Hi , Rana Here

hi…rana here,

i am abhishek singh rana …among our peers to be on last name basis is considered as a hint of closeness.

the story of my introduction to objectivism is an ironically unusual one. the guy who suggested A.S. to me is a kabadiwala…a kabadiwala is a guy who purchases old newspapers and sells these to paper mills for recycling, he keeps the chance books and sells these at low prices.

this kabadiwala freind of mine also keeps the pirated versions of certain popular novels. so it was reading from a pirated A.S. that i learned the basics of objectivism. i should mention here that i have already made amends for this ‘theft’ of mine.

the other day someone was asking Omkar Ghate on whether objectivism is getting popular in india (or something to that effect) …the fact that they have started pirating A.S. at least means that a lot are bring introduced to it.

Hi Rana!

Welcome to this forum.

Good to see a fellow Indian out here!!

Welcome to the forums!

Dinesh.

Hey Rana. Are you Sikh (at least culturally) by any chance?

thanks everyone. … …

satsriakal bigbangsingh…i am not a sikh…i am a rajput :wink:

thanks      everyone. … …

satsriakal  bigbangsingh…i am not a sikh…i  am a rajput :huh:

No Sat Sri Akal for me anymore as I’m now atheist :slight_smile:

At least we both have warrior blood :wink:

Hey guys,

Can you explain these concepts for me?

Sat Sri Akal

warrior blood

rajput

Thanks! :lol:

Hey guys,

Can you explain these concepts for me?

Sat Sri Akal

warrior blood

rajput

Thanks! :smiley:

“Sat Sri Akal” means “God Exists.” Sikhs and Rajputs traditionally belong to the warrior class, hence us sharing the name “Singh” (means “lion”).

Pirated versions of AS and most other Rand fiction has been sold in India as early as the 1980’s. Small-town railway stations (e.g. Muzzafarnagar) will usually have a “Wheelers” book stall. It is not surprizing to see “Introduction to Objectivist Epistemology” being sold (legitimate, not pirated versions).

India has a large English-literate population. Rand’s books are not the only ones to benefit from this. Lots of Indians can talk fluiently about Sartre, Kant, Marx, Kafka… you name it.

eran,satsriakal is a salutation.

i had an inkling that ‘satsriakal’ has got something to do with god,though wasnt sure of it… i dont have many sikh freinds :wink:

btw none of my ancestors was a warrior(to my knowledge) :stuck_out_tongue:

hey oaktree your knowledge of india is impressive …but my conclusions were based on my experience with the kabadiwala freind of mine…because he doesnt keep many pirated books(only the more popular ones)…

Well, I just added India to the list of countries I want to visit one day.

Many Israelis are obssesive about India. Some live there for years. But now that I know they sell copies of ITOE on wheel carts I simply have to go! :wink:

Welcome to the forum, Rana. I enjoyed the story of how you came to Objectivism. B)

so when are coming eran…btw how did fair on the little game of yours in my case?

i have suspiscion oaktree, that you are an indian …is that so??

i have suspiscion oaktree, that you are an indian …is that so??

Yes, indeed.

Warning, this is off-topic.

Once or twice when I have told someone I am Indian, they thought I meant “American Indian”.

I don’t like the terms “American Indian” and “Red Indian” because they institutionalize a historic error (though that does make them cute).

I find “Native American” to be far, far worse because I think it is used by some(incorrectly and politcally) to imply “True American”. This usurps the term “American”.

After thinking about it, I decided that whenever I think about it to myself, and whenever I can get away with it in public, I will use the term “aboriginee”. In some ways, it means “native”, but I think there are some connotations of tribalism and backwardness that it evoke that really annoy the aboriginees of the western hemisphere.

I agree with your assessment of “native American”. I am a native American, born and bred in this country.

I think aborigine is the correct term, but the term “Indian” is the common one used. The Indians never called themselves that, of course. It was the term coined by the Europeans because they originally thought they were in Asia. It’s how all those islands became the West Indies.

Most American Indians are still very tribal. The policies the government instituted after the Indian Wars has kept them tribal and backwards. Not all of them, of course. There are several tribes which assimilated. I am part Cherokee, as are many Americans, because a large number of Cherokees assimilated rather quickly into American life. I may be wrong, but I think the Cherokees were the only tribe to have an alphabet and a written history. They were a settled, agrarian people, for the most part, unlike other hunter-gatherer tribes.

Rana - Just out of curiosity, how did you make amends for your “theft”?

And, on another note, I was surprised to discover that Ayn Rand indeed has a following in India. When I was back in India, one of my friends told me about some kind of local Objectivist Club which he once contacted for a clarification about objectivism. Apparently, he asked them what would stop a criminal from thinking that murdering others was in his self-interest and that he was therefore morally justified in committing murder. The club came back to him with this concise response which said everything - “Where force begins, morality ends!”. I intend to contact the club and maybe join it when I go back to India.

Rana - Just out of curiosity, how did you make amends for your “theft”?

i dumped that book and bought a legitimate A.S. …

I intend to contact the club and maybe join it when I go back to India.

i too would like to be a part of such a club :wink:

If you are in the US right now, there are Objectivist Campus Clubs promoted by the ARI present in many universities around the country. You could try joining the one closest to you. I personally am trying to get into the objectivist club of the University of Minnesota which is a 10 minute bus from my workplace, but haven’t been able to contact them - I think it’s summer vacation time for them.

If you are in India, I don’t really know of any way of locating Objectivist Clubs close to where you live. The reason I don’t care to know right now is because I am not yet in India, but I do intend to find out if my return seems imminent.

i too would like to be a part of such a club

Which Indian city? I know objectivists in some cities.