When is an academic career moral and rational?

I’m currently at the end of my computer science studies (German “Diplom”, similar to master’s degree). Now I’m considering all my options and do some brainstorming.

Besides getting paid for what I can *do* best, to me an academic career looks irrational. You’re getting paid through taxation, papers are often counted not by their scientific quality but by quantity, there are bureaucratic structures, you’re dependant on the government and (most important) all you do goes into public domain. Yes, there are lots of people you can meet, but those people all share an academic career with a similar structure.

And is an academic career moral at all? There are companies where you can teach and research or you can publish books yourself, so there is an alternative.

Is it rational? What other reasons are there?

To me it somehow looks like a career where the path is laid out for you, where you can already plan your pension etc., with little room for personal growth…

I guess I want to do science but don’t want to be a scientist :slight_smile: The best would probably be to create a company and apply new methods myself…

Thank you for your thoughts, anything helps to clear my view on this subject and dig through the sea of ideas that float through my head :stuck_out_tongue:

You should realize that virtually all education in America is saturated with the government. Since you are not responsible for that and might not have a pleasant career alternative, you are not being immoral by taking part, because you have no choice. You should only consider whether you could tolerate the atmosphere or not.

There may be other viable career options for you, and if you are interested, you should research them. If you then find there is nothing else good, and you really like to teach, definitely go into teaching wherever you are happy working, university, corporation, private lessons. You aren’t responsible for the government.

I am going to be a lifelong academic and I consider it both a rational and moral choice.

Mmh… I guess I first have to figure out clearly what I want to achieve.

Still, science feels like giving out candy having an applauding audience with no clue what you’re doing…

I think there are some deeper issues involved, my mind-set is usually to go my own way, not wanting to be part of a larger movement/institution. Maybe I need some more work experience and finish some own projects before I really can say that I do want or do not want to join the science community.

@themadkat:

Reading your profile I wonder:

Do you see the environment of an academic career as an opportunity or as a necessary evil (i.e. you get paid for what you want to do and you have easy access to laboratories, books etc.)?

I ask because in computer science all I need is a computer :stuck_out_tongue:

I’ve been a life-long academic, and I consider not having made that choice to be both irrational and immoral. But I can’t speak for you.

You have the wrong focus in evaluating the worthiness of an academic career (or, alternatively, a career in industry). I would say that making a career choice based on the sociology of either kind of career is in the “worst possible choice” spectrum. Instead, you should decide what would be the best goal to be pursuing seen from your perspective, completely leaving out the behavior of other people. Once you really understand that, then it makes some sense to ask “can I pursue that purpose in an academic context? can I pursue that working for some corporation? can I pursue that as an independent businessman?”. You may find that the freedom to pursue your own interests is more important, which would favor an academic career; but you may find that avoidance of bureaucracy is more important to you (well, in that case, you’re screwed).

The “paid through taxation” argument is a non-starter from an Objectivist perspective, given the nature of the society that you live in. Your concern with how papers “count” presupposes that your self-worth is determined by external praise and ignores the fact that mindless point-counting exists in all large organizations – it is probably even worse in the corporate world. I don’t know what German law is, but I doubt seriously that all that you produce becomes “public domain”. (That may be true of patents, but that is not by any stretch “all” of what an academic does).

So your first question should be “What do I want to do?” and once you know that you can sensibly ask “How can I accomplish that?”

I’ve been a life-long academic, and I consider not having made that choice to be both irrational and immoral. But I can’t speak for you.

Ok, I should have sticked with the original question, i.e. when such a career is the wrong choice (although one has the ability to work as a scientist). There is nothing wrong with it if you enjoy it :slight_smile:

Thinking about it I guess I understand under “career” an occupation with which I make money which I then use to pursuit my real goals.

You have the wrong focus in evaluating the worthiness of an academic career (or, alternatively, a career in industry). I would say that making a career choice based on the sociology of either kind of career is in the “worst possible choice” spectrum. Instead, you should decide what would be the best goal to be pursuing seen from your perspective, completely leaving out the behavior of other people.

Yes, I agree.

Once you really understand that, then it makes some sense to ask “can I pursue that purpose in an academic context? can I pursue that working for some corporation? can I pursue that as an independent businessman?”

Right, I guess this is the central question. Currently I’m not convinced that I need an academic career to accomplish that, the only major argument would be that I’m good at it and that I get paid for it.

You may find that the freedom to pursue your own interests is more important, which would favor an academic career; but you may find that avoidance of bureaucracy is more important to you (well, in that case, you’re screwed).

:smiley:

The “paid through taxation” argument is a non-starter from an Objectivist perspective, given the nature of the society that you live in.

Sure, I don’t steal anyone’s money, I don’t force taxation on others and there are people who would gladly pay me for research, even without taxation.

Still I don’t feel very good about it, especially when doing theoretical research of which even I don’t know if that is of use to anyone. There is little oversight of what is being researched so I end up with a bad conscience. I have the same bad conscience when I get paid by the hours without much oversight what I did. I usually put in my best effort into each hour of work, ending up with good results, but (relatively, compared to others) less money. Yes, it’s useless to compare to others, still I end up with less money than I deserve (i.e. something like a ‘market price’ for my results).

That’s why I prefer to be paid by results than by effort.

Your concern with how papers “count” presupposes that your self-worth is determined by external praise and ignores the fact that mindless point-counting exists in all large organizations – it is probably even worse in the corporate world.

I guess the only real alternative is to be self employed and engineer a product that sells well. That, of course, would be the hardest, but most interesting, path I can take.

I don’t know what German law is, but I doubt seriously that all that you produce becomes “public domain”. (That may be true of patents, but that is not by any stretch “all” of what an academic does).

Mmh… well, you publish a paper, let’s say how to get from A to B in the shortest time, a company reads your paper, creates a product out of it and sells it.

But I think I should do more research into what rights I would retain from my work depending on the type of work and in which country I publish.

Thinking about it I guess I understand under “career” an occupation with which I make money which I then use to pursuit my real goals.

Ah! That’s the problem. That is not the correct view of career. A career (for a rational man) is the integration of “central purpose in life” and “means of survival”. It might be best to speak of “employment” as opposed to “central purpose in life”. If you can’t integrate the two, I sympathize. Imagine that you would really rather be studying the history of scientific reasoning, but you understand that it’s not possible for you to that as a sustained means of survival. Well, you realize that you can do database magic for a living and actually make enough money that you can eventually retire and pursue that principle interest of yours. Of course you do find performing database magic interesting, but not as interesting as actually researching the development of certain areas of epistemology.

My question then would be, just how incompatible are “your real interest” and “what you can do to make a living”?

What I know about academic computer science is that there are relatively few people for whom being an academic is actually a good thing for them, and the pay in industry is better. So unless you have an intellectual goal that is pretty esoteric, I wouldn’t think that an academic career is right for you based on what you’ve said.

There is little oversight of what is being researched so I end up with a bad conscience. I have the same bad conscience when I get paid by the hours without much oversight what I did.

You should do self-oversight. Is there any actual, objective merit to what you are researching? Are you doing excellent work?

That’s why I prefer to be paid by results than by effort.

Well, it seems that you’re almost there.

I guess the only real alternative is to be self employed and engineer a product that sells well.

No, you’re there.

Mmh… I guess I first have to figure out clearly what I want to achieve.

Still, science feels like giving out candy having an applauding audience with no clue what you’re doing…

I think there are some deeper issues involved, my mind-set is usually to go my own way, not wanting to be part of a larger movement/institution. Maybe I need some more work experience and finish some own projects before I really can say that I do want or do not want to join the science community.

@themadkat:

Reading your profile I wonder:

Do you see the environment of an academic career as an opportunity or as a necessary evil (i.e. you get paid for what you want to do and you have easy access to laboratories, books etc.)?

I ask because in computer science all I need is a computer :slight_smile:

I think I see it as an opportunity because I’m not sure what better way there would be to pursue my career goals. Unlike you (based on what you mentioned in my reply to DavidOdden), I do not view my career as a way to make money to achieve my “real” goals. My career is my “real” goal, or at least one of the major ones in my life. I can’t make do with just a computer, like you can. I need funding, which is nearly impossible to get outside of an institutional association. I need at least a little bit of lab space, although that’s not so much of a major concern unless I start doing some genetics as part of my larger project. I need equipment which, again, easier to get through an institution. But I think the major difference between me and you with regards to wanting to be in academia is that teaching is important to me and I look forward to it, whereas I don’t see you mention teaching at all. Certainly if you don’t want to teach or want to actively avoid it then academia may not be the best choice, but I am all about the teaching.

As for politics and jumping through hoops, there is no guarantee of any more freedom for yourself in a corporation than in academia. I don’t know how it works in Germany, but here in the States I have a lot of programmer friends who constantly complain to me how nothing they create while working for a given company belongs to them - in fact, sometimes what they create AFTER they quit belongs to their company, for a period of a few years even. Having worked in a corporation myself for a couple years, a tech company actually, I was constantly fighting with management both over the treatment of my employees (I was a supervisor) and the quality of the product, which I bent over backwards to maintain in the face of their poor planning and corner-cutting. They kept wanting to avoid taking the time to make the product right the first time, not understanding that when the customer gets their product and it’s wrong, we just have to do it again anyway, or even if a team further down the line at the company gets it and says they can’t work with it because it doesn’t meet quality. I kept trying to explain how much time and money is wasted by redoing things, sometimes more than once, and although they claimed to understand it they would never actually allow us to take the time to make it right on the first try, or would allow other departments to undo some of our work. It was maddening. At least the pay was good.

And is an academic career moral at all? There are companies where you can teach and research or you can publish books yourself, so there is an alternative.

Is it rational? What other reasons are there?

I’m actually in the exact same place as you. I finished my Master’s in Computer Science last year, and I’m about to start on my PhD this fall. I considered an academic career, but decided against it. I wouldn’t necessarily be opposed to it, but I would prefer to do research for an actual company (or start my own company).

An academic career is certainly rational, but may not be moral. The only reason I say that is because I think that government funding has ruined the concept of tenure and academic freedom. In an ideal environment, academia should isolate you completely from anything political so you are free to pursue your research and be influenced only by the truth. But if you ever want funding you need to play the political game. This is where some academics can lose their morals. Two examples of this are sociology and environmental research. Both of these areas tend to start with a political stance and try to find evidence that supports it (and ignoring evidence that would be inconvenient to their sources of funding). This clearly is not the scientific method, but that is the way these groups have to get funding.

Fortunately, you and I have selected a career that isn’t quite as politicized as others, so this shouldn’t be as much of an issue for you. However, you’ll end up dealing with politics no matter where you go. Unfortunately, it’s just a fact of life. :stuck_out_tongue: