1 hour ago, HowardRoarkSpaceDetective said:
It sounds, from what the experts say, that my problem really centers on the desire for omniscience, or in other words, frustration with having limits.
It sounds to me like your problem centers around the relationship between evidence and truth, which is itself a bit of an abstraction. I expect that you don’t have totally crazy ideas, but let’s test that. With your eyes open, put your right hand in front of your face and determine whether the following proposition is true: “I see my right hand”. I assume you feel that the proposition is true, and that you find this very strongly to be true. Next, watch a moving car approaching an intersection and, 100 ft before the intersection decide whether the following proposition is true: “That car will turn right”. Notice that I set this up so that different circumstances could lead you to different evaluations. I expect that your will not feel very strongly that the proposition is true (or false).
Your feeling of certainty about your hand versus uncertainty about the car is about alternative propositions. To be concrete, let’s say that the car is in the right-hand lane, they signal for a right turn, and they start to slow down. This is good evidence that the proposition is true, but it doesn’t require much mulling-over to see that there are still possibilities for stopping and not turning, going straight through, and even turning left. Another “possibility” is that a black hole will develop into which the car will vanish. That is a crazy alternative, in contrast to the reasonable alternatives which I’ve given. I am directing your attention to Peikoff’s evidentiary continuum and the difference between claims that are possible, probable versus certain (plus, arbitrary which is totally of the scale). Reasonable people do not entertain unreasonable propositions, which is to say propositions that enjoy no factual support an serve merely as conjectures designed to defeat knowledge. If you do seriously consider the possibility that you don’t see your hand, you have a very serious problem.
I have spoken of feelings here because that is not people usually talk, but Objectivism is about what is, and not what you feel. When you read OPAR “Reason”, notice what thing is “certain” – the proposition, not the person. A true proposition is one that correctly states an aspect of reality (a fact), and truth is not determined by the quality of the evidence for it – which is why propositions are either true or false, and not undecided. The evidentiary scale is a tool for making a judgment as to truth. I find that many people do not properly distinguish between truth and evidence, which leads to theories of “truth” whereby a well-supported false claim is “true”. No being has direct infallible access to truth, we always approach truth via knowledge judgments.
My suggestion is to take a few moments to scrutinize real things that you know, and to more explicitly say what your basis is for “knowing” this, and for dismissing alternatives. Cases like the hand in front of the face, and then things that are slightly less self evident. The central question should be, what is the evidence for and against the proposition, and what are the alternatives and their (counter)evidence. Omniscience is not required, what is required is that in making these judgments, you integrate everything that you know – you don’t have to take into consideration everything that I know. You can and should, of course, ask about things that I know if you suspect that there is a specific fact that I know and that would be relevant to your judgment.