From a rights perspective, it seems that it would be the responsibility of people who did want to be treated to carry something which implied a contract. It sounds terribly cold, but it would probablybe in a hospital’s best interest to let someone die out in the street if they had not bracelet.
Carrying a ‘bracelet’ indicating your willingness to pay for what can be deemed ‘necessary’ medical treatement is exactly the solution to this problem. I say ‘bracelet’ because this could easily be a card in your wallet, a chip implanted in your skin, or an entry in an online fingerprint database that states your preferences. I say ‘necessary’ because if there were a dispute, whether or not a specific treatment for a specific person was ‘necessary’ could be determined through the court system.
Personally, I’d want this system anyway, because it would also allow me to inform the hospital of any medication I was taking, my blood type, any allergies, my closest relatives, and a plethora of other useful information.
In reality, we already partially have this system. If I got hit by a truck today, they’d look in my wallet, find out who I am, and use that to track down my doctor and my relatives. The doctor would have all pertinent medical information. Furthermore, my driver’s license says I’m a willing organ donor in case I’m dead anyway and someone needs organs (this is a statewide program that probably exists in most states). Finally, I have my insurance card in my wallet, and the doctor has my insurance records.
Someone could probably make a lot of money by formalizing a system of medical identification or doing an online fingerprint thing, and making it relatively inexpensive. Then there would be no excuse for someone who wasn’t on record as being willing to pay for necessary procedures. Only the most destitute people would fall into that category, and as a doctor, while I’d want to save the average accident victim out of ‘goodness’ (and hope I’d get compensated), I’d probably not feel bad about letting the crackhead, or the ghetto dweller who is simply hoping for a freebie, die - because those people would essentially either be trying to game the system, or they’d legitimately rather die than make the commitment to pay it back (very rarely indeed).
By the way, if I were a doctor and a person with bone cancer came to me for help, I’d ask him to set up a plan of repayment, kind of like a loan (and I think you can get medical loans these days). If the person said they were too poor to afford the procedure that way (i.e. they refused to get a job), I’d tell them they weren’t worth the resources it would take to save them.