So would you say that one should be, and should have been, when it was published, allowed to copy “Atlas Shrugged” and sell it at a discount? Do you think it would have been right, after 14 years of hard work, for Ayn Rand to have been made destitute because someone else was allowed to steal the fruits of her labor? Who would have been sacrificed for what in this instance?
I would put the person who answered yes to the first two questions in the same category of animal as the man who would steal the money from my bank account via the internet. They would be an evil looting mooching dog, not worthy of rational discussion.
Of course to be consistent you would have to answer yes, just as howardofski has.
Hi Marc.
I’m going to try to answer your question. I’ll ask for your patience upfront, because I’d like to answer it as fully as I can (and you’ll have noticed that I can be quite “full” in my answers). I also want to stipulate that my primary interest is not in being “consistent,” even with my earlier statements. If there are inconsistencies between how I answer you here, and my position overall, so be it – that’ll point out where I need to do some more thinking. But anyways, I don’t care about maintaining “consistency” for its own sake, or for “winning” some conversation – I only care about getting to the truth, regardless of where I’ve started, or how much crow I might have to eat afterwards.
So would you say that one should be, and should have been, when it was published, allowed to copy “Atlas Shrugged” and sell it at a discount?
In another thread on this same subject, I conceded that I find the case of a novel (or similar artwork) to be the strongest case for IP. There is something very emotionally compelling (at minimum) about the idea, though I want to be careful about how much my emotions influence my thinking on the matter.
Now… the post that you’re responding to (though not the portion you’ve chosen to quote) introduces an example of one farmer copying another, for the purpose of improving his own land. I posit there that this is not an example of destruction and not an example of the initiation of the use of physical force. So whether or not I wind up agreeing with you, that there’s something about copying and selling a freshly published novel that requires some sort of protection – and even if I ultimately concede that this is “Intellectual Property” – I still would not believe that my own example qualifies as the same sort of thing. And so I would still find the Objectivist theory of IP wrong, or at least as I understand it, because I believe that it would group together the just use of force (in protecting Atlas Shrugged) and the unjust use of force (in prohibiting the farmer from learning from his observation, and improving his own lot without causing anyone else harm).
Even if there’s *something* correct about IP, I’m afraid that I will want a theory of IP that discriminates properly between those things that are actually the initiation of the use of force, and those that are not. I do not believe that Rand’s theory in Patents and Copyrights achieves that, again, even if there’s “something correct about IP.” And furthermore I will want an objective implementation of that theory, if I am to agree with any proposed IP law, and I don’t yet see any basis for an objective implementation (though that is, perhaps, an altogether separate conversation).
Are we agreed on all of this so far? Or do you believe that my farmer is also a parasitical villain, in improving his own lot? (Because I’d love to see my own examples addressed from time to time, as I answer everyone else’s in their turn.)
Now let me step a foot closer to answering your question. 
I want to be clear, especially as it pertains to novels, that my opinions on IP do not have to do with voluntary licensing agreements or contracts that may serve many of the same practical purposes. I know of at least one other member here (and I want to say FeatherFall, though I could be mistaken) who has said that a “copyright” in the sense of an agreement that you enter into, when you purchase a book, not to make any copies of it, is legitimate.
I agree with that. It’s not copyright in the sense of IP that I’ve been discussing, but yes, a condition of the sale of a copy of Atlas Shrugged could very well be that no copies may be made. I’d be perfectly happy with that.
(I should note, to help draw the distinction between this – “copyright” as a common group of contractual agreements, versus copyright as IP – that I could make such a stipulation to any buyer of any of the books I have on my own bookshelf as a condition of sale, not to make any copies of them. It’s not a special right accounted to an innovator, but just a normal aspect of voluntary trade.)
Beyond such a “copyright,” let’s briefly imagine what a marketplace for novels might be like in a world without IP (cue dramatic music). If it were the case that authors knew, prior to publication, that upon publication their work would (in a sense) be to the winds, well… wouldn’t that change the terms upon which authors would be willing to publish their work in the first place? I mean, I honestly don’t know. I don’t know how the economics would work out, or how the market would shift/adjust/change. Just as when I discuss matters like “ending social security,” and someone asks me whether this would mean that seniors would start dying by the score, what I really believe is that the market would adjust in the end, so that we would still find ways of achieving what we find of value, but I don’t know that I can describe the specifics of it.
I think you and I would agree that Atlas Shrugged would be a tremendous value in any society. I think that there would be a ton of money to be made on it. I think that since Rand would control Atlas Shrugged’s entry into the marketplace, and since she would perhaps need to make that the point at which she receives her just recompense, that she would command something quite a bit greater than what we’d normally expect at present.
Further, in an earlier post in this thread, I’d briefly mentioned my own attitude when it comes to YouTube videos:
When I have a choice between watching some original YouTube content on the channel of the person who has created that content versus someone else who has simply uploaded a duplicate of the very same footage, I watch on the original channel.
Now… when I imagine myself presented with the possibility of buying two copies of Atlas Shrugged – one that is published by Ayn Rand (or the equivalent thereof; the one whereby she stands to profit, personally) and one that is not, though at a discount…? I buy Rand’s copy every time. Because I want to personally reward her, insofar as I was able.
I imagine that many other people would act likewise, and especially those drawn to purchase Atlas Shrugged in the first place.
Here’s the answer you’ve been waiting for.
So, with all that said (and all of which I consider important context to fully understand my answer), the answer to your question is: yes.
Assuming that Rand has not required some sort of licensing/“copyright” agreement of those who’ve purchased her novel, and assuming that these are the terms of the marketplace so that Rand has had the opportunity to deal on those terms (and with the features of that marketplace that have arisen to better reward the value she provides, which I cannot specify, but which I believe would arise in some fashion), and despite my questioning whether there would be a market for such a thing (and knowing that I would not be a part of that market), I do believe that a person should be able to make a copy of a book and sell it, at a discount, or even give it away.
Do you think it would have been right, after 14 years of hard work, for Ayn Rand to have been made destitute because someone else was allowed to steal the fruits of her labor? Who would have been sacrificed for what in this instance?
With my (full) answer considered, I hope you’ll understand that I don’t consider making such a copy “theft” or a “sacrifice.” If Rand knew the conditions going in, after all, I doubt that she’d allow herself to be “sacrificed” in any manner at all. And if she wished to prevent such “theft,” I expect that she would insist on “copyright” protections to that effect. (If, however, we are discussing the situation of those authors who were reliant upon IP protection getting caught up in a legal change… well… that’s a far thornier issue. But I also find it thorny, discussing what would happen to those seniors who were raised to depend on social security, while the market adjusts. I don’t know if I have good answers to those sorts of questions.)
Let me also say that I think that there’s sometimes a difference between what I consider “right” and what is (or ought to be) legal. For instance, I could propose a scenario where a man isn’t allowed to dine in a restaurant due to racial discrimination. That isn’t right. It’s not just. But it ought to be legal.
And I’m not saying that these are equivalent examples at all. I’m only trying to draw a distinction between these important concepts, to clarify my thoughts on the situation. If I were a publisher, and if I thought I had the opportunity to publish Atlas Shrugged at a discount, siphoning sales away from Ayn Rand, but I judged that to be an immoral action, I would not do it.
If we’re talking about “what did Ayn Rand deserve,” I’ll tell you that I think she deserved all of the fame and wealth that she got, and far more besides. She deserved more people who understood her. She deserved better friends (and, perhaps, better enemies). She deserved to see her ideas change the world, far more than they did. She deserved a legacy wherein she is respected as perhaps the greatest philosopher the world has seen. I’m glad that Rand lived comfortably, but if I’m speaking honestly, I don’t know that she received nearly what she deserved, or what was right, or her due, or what her incredible body of work ought to have purchased.
In arguing for what I believe is right, according to my best use of reason, I hope that I continue to “give Ayn Rand what she deserves,” even though I recognize that I disagree with her specific conclusion(s) on this issue.
I would put the person who answered yes to the first two questions in the same category of animal as the man who would steal the money from my bank account via the internet. They would be an evil looting mooching dog, not worthy of rational discussion.
Of course to be consistent you would have to answer yes, just as howardofski has.
In previewing this for publication, I’ve taken note that another moderator has hidden your original post. I suspect that has to do with the reference to my possibly being “an evil looting mooching dog, not worthy of rational discussion.”
I respect that decision – this thread is in dire need of greater civility – but I’m going to preserve the quote of that post for this reply, for context. I don’t know whether you’ll continue to find me worthy of rational discussion, but I’ll continue to try to be an honest and rational man, and to speak honestly, the consequences (and anyone else’s opinion of me) be damned.