I became an apostate -- tempus fugit

5 hours ago, DonAthos said:

You mean to tell me that, because I recognize the problems with, for instance, Islam, I cannot also identify the problems in Christianity? Because the world lumps itself into “left” versus “right,” I must pick a side – for pragmatic reasons – and thereafter only find the faults in my supposed opponent?

If that’s the thrust of your response,  I strongly disagree. There is irrationality all around, I’m afraid, and on every side. If we mean to advocate a philosophy of reason, then we must identify that fact without hesitation. Evangelists absolutely belong with, for instance, the jihadists – whom our current Western evangelists would more and more closely resemble, if they ever again got a whiff of real power.

In fact, with respect to some socialists*, I would say that the faults of evangelism are typically graver as they represent an earlier/more fundamental breach with reality. There are some socialists who broadly accept “reason” as a governing epistemological principle, and then incorrectly believe that socialism itself is the reasonable means to govern, or effect justice. They’re wrong, and that error has grave implications and must be addressed, but it is worse to deny reason itself – which, obviously, can itself have dire consequences politically, even if someone claims to be an advocate for “capitalism.”

(* I say “some socialists,” because there are, obviously, many other socialists who also reject reason explicitly… and there are even some special folk who are both “evangelist” and “socialist.”)

That said, it’s true that we might sometimes make common cause with some given individual or group to achieve some specific end or narrow range of goals. I agree that that’s in the nature of politics, and it might sometimes involve some temporary and delimited agreement with the “right” (to the extent that they support a “pro-business” agenda, for instance; so long as their “pro-business” ideas are not, themselves, “class warfare” waged from the other side) and it might sometimes involve some temporary and delimited agreement with the “left” (e.g. to support marijuana legalization or the de-criminalization of sex work).

In every election, ultimately, a ballot must be cast: and I’ve seen you stump for Trump, which I’ll allow so long as you understand that – as an American citizen who has to live with him as my president, my representative in the world – I would rather vote for a cheese sandwich.

But none of that ever means that we stop recognizing the faults of those with whom we make such common cause, or that they get a “pass.” Because I recognize the dangers of Antifa, that doesn’t make me conservative or “alt-right,” any more than recognizing the problems with the Proud Boys suggests that I should throw a brick through a Starbucks window. I will only ever find “common ground” with the “left” or the “right” to the extent that I believe they’re actually correct on any given issue, and that is the full extent of my participation, my consent, my sanction. I will not join their teams. I will not play their game.

Of course one can and should identify and assess all that’s about us in such difficult times - but of course too, one must identify that *this* is morally worse that *that*.

‘In kind but not in degree’ matters greatly.

Which is why I disagree with your equivalence. There is none, not between evangelicals and Jihadis. There is with the faith of Islam, qua faith, mind you (at their common religious roots, I’d argue that Christianity has evolved much further then Islam): but not an iota with Jihadis.

You can call out a single violent episode by one religionist, not representative of the millions of evangelicals and believe there is a pattern of violence endemic to all, but it is false. Conversely the method, tactics and actions of Jihadis has violent terror as its mission and identity. . 

Nobody gets a “pass”. This is a state of emergency the civilised, semi-free world has arrived at. The opportunists are flocking to take advantage and remove whatever there existed of individual freedom and impose greater control. “The New Normal” is unspecified but it won’t be good.

Yes, I stump for Trump not because I necessarily have to like him and his behavior, but because I saw the early signals of what the Left was up to, and that for the sake of the US (and elsewhere) they must be slowed in their tracks. Their worsening insane and inciting behavior, counter to the good of the nation, mostly bears out that observation.

Trump doesn’t get a pass, especially nor should his opponents. . 

I state it baldy, whatever his personable faults:

America under Trump was “doing too damned well”.

A little more precise, America in the time of Trump’s presidency - was doing too well - in many eyes, (there and overseas). These are the sacrificers of value to a non- value. Definite anti-capitalists despising their country. The Leftists of course could see they were bleeding votes to the remarkable employment figures and were desperate to regain power. It should not be surprising that a president who insisted on American independence and self-interest in the world, would be responded to with a booming economy. (I’ve remarked on “business confidence”, an intangible, a sort of psychological consequence to Trump’s general - if confusing - approach).

With not the least good faith, considering that we know that private enterprise is the root of capitalism, many Objectivists nominated him an economic nationalist… I find that and the largely unfounded “racist” slurs on him prejudiced and irrational, and rationalist and intrinsicist.

In the greatest of misfortunes, a one-two blow - the pandemic and then the killing of a black man put a stop to the economy and then ‘caused’ the social and racial upheaval. For the Left, don’t believe their protestations of sorrow and anger at injustice (they are victimologists, finding victims to feed off, to further power is all they know how to do) In your identifications, DA, you will have seen the role of the vile mainstream media in shrewdly playing up those misfortunes.

In all, the enemy of my enemy is not necessarily my friend. But too, the enemy of my enemy can be my ally in a state of emergency.

14 minutes ago, DonAthos said:

You’re talking past everything I actually say, to argue against something I have not said. It is supremely frustrating.

While I could engage on you whether Christianity is somehow a “religion of peace” (despite all of its history), better or worse than Islam in that or any other respect, I fear that I could not expect any better behavior in that conversation – or even for you to agree that it is itself a tangential distraction from the matter we had initially been discussing.

You paid me a compliment in another thread, but the far better compliment would be to repay my efforts with honesty.

I did reply with honesty.  I’m saying that due to the nature of the religions in question, the specific characteristics, they should NOT just be clumped in with each other.

Just because you choose to see things differently from me, or better put, not see any significant difference between the religions, (this is taken from the totality of your comments which tend to homogenize rather than differentiate), does not mean I am replying dishonestly… to get personal and claim I am dishonest because I don’t see it the way you do is very condescending and, frankly inappropriate.

We simply had an honest disagreement… until you made it personal. 

“There’s that housing settlement for the workers of San Sebastián. It cost eight million dollars. Steel-frame houses, with plumbing, electricity and refrigeration. Also a school, a church, a hospital and a movie theater. A settlement built for people who had lived in hovels made of driftwood and stray tin cans. . . . The wonderful roads we graded up four thousand feet of rock for the People’s State of Mexico, will not last beyond a couple of winters: they’re cheap cement without foundation, and the bracing at the bad turns is just painted clapboard. Wait for one good mountain slide. The church, I think, will stand. They’ll need it.”

As a primitive form of philosophy, Rand may have weighed the thought of a people with enduring under a purer form of skepticism. She had softened her stance of 1934 by the time she penned these words.

Accept the notion that man has a philosophy whether he thinks he does or doesn’t, and a philosophy that gilded itself in myths was seeking to explain the human condition observed around it, albeit, more metaphorically so.

 

As to disseminating her views, Miss Rand stated that she did it out of cowardice in that she saw the consequences of philosophy too clearly. (If this was done tongue in cheeks, I don’t recall her facial expression betraying that.)

Look at the time it took for Christianity to spread. While the Bible alone is not responsible for bringing it about, it is a book that many a theologian used to exhort those in the world around him. In such a sense, consider the impact that one book of its nature has had on the world.

It could be an interesting observation to learn if there are numbers that could provide the basis for graphs of the growth of Christianity over the centuries, and ask while looking at them, if this one book could influence so many over this period of time, imagine what Rand’s collection of fiction is doing as it continues to be in the world.

 

14 hours ago, dream_weaver said:

It could be an interesting observation to learn if there are numbers that could provide the basis for graphs of the growth of Christianity over the centuries, and ask while looking at them, if this one book could influence so many over this period of time, imagine what Rand’s collection of fiction is doing as it continues to be in the world.

Imagine what presence Rand’s entire collection of works would be enjoying today if Rand were just as passionate, just as logical, but a style which was wholly benevolent, positive, encouraging, uplifting, and having little to none, of it s emphasis of using the negative, the ugly, the flawed, as its foil.  Imagine replacing all of the acerbic, almost hyperbolic alarm, with a style conveying the same important substance, with smiling optimism, and untouchable inner peace, resolute and passionate.

Imagine a body of work devoted only to what IS and should BE, without skipping a beat over what isn’t or shouldn’t or should never be.

Imagine the benevolence principle incarnate, in a philosopher who is as passionate as Rand, as charismatic as Francisco, and as undefeatable as Galt… and as playful and light as… well we need to look to other authors for that… (one character that comes to mind is Tom Bombadil of the Lord of the Rings… even though I tend to dislike the character.. a bit of the twinkle in his eye would be the kind of ingredient needed here)

and imagine that in the philosopher and throughout the works

where would, where could we be now?

7 hours ago, StrictlyLogical said:

Imagine the benevolence principle incarnate, in a philosopher who is as passionate as Rand, as charismatic as Francisco, and as undefeatable as Galt… and as playful and light as… well we need to look to other authors for that… (one character that comes to mind is Tom Bombadil of the Lord of the Rings… even though I tend to dislike the character.. a bit of the twinkle in his eye would be the kind of ingredient needed here)

I get the twinkle in his eye part, but I couldn’t help but think of this scene from Groundhog’s Day:

Spoiler

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YAPazuqLkx4