Intellectual Property: A Thought Experiment

No you did not. You said, “You’re convinced that…” and I labeled that as ‘psychobabble’. It was an irrelevant aside. Let us continue. I still would like a reply to my question about copyrights. Then I will respond to your other items.

I had thought that our respective positions on copyright were well understood.  Since that seems to not be the case…

 

It is moral for an architect to be able to assign copyright protection to the drawings and specifications that he produces, in order to prohibit their unauthorized use in the construction of a building.  I do not concede your notion that copyrights are an unethical abuse of State power, or that they in some way constitute an initiation of force, either explicit or implied.

IP is not a variant of property; it is anti-property.

Indeed! And I’ve noticed some things about that which beg an interesting question.

The first is that, while noncontractual “ownership” of anyone else’s actions logically leads to nursemaid statism, its advocates usually attempt to avoid this (specifically in defining “patentability”) by excluding drawbacks from their corresponding benefits (Nobel’s guilt) and excluding evaluations from their corresponding facts (the scientific can be owned but not the philosophical).

While both accurately reflect Rand’s essays on IP, they both strike me as very acausal; very Kantian.

The second is that the whole thing hinges on that “mind acting through other bodies” (which is a perfect summary), which means that nobody is responsible for their own natures (the innovator is), which flies in the face of everything else Rand thought.


Not only is IP anti-property, it’s anti-mind and anti-self. What I don’t understand yet is what the rest of it stems from.

Where is the root of the error?

Because despite its similarities to “you didn’t build that” it still isn’t quite the same. Every single variety of Collectivist I’m aware of hates innovators, to their core, but here’s a collectivist concept which seems to be the opposite.

So what is the root of it?

Why do you think the morality/legality distinction is important here? I already explained how I think IP is the same as any other kind of property, so it should be treated like land or objects. I gave reasons why the concept of IP matters. I also explained why it deserves legal protection.

If you study the history of IP law you will find it is wholly a legal construct, invented to avoid the need for thousands of non-disclosure agreements. The common law attitude has long been trade secrets have identifiable protections, common knowledge does not. The very lack of ‘moral’ common ground has made IP law the gnarled, convoluted mess it is today, pretty much the world over…

No, my reasons have to do with first use - not first thought - and that is exactly what Ayn says.

No, it is not. But, as you posted earlier, you think that her quotes can be used to support either side of this debate, so I’m not sure why you’re using them now. But, it’s not actually true that she can be accurately quoted supporting two sides of an issue she clearly wrote about. She had one consistent view on property rights, which includes intellectual property. In fact, if intellectual property is invalid, so is Rand’s entire basis for ethics and politics.

You say the man who did not think up the original idea deserves to be able to copy the man who did think up the original idea. This is the core of your argument, right? Do you not see how this contradicts your supposed emphasis on *use* in your justification for property rights? You can’t use something without knowing how, and you say this is “OBVIOUS.” Does use not originate from one man’s ideas? If one man learns ideas for use from another man’s prior thinking effort, who deserves the most benefit in a socioeconomic context?

But, you drop the appropriate context, repeatedly. In every post. When context is brought up, you simply repeat the same statements again and again: “IP is not property.” Why? “Property is only material things.” Why?

Howard,

As near as I can tell, if you stole the unpublished manuscript of Atlas Shrugged, and sold it to a Publisher, you would agree that Rand would have the right to take you to court, but only for the $10 or so value of the paper that the manuscript was printed on?

Howard,

As near as I can tell, if you stole the unpublished manuscript of Atlas Shrugged, and sold it to a Publisher, you would agree that Rand would have the right to take you to court, but only for the $10 or so value of the paper that the manuscript was printed on?

You have now shifted from refusing to answer questions about your own position to telling me what my position is. Amazing.

No, it is not. But, as you posted earlier, you think that her quotes can be used to support either side of this debate, so I’m not sure why you’re using them now. But, it’s not actually true that she can be accurately quoted supporting two sides of an issue she clearly wrote about. She had one consistent view on property rights, which includes intellectual property. In fact, if intellectual property is invalid, so is Rand’s entire basis for ethics and politics.

You say the man who did not think up the original idea deserves to be able to copy the man who did think up the original idea. This is the core of your argument, right? Do you not see how this contradicts your supposed emphasis on *use* in your justification for property rights? You can’t use something without knowing how, and you say this is “OBVIOUS.” Does use not originate from one man’s ideas? If one man learns ideas for use from another man’s prior thinking effort, who deserves the most benefit in a socioeconomic context?

But, you drop the appropriate context, repeatedly. In every post. When context is brought up, you simply repeat the same statements again and again: “IP is not property.” Why? “Property is only material things.” Why?

Ayn, in the quotes I have offered, does take the same position as I do (and John Lock does). In supporting IP, she contradicts these quotes. I agree with what I have quoted and disagree with her support for IP.

Your claim that without IP, Ayn’s entire ethics becomes invalid, is itself invalid. Without IP, humans would still have their minds, their liberty, their property (acquired by the first-use principal) and the NAP.

And you ask another question that has been repeatedly answered: who deserves? This whole question of “just deserts” has been covered and re-covered. The answer is to be found in the quotes from Ayn that I have offered. Read them. She does not mention who originated the knowledge.

She says property belongs to whoever applies knowledge to un owned materials and resources. Is she wrong or does that not mean what it says or will you be ignoring that quote?

Your insistence that this only counts for those who originated the knowledge is clearly a failure to comprehend what she actually wrote. Don’t get me wrong - I am not claiming to be right because Ayn agrees with the first-use principal. The point here is that she does in fact agree with it, and her quotes make that clear, and I agree with it and, apparently, you don’t.

You ask, “If one man learns ideas for use from another man’s prior thinking effort, who deserves the most benefit in a socioeconomic context?”

How often must this be answered before you will admit that it has been answered? You deserve the property that you have invested your knowledge and effort in, nothing more. Reread Ayn’s quote, or John Lock or the many posts in this thread. You do not deserve someone else’s property simply because what they are doing with their property reminds you of what you did with your property.

You accuse me of dropping context, but neglect to say what context I am dropping. Did I drop your IP context? That’s not a context. Did I forget to include the human mind? Quite the opposite. DonAthos has replied to this point (the effort of applying un-original knowledge) in great detail with no comment from you.

It appears to me that you do not read carefully or do not remember what has already been said in this debate, or haven’t even bothered to follow it. You end with two “why” questions that have been repeatedly answered.

Meanwhile, I continue to wait for one of the pro-IP debaters to name what is taken from them when someone copies their ideas. Silence ensues of course because the answer is: Nothing!

You have now shifted from refusing to answer questions about your own position to telling me what my position is. Amazing.

See post 261. 

See post 261.

My original question (205 & 213) asked if you agreed that force was only justified for self defense. That’s a yes or no question. 261 says you do not concede that enforcement of IP law is an initiation of force.

I interpret this to mean that IP infringement must therefore be an initiation of force. But I dislike having to interpret indirect answers in a debate. So, to clarify your position, I ask:

Do you believe that:

IP infringement is an initiation of force?

My original question (205 & 213) asked if you agreed that force was only justified for self defense. That’s a yes or no question. 261 says you do not concede that enforcement of IP law is an initiation of force.

I interpret this to mean that IP infringement must therefore be an initiation of force. But I dislike having to interpret indirect answers in a debate. So, to clarify your position, I ask:

Do you believe that:

IP infringement is an initiation of force?

Moving on, Howard.  I should have dropped this discussion on your response #205.  In my book, your views are parasitical.  I can’t imagine that anything will come of further discussions.

Moving on, Howard.  I should have dropped this discussion on your response #205.  In my book, your views are parasitical.  I can’t imagine that anything will come of further discussions.

Well, as I have made clear in several posts, IP law and NAP are in direct contradiction. You refuse to answer questions that would lead to that contradiction becoming explicit. Instead you cook up examples which describe me as breaking and entering to steal manuscripts and you now deploy the term “parasitic” while announcing that you will not debate further. Good.

You claim that copyright enFORCEment is not an initiation of force.

It follows that copyright infringement IS an initiation of force, which is obvious nonsense.

My original question (205 & 213) asked if you agreed that force was only justified for self defense. That’s a yes or no question. 261 says you do not concede that enforcement of IP law is an initiation of force.

I interpret this to mean that IP infringement must therefore be an initiation of force. But I dislike having to interpret indirect answers in a debate. So, to clarify your position, I ask:

Do you believe that:

IP infringement is an initiation of force?

Since it seems like an answer may not be soon in coming from other quarters, I’ll say that it was this very question, which I’d initially asked of myself, that started me down this particular path of thought.

For here are a couple of my beliefs on the subject of rights and force:

I believe that rights may only be violated by the initiation of the use of physical force.

I believe that physical force is justified in retaliation to its initiation (and only in retaliation).

And so I started thinking of examples of IP and trying to view them in terms of the initiation of force (and also what retaliatory force would mean).

For instance, in post #230, I spoke of some scenarios where I have (or would) take actions contra-IP which I still consider to be moral action. It doesn’t really comprise an argument, per se, but perhaps it speaks to some sort of… inductive approach to trying to convey my sense of IP? I don’t really know! :slight_smile: Anyways, this was one of my scenarios:

 

If I were a farmer and involved in plowing my fields, and if I saw that my neighbor had discovered some better way to plow fields, I would adopt that methodology without a moment’s hesitation (assuming that such a thing otherwise made sense for me to do). I would not feel guilty for having done so. (Rather, I would feel guilty if I didn’t.) Though I might feel appreciative towards my neighbor, and his ingenuity, I would not feel that I somehow required his permission to improve my own lot, or to make use of what I had witnessed.

Now… perhaps this does not run afoul of every possible IP scheme that the advocates of IP might propose – there is a great variety, after all. But in my opinion, this is a direct violation of the kind of IP that Ayn Rand proposes, and for the very reasons that she gives.

I’m engaged in “mindless copying,” aren’t I? I’m seizing the value that my neighbor’s mind has created – a truly parasitical act, no?

And thus…

I’m initiating the use of physical force against my neighbor? By learning a better way of plowing my fields (through observing my neighbor, true) and putting it to use, to better my life?

And furthermore! Now I have made moral the use of retaliatory force against me!

It may suit us now to cast such a retaliatory force as some sort of antiseptic “fine” levied by an austere judge or something. I think that’s how most conceive of it. But it doesn’t have to be so. We are talking about physical force after all – its initiation and retaliation. So we can ask ourselves questions like… what if the local law refused to take action against me (or didn’t exist)? What would my neighbor be morally justified in doing?

What about seizing the produce from my fields at the point of his gun? What about burning down my fields altogether?

I don’t expect any advocate of IP to follow us all the way down such a path of thought. And yet, I believe it’s consistent with what they argue, whether they allow themselves to understand it or not. John Galt said:

 

It is only as retaliation that force may be used and only against the man who starts its use. No, I do not share his evil or sink to his concept of morality: I merely grant him his choice, destruction, the only destruction he had the right to choose: his own. He uses force to seize a value; I use it only to destroy destruction.

IP, and the arguments that underlay it, has my act of improving my farmland as me “using force to seize a value.” It is me choosing my own destruction, through the act of destruction that I have myself performed.

Destruction?

Human learning (which is ultimately what the anti-concept of “mindless copying” resolves into), productivity, and the increase of actual, material wealth – me acting for the betterment of my own life, in improving my plot of land while hurting no one – is destruction???

I honestly feel that it is ludicrous on its face.

Now… there might be some out there who might even embrace this monstrosity. They might follow a path of mental math like this:

It is the mind which creates value, and thus a Mind owns that value which it creates. An innovator is entitled to Intellectual Property. The farmer owns the methods of improving farmland which he innovates. Thus for me (the second farmer) to use his method without permission *is* the initiation of physical force. Physical force in response to its initiation is entirely justified, and yes – in a certain setting – that might mean burning down my farmland. For after all, that is only “destroying destruction.”

But what can I do for such a person? If they can’t bring themselves to recognize that this is a horror… then what could I possibly say that would help them make that connection? Dub it rationalism? Propose that if “the initiation of physical force” were confined to people improving their own lots of land, that 1) we’d never have any conception of “the initiation of physical force” or 2) if we did, we’d account it a good thing? How can I break through to a man who is willing to surrender his reason, so that he may have the emotional satisfaction of believing that “he was right all along,” no matter what he may have sacrificed for it?

Men must ultimately hold themselves to high standards of intellectual honesty, if discussion/debate is to do them any good.

Men must ultimately hold themselves to high standards of intellectual honesty, if discussion/debate is to do them any good.

Exactly right. We can not make it our purpose here to change minds. Our purpose can only be to present our case in the best philosophical form that we can. Being persistently challenged forces us to keep modifying the position or our rhetoric until it is the best we can do.

My formula for good philosophy is to compose sentences which are:

1 true

2 important

3 universal

4 clear

5 brief

I have learned a great deal in this forum about how better to state the anti_IP position. I have not learned of any new or better pro-IP arguments. I never expect to “win” debates - that would require an impartial jury and there is no such thing where ethical questions are involved.

My formula for good philosophy is to compose sentences which are:

1 true

2 important

3 universal

4 clear

5 brief

I don’t know whether this will meet your formula, but in the spirit of the OP, I’d like to propose a thought experiment:

Suppose a society comprised of people who are completely isolated from one another, except that they may see and hear what the others are doing. (Perhaps this is something like a futuristic reality show a la Big Brother, or something similar.)

And so, there is no “physical” interaction between any individual and others, save for whatever is required to gather and transmit the video/audio feed.

This society could be as big or as small as we’d like it to be. For simplicity’s sake, let’s suppose two people, who may monitor one another and who are, themselves, monitored.

While one member of this society could not, for instance, steal someone else’s piano, or his crops, what would still be possible would be: imitation. Or copying. Or learning. Or however you’d like to conceive of it.

If Person One invented the piano – or a new type or design of piano, such that ordinarily we would find it “patentable,” and thus a new piece of Intellectual Property – and Person Two saw this, and considered it to be in his best interest to build likewise in his own realm, well…

Would that be the initiation of physical force?

Is Person One harmed? Should he be angry? Should he wish that he had some means of stopping Person Two from acting in this manner, or punishing him for doing so?

Is this an example of destruction? Or production? And if “destruction,” what exactly has been destroyed?

This thread has gotten convoluted with warped, minuscule side issues and made up detail scenarios that do not speak to the spirit or reasons for the identification of intellectual property – that is, context has been thrown away. Defenders of IP have been painted as irrational and emotional, even immoral, while detractors of IP supposedly see the truth, and isn’t it so sad that men’s minds can’t be changed, no matter how hard we try? It’s not hard to see why people would decide to just stop engaging. But, IP is an important issue. So…

There is really no point in arguing further if those opposed to IP agree with the following, since the fundamental beliefs of the two sides would be as opposed as a communist to a capitalist:

“The men who originate ideas and realize them in physical products do not deserve to decide how they are to be introduced and sold to other men, ie. the rest of society. Any man who can grasp any idea deserves to use it however he wants, even if he did not think it up himself, and even if he could not have thought of it himself.”

To me, and not coincidentally, also to Rand, THIS is the immoral position. It is immoral to take the mental effort of another man and give him nothing in return. It is immoral (and parasitic) to receive the benefits of a rational, thinking society while rejecting what makes it all possible to begin with: mutual benefit through *mutual* trade – and especially immoral to do this on *principle*!

Personally, (at the risk of sounding like hyperbole) it makes me sick that someone would want to do this, and even have the nerve to parade around saying so. “Thanks for thinking of all these great new ideas. Ok, see ya! Sucker!”

IP, like all laws and like society in general, isn’t simple or automatic. It’s difficult to formalize a way of recognizing who deserves what in the realm of mental effort. But, the alternative is to treat original thinkers like they are worth nothing. “It’s the idea that’s worth something, the guy who thought it up just happened to think it up! Oh well for him.” Really… Well, those guys think differently, one way or another. They’re either going to go after your dishonest self legally, or they’re going to stop thinking up ideas to bring to market – because no one wants to work for free, especially if the benefactor is an ingrate, on principle(!).

Fraud is generally thought of, by both Objectivists and Libertarians, as an initiation of the use of force. The reason is clear: Examples of fraud will always reduce to a case of someone being forcefully deprived of their rightful property (usually their money).

 

  1. An example would be: homeowner contracts with roofer. Roofer does the work. Homeowner doesn’t pay. Where is the force? The amount of force is small, but it is enough to keep roofer’s money in homeowner’s pocket so retaliatory force is justified to remove roofer’s money from homeowner’s pocket. It is Roofer’s money because Roofer complied with the contract by doing the work.

 

  1. Prize committee awards money to Deep Thinker for his anti-IP writing. Shallow thinker claims to be Deep Thinker and collects the money. The fraud is identity fraud. The money is the property of the committee or of the person they choose to award it to. The amount of force is small, but it is enough to keep the Committee’s money in Shallow Thinker’s pocket, so retaliatory force is justified to remove it from his pocket since he has no title (no claim) to it.

 

Everyone is convinced by Deep Thinker and all IP law is eliminated.

 

  1. Deep Thinker then writes a book and on the title page says: I am authorizing only InkblotPrinting to publish my book, so if you care about me, you will only buy copies from them. Signed, Deep Thinker.

 

The firm of SmudgePrint copies the book and puts the same message on the title page, merely changing it to read SmudgePrint instead of InkblotPrinting. They are stopped by force for identity fraud. The jury points out that it is fraud to publish a statement by Deep Thinker that Deep Thinker did not make, since consumers are tricked into buying an unauthorized book when they had only agreed to buy an authorized book. The money remains the consumer’s property until he receives an authorized copy.

 

SmudgePrint tries again by shipping copies claiming to be printed by InkblotPrinting. Again they are stopped by force for identity fraud.

 

DiscountBooks copies the book and sells at a reduced price, but their copy has no authorizing statement by Deep Thinker. Most people won’t buy it since they prefer to see the author rewarded for his work and so they usually don’t buy books without an authorizing statement. Most booksellers won’t retail such books.

 

SlumBooks changes a few words and copies the book and credits it to a Shallow Thinker. Some copies are sold, but it is known that Deep Thinker’s book hit the market first, and most people arrive at the opinion that both SlumBooks and Shallow Thinker are disreputable plagiarists. They become known for their ShallowSales.

 

Objectivists and various other mercantilists complain that all the guns they bought to enforce IP law are rusting and they demand compensation. They are ignored. Thousands of IP lawyers go hungry.

 

“The men who originate ideas and realize them in physical products do not deserve to decide how they are to be introduced and sold to other men, ie. the rest of society. Any man who can grasp any idea deserves to use it however he wants, even if he did not think it up himself, and even if he could not have thought of it himself.”

 

I could sign on to the above if it did not include a subtle shift away from my position.  If you originate an idea, you most certainly do deserve to decide how it is introduced to others.  But this entire thread has to do with what you deserve AFTER you have introduced your idea to others.  The anti-IP position is that no one owes you anything unless they contracted for it in advance.  So If you want to rewrite that statement, I’ll be happy to sign it. 

Objectivists and various other mercantilists complain that all the guns they bought to enforce IP law are rusting and they demand compensation. They are ignored. Thousands of IP lawyers go hungry.

 

Please stop with the hyperbole, or at least psychologizing to presume there is some ulterior motive to pro-IP. Clearly if IP is invalid, then it is initiation of force. The thread is about what’s in the OP, so  try to stick to that. Same with other posts. The little story you wrote to illustrate a point? That’s basically what the OP is about. That’s what the thread is discussing, so it’s insufficient for a reply.

Please stop with the hyperbole, or at least psychologizing to presume there is some ulterior motive to pro-IP. Clearly if IP is invalid, then it is initiation of force. The thread is about what’s in the OP, so  try to stick to that. Same with other posts. The little story you wrote to illustrate a point? That’s basically what the OP is about. That’s what the thread is discussing, so it’s insufficient for a reply.

Let’s see.  My little story is basically what the OP is about, so I should try to stick to what the OP is about?  Got it.  I’ll continue to do my best.

 

P.S. The quote of my post included no hyperbole or psychologizing about motives that I can see, but then I’m not an Objective moderator, am I?

So would you say that one should be, and should have been, when it was published, allowed to copy “Atlas Shrugged” and sell it at a discount? Do you think it would have been right, after 14 years of hard work, for Ayn Rand to have been made destitute because someone else was allowed to steal the fruits of her labor? Who would have been sacrificed for what in this instance?

I would put the person who answered yes to the first two questions in the same category of animal as the man who would steal the money from my bank account via the internet. They would be an evil looting mooching dog, not worthy of rational discussion.

Of course to be consistent you would have to answer yes, just as howardofski has.

Hi Marc.

I’m going to try to answer your question. I’ll ask for your patience upfront, because I’d like to answer it as fully as I can (and you’ll have noticed that I can be quite “full” in my answers). I also want to stipulate that my primary interest is not in being “consistent,” even with my earlier statements. If there are inconsistencies between how I answer you here, and my position overall, so be it – that’ll point out where I need to do some more thinking. But anyways, I don’t care about maintaining “consistency” for its own sake, or for “winning” some conversation – I only care about getting to the truth, regardless of where I’ve started, or how much crow I might have to eat afterwards.

 

So would you say that one should be, and should have been, when it was published, allowed to copy “Atlas Shrugged” and sell it at a discount?

In another thread on this same subject, I conceded that I find the case of a novel (or similar artwork) to be the strongest case for IP. There is something very emotionally compelling (at minimum) about the idea, though I want to be careful about how much my emotions influence my thinking on the matter.

Now… the post that you’re responding to (though not the portion you’ve chosen to quote) introduces an example of one farmer copying another, for the purpose of improving his own land. I posit there that this is not an example of destruction and not an example of the initiation of the use of physical force. So whether or not I wind up agreeing with you, that there’s something about copying and selling a freshly published novel that requires some sort of protection – and even if I ultimately concede that this is “Intellectual Property” – I still would not believe that my own example qualifies as the same sort of thing. And so I would still find the Objectivist theory of IP wrong, or at least as I understand it, because I believe that it would group together the just use of force (in protecting Atlas Shrugged) and the unjust use of force (in prohibiting the farmer from learning from his observation, and improving his own lot without causing anyone else harm).

Even if there’s *something* correct about IP, I’m afraid that I will want a theory of IP that discriminates properly between those things that are actually the initiation of the use of force, and those that are not. I do not believe that Rand’s theory in Patents and Copyrights achieves that, again, even if there’s “something correct about IP.” And furthermore I will want an objective implementation of that theory, if I am to agree with any proposed IP law, and I don’t yet see any basis for an objective implementation (though that is, perhaps, an altogether separate conversation).

Are we agreed on all of this so far? Or do you believe that my farmer is also a parasitical villain, in improving his own lot? (Because I’d love to see my own examples addressed from time to time, as I answer everyone else’s in their turn.)

Now let me step a foot closer to answering your question. :slight_smile:

I want to be clear, especially as it pertains to novels, that my opinions on IP do not have to do with voluntary licensing agreements or contracts that may serve many of the same practical purposes. I know of at least one other member here (and I want to say FeatherFall, though I could be mistaken) who has said that a “copyright” in the sense of an agreement that you enter into, when you purchase a book, not to make any copies of it, is legitimate.

I agree with that. It’s not copyright in the sense of IP that I’ve been discussing, but yes, a condition of the sale of a copy of Atlas Shrugged could very well be that no copies may be made. I’d be perfectly happy with that.

(I should note, to help draw the distinction between this – “copyright” as a common group of contractual agreements, versus copyright as IP – that I could make such a stipulation to any buyer of any of the books I have on my own bookshelf as a condition of sale, not to make any copies of them. It’s not a special right accounted to an innovator, but just a normal aspect of voluntary trade.)

Beyond such a “copyright,” let’s briefly imagine what a marketplace for novels might be like in a world without IP (cue dramatic music). If it were the case that authors knew, prior to publication, that upon publication their work would (in a sense) be to the winds, well… wouldn’t that change the terms upon which authors would be willing to publish their work in the first place? I mean, I honestly don’t know. I don’t know how the economics would work out, or how the market would shift/adjust/change. Just as when I discuss matters like “ending social security,” and someone asks me whether this would mean that seniors would start dying by the score, what I really believe is that the market would adjust in the end, so that we would still find ways of achieving what we find of value, but I don’t know that I can describe the specifics of it.

I think you and I would agree that Atlas Shrugged would be a tremendous value in any society. I think that there would be a ton of money to be made on it. I think that since Rand would control Atlas Shrugged’s entry into the marketplace, and since she would perhaps need to make that the point at which she receives her just recompense, that she would command something quite a bit greater than what we’d normally expect at present.

Further, in an earlier post in this thread, I’d briefly mentioned my own attitude when it comes to YouTube videos:

 

When I have a choice between watching some original YouTube content on the channel of the person who has created that content versus someone else who has simply uploaded a duplicate of the very same footage, I watch on the original channel.

Now… when I imagine myself presented with the possibility of buying two copies of Atlas Shrugged – one that is published by Ayn Rand (or the equivalent thereof; the one whereby she stands to profit, personally) and one that is not, though at a discount…? I buy Rand’s copy every time. Because I want to personally reward her, insofar as I was able.

I imagine that many other people would act likewise, and especially those drawn to purchase Atlas Shrugged in the first place.

Here’s the answer you’ve been waiting for.

So, with all that said (and all of which I consider important context to fully understand my answer), the answer to your question is: yes.

Assuming that Rand has not required some sort of licensing/“copyright” agreement of those who’ve purchased her novel, and assuming that these are the terms of the marketplace so that Rand has had the opportunity to deal on those terms (and with the features of that marketplace that have arisen to better reward the value she provides, which I cannot specify, but which I believe would arise in some fashion), and despite my questioning whether there would be a market for such a thing (and knowing that I would not be a part of that market), I do believe that a person should be able to make a copy of a book and sell it, at a discount, or even give it away.

 

Do you think it would have been right, after 14 years of hard work, for Ayn Rand to have been made destitute because someone else was allowed to steal the fruits of her labor? Who would have been sacrificed for what in this instance?

With my (full) answer considered, I hope you’ll understand that I don’t consider making such a copy “theft” or a “sacrifice.” If Rand knew the conditions going in, after all, I doubt that she’d allow herself to be “sacrificed” in any manner at all. And if she wished to prevent such “theft,” I expect that she would insist on “copyright” protections to that effect. (If, however, we are discussing the situation of those authors who were reliant upon IP protection getting caught up in a legal change… well… that’s a far thornier issue. But I also find it thorny, discussing what would happen to those seniors who were raised to depend on social security, while the market adjusts. I don’t know if I have good answers to those sorts of questions.)

Let me also say that I think that there’s sometimes a difference between what I consider “right” and what is (or ought to be) legal. For instance, I could propose a scenario where a man isn’t allowed to dine in a restaurant due to racial discrimination. That isn’t right. It’s not just. But it ought to be legal.

And I’m not saying that these are equivalent examples at all. I’m only trying to draw a distinction between these important concepts, to clarify my thoughts on the situation. If I were a publisher, and if I thought I had the opportunity to publish Atlas Shrugged at a discount, siphoning sales away from Ayn Rand, but I judged that to be an immoral action, I would not do it.

If we’re talking about “what did Ayn Rand deserve,” I’ll tell you that I think she deserved all of the fame and wealth that she got, and far more besides. She deserved more people who understood her. She deserved better friends (and, perhaps, better enemies). She deserved to see her ideas change the world, far more than they did. She deserved a legacy wherein she is respected as perhaps the greatest philosopher the world has seen. I’m glad that Rand lived comfortably, but if I’m speaking honestly, I don’t know that she received nearly what she deserved, or what was right, or her due, or what her incredible body of work ought to have purchased.

In arguing for what I believe is right, according to my best use of reason, I hope that I continue to “give Ayn Rand what she deserves,” even though I recognize that I disagree with her specific conclusion(s) on this issue.

 

I would put the person who answered yes to the first two questions in the same category of animal as the man who would steal the money from my bank account via the internet. They would be an evil looting mooching dog, not worthy of rational discussion.

Of course to be consistent you would have to answer yes, just as howardofski has.

In previewing this for publication, I’ve taken note that another moderator has hidden your original post. I suspect that has to do with the reference to my possibly being “an evil looting mooching dog, not worthy of rational discussion.”

I respect that decision – this thread is in dire need of greater civility – but I’m going to preserve the quote of that post for this reply, for context. I don’t know whether you’ll continue to find me worthy of rational discussion, but I’ll continue to try to be an honest and rational man, and to speak honestly, the consequences (and anyone else’s opinion of me) be damned.