The first and most fundamental of all natural rights is the right to own property. The basis for this is derived from the right to own one’s own body, which assists in outlining the right to self-defense, the right to be free from invading forces, and the right to peacebly conduct our day to day affairs.
Okay, but now this confuses me. On the one hand you say that the first and fundamental right is the right to own property, but then you say that this right derives from something else. That means that the right to own property is not the first and fundamental right, but rather is a derivative right. Now are you saying that the first and most fundamental right is the right to own our own bodies?
Assuming that’s the case, do you believe that animals also have the same right to own their own bodies?
In other words, one does not have the right to initiate force against another person, in any form, other than self-defense and self-preservation. As a moral agent you have the right to choose for yourself and an obligation to let other moral agents choose for themselves.
How about fraud? I would surmise from this that it’s not okay to bash someone on the head to get their wallet, but if you can defraud someone nonviolently, that would be okay. If not, why not?
In order to physically own something, it must be something that can be appropriated and controlled. The laws of nature, celestial bodies, the air we breath are all examples of something not approbiable.
That seems like a strange conclusion. If I can own a chunk of land here, why can’t I own a chunk of land, or flaming gas, outside Earth’s atmosphere? Are you saying that the stars are for all mankind, not to be owned by an individual? Then I would suppose that if someone sets up an asteroid mining operation, that the ore which they dig out can’t become their property. That seems rather unlibertarian.
To be ownable something must exist, one cannot own that which currently does not exist.
Most certainly; but again, the air exists and the laws of nature exist, so why can’t these particular things which exist be owned?
I can ramble on, but in short, the right to own and control private property is the basis of liberty. One can not have one without the other. It is fundamental to our values of liberty to be able to exercise ownership and control of private property, whether it be goods we own, land that we own and control, or our own bodies.
This last sentence suggests that you’re saying that the ability to own is justified as a means of having liberty – so that having liberty is the fundamental principle, which ownership is in service of. Is that right?
Let me explain why I asked. I started life years ago as a libertarian (hell, I ran for public office on the LP ticket in 1972), but came to realise that the standard Libertarian account of rights was incoherent. The search for a coherent account of rights was what brought me to Objectivism. What I want to know is whether there was some Libertarian explanation of rights that I missed; or, is it simply an irredicible axiom, that man has rights. I believe that for libertarians, the latter is the case.