galtfans.com/

I’m glad to see this. Hopefully you can help me in convincing more Objectivists (on this forum) to sign the statement of intent :smiley:

-Rich

About Free State Objectivists, some of the links of this site tell me that lot of people involved in this organization are not really Objectivists.

I said I would consider moving there someday and if I do it will be because it is the freest place to live, enough said.  John Galt did what he did because the world was in an unbearable state.  Personally I do not think we are in the world of Atlas Shrugged quite yet.  If I am free to build my life then that’s what I’ll do, once that freedom is gone so am I.

I know that is what you said, but it strikes me as un-objectivist. You will be second-handing the state we build, not by the point in time you were born, which you cannot help, but by conscious choice.

And you are going to wait until that point so that everything has to be rebuilt and billions of people die instead of getting involved now?

Not quiet yet, but look around…is this the United States you wish to support?

Do not go gently into that good night…Rage, rage against the dying of the light.

Build your life in NH and help build a Free State.

-Rich

Signing a libertarian-sponsored statement is not something John Galt would do either.

It is not libertarian sponsored, but please enlighten me as to what is so contrary to Objectivism in the following statement:

I hereby state my solemn intent to move to the state of New Hampshire. Once there, I will exert the fullest practical effort toward the creation of a society in which the maximum role of civil government is the protection of life, liberty, and property.

-Rich

CF - exactly.  The project is just a blank-check support of an undefined and unidentified political platform that mouths vague platitudes about achieving ‘liberty’ - but without providing any intellectual basis (or even definition) for that liberty.

Its as well defined as the Objectivist political philosophy of Capitalism (care to argue this one?)

It is justifiably presumed that people have the intellectual basis for liberty or else people wouldn’t be pissed off or motiviated enough to move. A dare say you should come to a Free State Project meeting in your area and meet some of us.

-Rich

You are getting ridiculous. What will I be stealing from you and the others who start this “Free State”, if I chose to move there sometime in distant future? If this state is created, when I move there, after the fact, what will I have taken that does not belong to me?

“And you are going to wait until that point so that everything has to be rebuilt and billions of people die instead of getting involved now?”

Yes, I only worry about me.

“is this the United States you wish to support”

I don’t have to support it to live here.

“Do not go gently into that good night…Rage, rage against the dying of the light”

Instead of starting another political system lacking an ethical base, I am advocating the spread of one that contains a perfectly sound and explicitly defined ethical system and will not fail once it is in place.

“I hereby state my solemn intent to move to the state of New Hampshire. Once there, I will exert the fullest practical effort toward the creation of a society in which the maximum role of civil government is the protection of life, liberty, and property” (but has no foundation because it has not defined, just as the libertarians have not, the purpose for its liberty).

This is how I read it. What exactly will I be supporting here, life, liberty, and property, but by whose definition? This is the problem we face today through out America.

Finally, you are assuming that people, rational or irrational because you don’t care to ask, have an intellectual basis for liberty or else they would not have to stimulus to participate in this charade? WOW! Rethink that one. Please tell us what this intellectual base you are presuming exists in every individual involved in this project.

You are getting ridiculous.  What will I be stealing from you and the others who start this “Free State”, if I chose to move there sometime in distant future?  If this state is created, when I move there, after the fact, what will I have taken that does not belong to me?

“And you are going to wait until that point so that everything has to be rebuilt and billions of people die instead of getting involved now?”

Yes, I only worry about me.

“is this the United States you wish to support”

I don’t have to support it to live here.

“Do not go gently into that good night…Rage, rage against the dying of the light”

Instead of starting another political system lacking an ethical base, I am advocating the spread of one that contains a perfectly sound and explicitly defined ethical system and will not fail once it is in place.

“I hereby state my solemn intent to move to the state of New Hampshire. Once there, I will exert the fullest practical effort toward the creation of a society in which the maximum role of civil government is the protection of life, liberty, and property” (but has no foundation because it has not defined, just as the libertarians have not, the purpose for its liberty).

This is how I read it.  What exactly will I be supporting here, life, liberty, and property, but by whose definition?  This is the problem we face today through out America.

Finally, you are assuming that people, rational or irrational because you don’t care to ask, have an intellectual basis for liberty or else they would not have to stimulus to participate in this charade?  WOW!  Rethink that one.  Please tell us what this intellectual base you are presuming exists in every individual involved in this project.

I didn’t say you’d be stealing, I said you’d be second-handing. You will be reaping the benefits of the state we will have created while you have done nothing to aid us. You consume, but do not create.

I’m as selfish as you, but I guess I am not as short sighted and/or idle when an opportunity to live in and create a state for individual freedom to flourish comes knocking.

I will take that as a no.

And I have no problem with you advocating Objectivism. What I am saying is that talk is cheap. How about you and the others on this list create an Objectivist Project to get Objectivists to move to New Hampshire. Come show us up…

By your definition, since it’s you who decide what to work to create. I think it’s your problem that you think abstractions can be made absolute, consistent across all people, and perfectly concrete (no greys) without artificial/man-made definitions and continual acceptance by the individuals within a community. Capitalism is no more well defined than life, liberty, and property. Both are words which (can) trigger differing definitions and behavior. Rand’s definition of Capitalism is one, mine is another (that it is simply an economic system whereby the means of production are owned/controlled privately), but individuals decide which they will choose to use.

Funny, Rand recognized the intrinsic characteristic of men to be free, do you? They see that they are not living in a free society where they can rise to be the best they can be and live the life they want to live, and decided to do something about it. Isn’t that obvious :wink:

-Rich

“It is justifiably presumed that people have the intellectual basis for liberty”

The fact that someone thinks they can justify their idea of ‘liberty’ does NOT mean that justification is valid. As such, your presumption is false.

“Its as well defined as the Objectivist political philosophy of Capitalism”

No it is not. You demonstrate this clearly in the above statement as well as with your previous posts, including those in which you explicitly state there is no *one* standard of ethics for liberty.

–

You are taunting, goading, cajolling and mudslinging in your attempt to get others to debate you and to promote libertarianism. This site does not tolerate such behavior. You have been warned once already. If it persists, you will be removed.

CF - exactly.  The project is just a blank-check support of an undefined and unidentified political platform that mouths vague platitudes about achieving ‘liberty’ - but without providing any intellectual basis (or even definition) for that liberty.

Of course it’s a blank-slate, because the Free State Project is not about a specific political platform/slate of policies. It is solely about getting 20,000 activists to support a society for the protection of life, liberty, and property to move to NH. It is up to the people that move to bring these abstract ideas into eventual existence and meaning through political activism. We do not know what the eventual Free State that is created will look like..(free) societies are chaotic systems.

So, I ask you to ask yourself, do you have in your mind what a society that protects life, liberty, and property would look like? That is your working definition. Now, how do you plan to achieve this society. I impeach you to attend a local meeting of FSPers/porcupines in your area to check your premises and see whether your hostility towards joining the FSP is justified. I think you will find your (Objectivist) vision is aided, not hindered, by us.

Because most of us don’t use the label Objectivist to describe ourselves doesn’t mean many of us do not follow most of, if not all of, Objectivism. I would hate for you to be getting upset (disregarding us) over semantics.

-Rich

You continue to use arguments that have been either demonstrated to you as false or have no relevance to the topic. I will no longer participate in this discussion unless you provide any new ideas on the mater or at least begin to comprehend what you have already been told by either myself or RadCap. I have said my piece on this topic, if you have any question regarding what I have said state them polite and honest manner and I will be happy to answer them.

I was actually interested but now it seems like some secular cult.