How is the initial right of ownership in a piece of land rightfully acquired?
Good question. There has been some prior discussion about this: http://forum.objectivismonline.com/index.php?showtopic=23717
Nicky covers the Objectivist response well, but there remains some troubling issues to resolve. For example, Nicky is correct to say private ownership starts with forming a governing body with objective criteria for claiming property, i.e. rightful ownership requires the establishment of objective rights. However in the context of the American frontier, did the Indian’s lack of objective criteria for claiming property justify removing them from it? Would objective criteria for claiming property have been sufficient, had Indian weapons been equal to or better than the Europeans??
I prefer John Locke’s argument for acquiring property, but won’t bother to rehash that here. I’ll simply refer you to Chapter 5 of his Second Treatise for Civil Government if you’re interested. Essentially the first acquisition of real estate is like plucking a pebble from a beach; so long as there remains an abundance of pebbles, no one cares. But the moment someone else wants your pebble, you need force to secure your right to it. The two maxims that always apply are: possession is 9/10ths of the law, and might makes right.