How Should An Objectivist Vote?

I have noticed in a number of threads commenting about voting. In the past twenty years since being locked out of the Wisconsin 2nd District Democratic Caucus in 1984, I have been refining my method of voting. I think that my method may appeal to some Objectivist. The method I used is based on a method described by Robert Heinlein in his novel Time Enough for Love. Very simply, research all the candidates and rank them in the order of who will do the most damage to your ideals. From this you can develop a list of which you want to vote against. This can vary for the different elections, i.e., in the primary, you might vote for Kerry over Dean because you see Dean as the bigger threat. Later you might vote for Bush over Kerry because Kerry is the bigger threat to you ideals. (I am using Bush, Kerry, and Dean only as examples, I am not stating that you should vote for any of these hotdogs.) One more thing, never vote for a nonviable candidate when voting against some one, vote for some one who might make it. Finally, never vote for candidates in uncontested races, their egos are big enough without adding to it.

Sorry if I sound cynical, but I live just outside of Madison, Wisconsin, where new-age liberalism reigns.

Sorry if I sound cynical, but I live just outside of Madison, Wisconsin, where new-age liberalism reigns.

What’s Paul Soglin up to these days?

Around 1970, when he was head of the local SDS, I debated him on a panel in front of a throng of maybe 1,000 of his supporters. I left Madison in 1972 and I was quite surprised to learn that he then became mayor.

Btw, I was in Madison when they blew up the Math-Science Bldg. I actually heard the explosion. When I was studying for my Masters exams in my rooming house on Bassett St. (right across from the football stadium) the police were teargassing rioting students right outside my window!

Quite a period.

(We had formed a group, CDIR - Committee to Defend Individual Rights - to oppose the SDS. There were all of about a dozen of us but we got a lot of play way out of proportion to our numbers. I learned a lot from the experience.)

Fred Weiss

How Should An Objectivist Vote?

Major Premise: All mortals should vote their conscience.

Minor Premise: An Objectivists is a mortal.

Conclusion: An Objectivists should vote his conscience.

(I just thought I’d bring the age-old archetype up to date.)

Objectivists shouldn’t vote except for a moral Objectivist. Otherwise you are a victim offering his sanction to his destroyers!

Ah, but is that practical, Xanadu? If you don’t vote, and disaster strikes, and New York’s lights go out, will your position be, “but I couldn’t help it, the perfect candidate didn’t run!”?

No, it is not practical. And by that statement, I mean to imply: it is not moral.

A absurd as it may sound; as a democracy if you cannot vote for a standing candidate then it is your duty for you to stand for those policy’s you feel a perfect leader would represent.

If someone from this board was to stand, an objectivist - would you not vote for him? or would you vote for the lesser of two evils?

As absurd as it may sound; as a democracy if you cannot vote for a standing candidate then it is your duty for you to stand for those policy’s you feel a perfect leader would represent.

Why? And why is it your duty rather than to your self-interest?

If someone from this board was to stand, an objectivist - would you not vote for him? or would you vote for the lesser of two evils?

That would depend on whether he had a real chance of being elected. If the only electable candidates were the “evils,” a vote for anyone else would be wasted.

hint, hint: I would love to see someone write a FAQ on this for the wiki, so we could just link newbie’s to it in the future…

QUOTE (Charles @ Jul 11 2004, 12:14 AM)

As absurd as it may sound; as a democracy if you cannot vote for a standing candidate then it is your duty for you to stand for those policy’s you feel a perfect leader would represent. 

Why? And why is it your duty rather than to your self-interest?

Not rather than; it is a mattter of duty because in a democratic state the only way you are going to uphold your ideals of individuality and freedom to be self- interested in the longterm (as far a voting is concerned) is to stand yourself; that is if no other government candidate comes even close to your position.

Im not advocating duty as defined in terms of democracy, i haven’t put forward support for democracy. Im simply talking about the necessary measures to be taken in liu of ones ideals when voting in a country that pertains to be democratic.

hint, hint

GreedyCapitalist = pseudo-objectivist

They are synonyms.

hint, hint

GreedyCapitalist = pseudo-objectivist

They are synonyms.

baseless ad hominem against the admin = short term forum account

:wink:

hint, hint

GreedyCapitalist = pseudo-objectivist

They are synonyms.

Where did that even come from? Is it something I said or do you object to my nickname?

Just a joke. Sorry I forgot to put “Just Kidding”

I guess it wasn’t as obvious as I estimated

Sorry

Just a joke.  Sorry I forgot to put “Just Kidding”

I guess it wasn’t as obvious as I estimated

Sorry

I’m sorry, but I still don’t get it.

How Should An Objectivist Vote?       

According to his/her own best judgment. :smiley:

It is immoral to vote! Why retain or vote in another socialist? These “politicians” only differ in their degree and kind of socialism. One advocates looting through welfare while the other protectionism. Why admire or support those who seek to plunder us?

Exactly, why give my murder my sanction?

It is immoral to vote!  Why retain or vote in another socialist?  These “politicians” only differ in their degree and kind of socialism.

Yes, but some socialists will buy us more time than other socialists and we can use that time to make the necessary revolutionary changes.

Yes, but some socialists will buy us more time than other socialists and we can use that time to make the necessary revolutionary changes.

Unfortunately true. Both parties lead the road to hell, just one happens to be the express lane.

Why could the question not be posed as ‘which candidated best represents the free market and capitalism and defends each (along with property rights et al)?’

I understand Rand’s take on it…i don’t need to be versed on it again and again, but as a necessity to slow the progression towards communism, should it be important to vote regardless of the evils/altruism of political parties?

Both parties lead the road to hell, just one happens to be the express lane.

Why could the question not be posed as ‘which candidate best represents the free market and capitalism and defends each (along with property rights et al)?’

Because that is not a realistic choice … yet.

I understand Rand’s take on it…i don’t need to be versed on it again and again, but as a necessity to slow the progression towards communism, should it be important to vote regardless of the evils/altruism of political parties?

Certainly, if the vote might make a difference – as in the slow lane versus the express lane to hell.