Objectivism tries to avoid the conflict between Free Will and Determinism by removing the “decision/choice to focus” from the conflict. Though I have been studying objectivism on my own for a number of years, and have read all of the literature and postings on the subject, I have not been able to understand how that “primary choice” is either:
-Logically generated by an individual independent of the facts and circumstances of his existence, or
-Made independent of the facts and circumstances of his existence but still attributable to him to the extent that he is responsible for it.
I will attempt (below) to explain this conflict as thoroughly as possible in the hope that the problem, as I see it, is understood and that someone may shed light on how it can be resolved. (sorry about the length, it is the only way to get the point across)
Is “Free Will” (defined as the ability to (a) originate an ( B) uncoerced/independent decision among multiple open alternatives and act in accordance with that decision) compatible with the nature of the universe?
The Nature of the Universe
(x) In a
causally deterministic universe
all of existence is governed by the same laws and shares a common origin; therefore, it may be assumed, the universe will unfold in a manner determined by the previously existing state of the universe and laws of physics.
(y) In an
indeterministic universe
events unfold randomly and are not a function of the previous state of the universe or of any universal laws of physics.
The Nature of Decision Making in a Deterministic Universe
Every decision is explainable as a function of two things:
(1) Reality, defined as the facts/circumstances of which one is aware; and
(2) Biases, which are predispositions to further one’s agenda via the decision.
Biases are a function of previous decisions about one’s ends that are ultimately rooted in the circumstances of one’s existence, which is essentially an element of (1). That is, the (2) portion of a current decision (externally or internally focused) is tainted by the outcome of a previous, internally focused, decision about what (2) should be; which its self was the product of a previous decision, etc…. The origins of these biases predate one’s consciousness and are entirely a product of nature, beyond the control or responsibility of the decision maker. Thus both the facts & circumstances of which one is aware and the biases that are rooted in those same facts & circumstances are not original to the decision maker and are, therefore, beyond his responsibility.
The Free Will vs. Determinism/Indeterminism Paradox
If (x), then (a) but not ( B) ; this is because decisions are a function of reality and biases (as explained above) that are not independent or voluntary since the biases are ultimately rooted in circumstances that predate one’s ability to originate a primary bias. (the primary biases are survival reflexes like hunger, etc…)
If (y), then ( B) but not (a); this is because it would be impossible to truly originate any judgment that one could be held responsible for if the mental processes that led to the outcome were at all random (if a decision a function of a chance, one cannot be held responsible for the product as it is beyond their control).
Since both (a) and ( B) are required to have Free Will, but cannot occur simultaneously in either (x) or (y), which are exclusive of one another, it would seem that Free Will does not exist.
The Logical Fallacy of Determinism/Indeterminism without Free Will
One cannot meaningfully affirm that Free Will does not exist without contradiction because such a conclusion, in order to be validated by the proclaimer or a listener, must, by definition, be done so at a level beyond the proclaimer [(a) - not originating with him] or must be done so without his consent [( B) - lacking independence], in which case it is hardly a claim at all. Indeed, it would be wrong to accept as knowledge anything that lacks an identifiable origin in an indeterministic universe or to accept a claim that emanated from an unidentifiable/indistinguishable actor in a deterministic universe.
Without Free Will, there are no means by which to check the validity of a statement, therefore the difference between true and false would be arbitrary. Far from coming to any real conclusions one would have to settle for “I have been programmed to accept that…..” or “the unfolding of the universe has caused me to say that….”
The Essence of the Conflict:
The universe is causally deterministic so far as human interaction with it is concerned. However, Free Will must be held, as an axiom, in order for any analysis (prior, present & future) to have any meaning. The conflict can be summarized by noting that there are two equally atrocious alternatives:
To claim to live in the type of causally deterministic universe required to validate the decision making aspects of Free Will, but to know that Free Will is not possible in that universe (see “The FW vs. D/I Paradox” above).
To claim that the universe is deterministic (or indeterministic) and that Free Will is impossible, but to do so without any means of independently (or logically) verifying that such is the case (see “The Logical Fallacy of D/I without FW” above).
To accept the later alternative would be the end of the analysis; any additional (and prior) conclusions would lack meaning since they would amount to little more than neatly arranged observations & data upon which only meaningless calculations could be performed, and for which no judgment could be rendered. However, acceptance of the former alternative would allow for additional analysis of the universe, but any conclusions reached would be qualified in the same manner as the former alternative, which has the same effect as the latter alternative (italicized above).
Should/Must I pretend to live in a deterministic universe in which Free Will is possible in order to validate knowledge or have moral responsibility? If so, why not pretend that a God, or a “soul,” exists in order to reinforce that moral responsibility? Or, for that matter, why not invent any number of non-existent things to suit my predetermined (or random) needs?