Help Me, Please.

Why don’t you start a new thread where we could discuss the implications of your ideas, if you’re not up to writing a book just yet, Don? I’d rather not so I’ll leave that decision to you. Both of you and iouswuoibev have given me my most precious pieces of advice and I’d hate to see them wasted at the bottom of my topic.

Thank you for the kind words. I may just do that.

You’re right, SMS, teachers like you and I face are redundant. However, one great advantage they bring is that they actually know their subject (some of the time). For instance, the history teacher I previously mentioned did know his subject. He just didn’t know anything else, and he didn’t care to know anything else, and he actively opposed knowing anything else while in his classroom. Nonetheless, he knew European history. The advantage of that is that he can tell you tons of essential and often useful concretes that you might have more difficulty finding independently. This also holds true for the sciences. I could never have re-invented all of that math if I did not have the formulas that previous thinkers handed down to me. With that kind of educational environment, I can look at the conclusions which I know are true, and trace their reasoning back to reality. Though it would be far, FAR easier if the teacher would just explain the damn things, it is still far easier that I have the teacher there rather than try to observe the motion of the moon and derive the acceleration of gravity on my own.

This is one reason why I am still motivated to go to class. The other is that I just know that I cannot get the graduate school I want without good grades—and I cannot get the job I want without the name of a good graduate school on my resume. It’s almost as if I have two sets of eyes at all times: One focused on the immediate job that needs to be done and the other looking at the ultimate goal that I hope to achieve. I must ask, do you have some kind of ultimate goal, held clearly in your mind? I don’t mean do you already know what kind of program you want to create later in life, or what corporation you want to work for. Do you know what it is in the world that you hope to change, and improve in order to make your life better, through computer programming?

It’s sad that college is something that has to be gotten over with. To be honest, I only think that way some of the time. The other time, I actually enjoy reading whatever it is that I am reading, and it’s almost a guilty pleasure of mine to re-invent these complicated subjects. It’s like exercising muscles that should never have to be exercised (or not in this way). I don’t like that I should have to do it, but it still feels good doing it—knowing that I can do it. But then there are times when I get very angry with the fact that I am wasting my time, spending years doing what could have been done in months with the right teachers. That’s when I have to bite down hard and push through my books/lecture notes/paper assignments. In the end I just have to look at my long-range goals, like an exhausted runner looking at the finish line on the horizon.

Another temptation I have is to ostracise myself from the few friends I have, because of their “evil” ideas. All this despite the positive things they bring into my life.

Why would you feel tempted to ostracise them, then? Objectivism certainly doesn’t endorse such a thing.

I don’t agree with LP’s assessment of evasion. I don’t think I am betraying my own convictions simply by listening to someone.

Neither do I. And neither, as far as I know, does Peikoff. Why, then, would you attribute such a view to him?

What Objectivism promotes is to try to argue with someone through exposure. The trouble with exposure is, it doesn’t work unless the other person is at least somewhat inclined to your way of thinking already. It is not an effective form of persuasion, by itself. People don’t drop their lifelong held convictions easily, and they don’t take them lightly. If you want to persuade someone to your way of thinking, you first have to make them feel a certain way. If you alienate them from you, you will alienate them from your ideas as well.

First of all, Objectivism doesn’t promote trying to argue with someone, period. Objectivism is a philosophy and takes no stance on whether and how you should go about convincing someone of your ideas.

Moreover, Objectivism would say that making others believe as you do must never be a primary aim (even if spreading Objectivism is your career).

For instance, if someone tried to talk about Kant, I wouldn’t rattle off a list of reasons why Kant is so obviously wrong - at least not at first. I’m more likely to ask a question such as: “What is it that draws you to Kant’s ideas?”. If you can make them comfortable by asking them easy questions, you can gradually turn them around to your way of thinking. By contrast, many Objectivists tend to go straight for explaining why the ideas are wrong. They don’t recognise, or don’t care about the psychological implications of this way of dealing with a person. If you go for that approach, and they aren’t of a similar mind to you already, they will evade, no matter how rational your explanation is, simply because of how you are making them feel.

Once again, what Objectivism endorses and what some Objectivists do are two different things. As an individualist, I don’t want to be lumped in with people who act in ways I disagree with simply because we share the same ideas.

And once someone evades, that’s it, that’s as far as the Objectivist method goes. Doesn’t matter why they are doing it, they just are - time to pull the plug. If you want to convince people that you are a lunatic, this is a good way of going about it. It’s not because of your ideas that they regard you that way, but because of how you deal with them as a person.

I have no idea what you are talking about here.

So in short, I think exposure is a guarranteed way to provoke someone to evade, and branding them as evil as soon as they do so will convince them you are a lunatic. I’d rather convert them, but clearly some people don’t have the patience (or “tolerance”). :slight_smile: I’m probably going to get lynched for saying this!

To begin with, strictly speaking, you can’t provoke someone to evade, and anyone who you could provoke would probably not be a very good candidate for Objectivism anyway. I do not believe that Objectivists should act like psychologists when trying to spread their philosophy. I do not believe the problem with spreading a philosophy is psychological.

Objectivists should make their arguments as best they can and give the person they are talking to the respect of assuming that person can evaluate the evidence on his own.

Of course I agree that one should not brand someone evil without sufficient evidence, and that evil people are more rare than some (mostly younger) Objectivists think. But I do not think a rational man should concern himself with what people think of him - he should be concerned with whether his actions are right. The problem with denouncing people in the way you are here speaking of is not that people will call you a lunatic - it’s that it’s irrational.

I will say this: no one hates dogmatic “Objectivists” more than I, and no one is harder on them. But it is a myth that the movement is populated by large numbers of them, and that this is a major problem which requires the “insight” of Nathaniel Branden to solve. This is a small problem limited primarily to some young people who read Atlas Shrugged and are trying to integrate it without proper philosophical guidance. Those people either grow out of it, or they leave the movement. In neither case do I believe it reflects on those of us who aren’t dogmatists, and it certainly does not reflect on Ayn Rand or Leonard Peikoff, who would abhor such behavior.

Yes it is true that Objectivism does not state that one must convince others to change their false ideas. What iouswuoibev was trying to say is that if this is one’s goal to do to another, e.g., a friend, then the best way to do it is to ask questions and avoid saying outright “You are wrong beacuse…” It doesn’t work, with most people, because they cling to their ideas very personally and are insulted when their ideas are criticized. Ask questions and make them think, not preach.

Branden’s essay does correctly show how some people may have a dogmatic approach to Objectivism (even if other parts of the essay are wrong). And I speak from experience.

Check out this essay: http://www.dailyobjectivist.com/Spir/selfinterestenough.asp

This essay, even if it has faults or errors, does show why the “myth” that many people are dogmatic in their approach to Objectivism is plausible. It does happen - I have experienced it myself - but I don’t claim to know how abundant it is.

Branden’s essay does correctly show how some people may have a dogmatic approach to Objectivism (even if other parts of the essay are wrong).  And I speak from experience.

Branden is taking a fact out of context in order to dump on Ayn Rand and the Objectivists who support her. (So what else is new? :slight_smile: )

Sure there are many people who take Objectivism dogmatically. What is being ignored is that almost everyone takes morality dogmatically whether their morality is Objectivism or not.

Most Objectivists took morality dogmatically before they were Objectivists and most pick up Objectivist values long before they learn how to value rationally and non-dogmatically. Eventually, Objectivism helps many people ground ethical principles in reality – which no other philosophy does.

In fact, fewer Objectivists are dogmatic about their morality than the adherents of almost every other morality that exists, so anecdotal reports about people applying the philosophy incorrectly are seriously misleading.

dog·ma ( P ) Pronunciation Key (dôgm, dg-)

n. pl. dog·mas or dog·ma·ta (-m-t)

A doctrine or a corpus of doctrines relating to matters such as morality and faith, set forth in an authoritative manner by a church.

An authoritative principle, belief, or statement of ideas or opinion, especially one considered to be absolutely true. See Synonyms at doctrine.

A principle or belief or a group of them: “The dogmas of the quiet past are inadequate to the stormy present” (Abraham Lincoln).

Why should I not be dogmatic? Ayn Rand has written doctrines relating to morality, faith, and authoritative principles or statements of ideas that my reason says are accurate. So why should I not be dogmatic?

You’re right, SMS, teachers like you and I face are redundant. However, one great advantage they bring is that they actually know their subject (some of the time).

You’re right. This is one fact that I have studiously been ignoring. :slight_smile:

It’s almost as if I have two sets of eyes at all times: One focused on the immediate job that needs to be done and the other looking at the ultimate goal that I hope to achieve.

A full context?

I must ask, do you have some kind of ultimate goal, held clearly in your mind? I don’t mean do you already know what kind of program you want to create later in life, or what corporation you want to work for. Do you know what it is in the world that you hope to change, and improve in order to make your life better, through computer programming?

Not a very clear goal, but I’m working on it.

It’s sad that college is something that has to be gotten over with. To be honest, I only think that way some of the time. The other time, I actually enjoy reading whatever it is that I am reading, and it’s almost a guilty pleasure of mine to re-invent these complicated subjects. It’s like exercising muscles that should never have to be exercised (or not in this way). I don’t like that I should have to do it, but it still feels good doing it—knowing that I can do it. But then there are times when I get very angry with the fact that I am wasting my time, spending years doing what could have been done in months with the right teachers. That’s when I have to bite down hard and push through my books/lecture notes/paper assignments. In the end I just have to look at my long-range goals, like an exhausted runner looking at the finish line on the horizon.

That’s just what I don’t think, and that is why I’m generally so depressed. But I see your point and I feel better already. Thanks. I’ve wasted a lot of precious time and hurt many people who care for me because I did not care for myself. I can see where I have been wrong.

Mrs. Speicher:

Would you please explain in a little more detail? How exactly should a person take morality? Once I have reasoned out something to be wrong, must I force it upon myself never to do it? Or should I drive it in so deeply that I never feel like doing it anyway?

Mrs. Speicher:

Would you please explain in a little more detail? How exactly should a person take morality?

Please call me Betsy. (Mrs. Speicher was my mother-in-law.)

Morality is a guide to help you make good choices – choices that will bring you success and happiness. It is a view that is at odds with all other moralities, but if you really want to see the uniqueness of the Objectivist ethics, read Ayn Rand’s article, “Causality Versus Duty” in Philosophy: Who Needs It.

[Once I have reasoned out something to be wrong, must I force it upon myself never to do it? Or should I drive it in so deeply that I never feel like doing it anyway?

Neither one! Will power is a poor substitute for understanding.

Generally, if you really see why something isn’t good for you and why it keeps you from getting what you want most, it won’t seem desirable at all. When you do have a conflict between what you think and what you feel, it means there are some ideas you need to think through some more, something you aren’t really convinced of yet. That is very typical of someone who is just learning Objectivism, so don’t let it throw you. It is normal and healthy to have conflicts in the beginning. Just take whatever time you need to think them through and eventually they will all be resolved.

Yes, I’m sure they will if I give them enough time. Thank you. :dough: