Homogenization

Many in our country believe we are endangered by Balkanization; that a lack of association and the exchange of ideas among the social classes, and e.g., the universtiy educated and the uneducated, or “unmelted” emmigrants has led to the divide. They believe the remedy lies in some sort of national service or a draft. But, the proposed remedy is clearly immoral.

Is homogenization a worthy goal? Do we need to stir the melting pot, before civility and disciple can return to American society? If this is beneficial, is there a way of accomplishing it that is not immoral?

Many in our country believe we are endangered by Balkanization; that a lack of association and the exchange of ideas among the social classes, and e.g., the universtiy educated and the uneducated, or “unmelted” emmigrants has led to the divide.  They believe the remedy lies in some sort of national service or a draft. But, the proposed remedy is clearly immoral.

Is homogenization a worthy goal?  Do we need to stir the melting pot, before civility and disciple can  return to American society?    If this is beneficial, is there a way of accomplishing it that is not immoral?

I don’t think homogenization is at all a worthy goal. There are certain values which everybody should recognise, but not everything is in that category. What I think should happen is that people cling to traditional music, clothing, language or whatever bits of culture they cling to because it is a value. I’ve noticed that a lot of Otavaleño immigrants keep the traditional hair and clothing, and there is nothing at all wrong with that. On the other hand, the practice of forcing children into marriage at age 10 or so is not a proper value, and even when the element of actual force is eliminated and is replaced by heavy-handed family pressure, it’s still not a good thing, so that’s a tradition which could go bye-bye for my money.

The emphasis should not be on creating homogeneity, but on recognition of certain specific values (especially those that pertain to rights and responsibilities).

Homogeneity is something out of Hitler’s vision. Which homogeneity should an individualistic culture posses but the recognition of individual rights?

It’s not homogeneity, but rationality, we must encourage. They are often opposites.

Many in our country believe we are endangered by Balkanization; that a lack of association and the exchange of ideas among the social classes, and e.g., the universtiy educated and the uneducated, or “unmelted” emmigrants has led to the divide.

It is actually the successful association and exchange of ideas among the social classes which has led to the divide. It is not the communication that is the problem. It is the ideas that are the problem.

If you don’t want to balkanize people, then don’t teach them balkanizing ideas like multiculturalism and socialism.

The emphasis should not be on creating homogeneity, but on recognition of certain specific values (especially those that pertain to rights and responsibilities).

Specific values need to be shared, and not only among Objectivists, if they are to gain any widespread distribution. If prosletizing is your answer, have you been to any trailer parks, barrios, or black ghettos lately?

I’ve noticed that a lot of Otavaleño immigrants keep the traditional hair and clothing, and there is nothing at all wrong with that.

I’m not arguing that homogeneity is a valid value, but I don’t think that we should necessarily encourage people to cling to cultural traditions if there is no reason for it other than that it is a cultural tradition. I don’t know if this is the case with any of the specific things you have in mind, but sometimes clothing and such that is appropriate in one historical, cultural, geographic setting is not in another (because there may have been a reason for it in the original setting that is lost when the setting changes).

If you don’t want to balkanize people, then don’t teach them balkanizing ideas like multiculturalism and socialism.

Exactly.

Specific values need to be shared, and not only among Objectivists, if they are to gain any widespread distribution. If prosletizing is your answer, have you been to any trailer parks, barrios, or black ghettos lately?

Prostletizing is not my goal in life, but teaching is, which is how I work on getting those values explained to the masses. So yes to the last question.

I’m not arguing that homogeneity is a valid value, but I don’t think that we should necessarily encourage people to cling to cultural traditions if there is no reason for it other than that it is a cultural tradition.  I don’t know if this is the case with any of the specific things you have in mind, but sometimes clothing and such that is appropriate in one historical, cultural, geographic setting is not in another (because there may have been a reason for it in the original setting that is lost when the setting changes).

While clinging to something purely because it’s part of a traditional culture isn’t a reason to continue to do so, the fact that it is from “the old country” isn’t a reason to automatically reject it. What I had in mind was clothing that looks sharp and is perfectly serviceable here or there, whereas an Arctic fur parka is not all that serviceable in Louisiana in the summer. In contrast, the standard Muslim woman’s head-to-toe body bag is not at all attractive, and the only value it reflects is a religious one. Lose it, I say.

This has degenerated into a discussion of multi-culturalism. I was hoping to discuss the exchange of ideas among the populace at large. There are many, other than ethnic groups, who never come into contact with each other. Is there an ethical way to widen association and the exchange of ideas. A few letters to the editor and a few college courses have not sufficed. Collectivist philosophies of one variety or another dominate the culture, the Huns are at the door.

There are many, other than ethnic groups, who never come into contact with each other.

I’m not clear on who you mean. Are you saying that the educated never come in contact with the uneducated? That rich people never deal with poor people? Capitalists never talk to socialists? Objectivists never date non-Objectivists?

What kind of non-racial classes are you talking about?

…In contrast, the standard Muslim woman’s head-to-toe body bag is not at all attractive, and the only value it reflects is a religious one. Lose it, I say.

Yes, this is the kind of thing I had in mind. I’m glad we are in agreement. :dough:

There are many, other than ethnic groups, who never come into contact with each other.  Is there an ethical way to widen association and the exchange of ideas.  A few letters to the editor and a few college courses have not sufficed.  Collectivist philosophies of one variety or another dominate the culture, the Huns are at the door.

Objectivists often engage in ad hoc activism with various groups where there is a common issue or value at stake. We have worked with Leftist and Feminist groups on abortion rights, the Cuban community on the Elian Gonzalez issue, Christians on school choice, etc.

When we act with other groups, Objectivists have run the show and made Objectivist arguments for our positions. As a result, we have exposed many non-Objectivists to our ideas.

Objectivists often engage in ad hoc activism with various groups where there is a common issue or value at stake. We have worked with Leftist and Feminist groups on abortion rights, the Cuban community on the Elian Gonzalez issue, Christians on school choice, etc.

When we act with other groups, Objectivists have run the show and made Objectivist arguments for our positions. As a result, we have exposed many non-Objectivists to our ideas.

This is the interaction I would endorse as well, but then why was David Kelly so roundly excoriated by Leonard Peikoff for speaking before a Libertarian group?

This is the interaction I would endorse as well, but then why was David Kelly so roundly excoriated by Leonard Peikoff for speaking before a Libertarian group?

The key is this:

When we act with other groups, Objectivists have run the show

When we act with other groups, Objectivists have run the show

What does this mean?

It means that when an Objectivist appeals to the values of a contradictory philosophy, he sacrifices his own.

When he does so in the name of Ayn Rand, he is do be denounced in the name of Ayn Rand.

Significant parts of a culture are always going to be somewhat arbitrary, and I would say that diversity in these is definitely a positive thing. Whereas issues such as morality, fundamental value choices, and government may be considered objective to the point where homogenity is good, other topics such as clothing, hair, music, funerals, sexuality (in the aesthetic sense), respected careers, hobbies, food and a million other things generally provide very little objective basis on which to say that one cultural attitude is superior to another. For these, I think that diversity is normally pleasant, even if only for no other reason than to stop people falling into the trap of thinking that armani suits, basketball, french fries, and 9-5 jobs somehow represent the essence of normality. In other words, it helps people to notice that the attitudes of their own culture are fairly arbitrary in certain areas, and they may encounter an alternative viewpoint which they like more (for instance I think the Western tradition of funerals is a bit silly, and there are several other cultures which have alternative practices which I may prefer).

Objectivists often engage in ad hoc activism with various groups where there is a common issue or value at stake. We have worked with Leftist and Feminist groups on abortion rights, the Cuban community on the Elian Gonzalez issue, Christians on school choice, etc.

I believe you missed this feldblum.

This is the interaction I would endorse as well, but then why was David Kelly so roundly excoriated by Leonard Peikoff for speaking before a Libertarian group?

This is part of Kelleyite Mythology. In fact, it was Peter Schwartz who criticized Kelley for that appearance. Peikoff broke with Kelley years previously for other reasons.