But Jaskn, if you did not believe in your OWN right to act on other people’s ideas then you never would have posted that.
Despite my better judgment, I’m going to jump back into this post.
My first contribution had to do with copyrights - something which I deal with on a day to day basis, and am reasonably familiar with and, in fact, profit from. (And other than copyrights, I only touched briefly on Trademarks). In my ever to be humble opinion, a large problem with this post is that people tend to just discuss “IP” without specifying whether the IP in question is Patents, Trademarks, Copyrights, Trade Dress etc. The “hypotheticals” are exactly that - way too hypothetical - and of no real value to the discussion.
Despite the misgivings that many of us share about the intrusive nature of the State in our day-to-day lives, this does not mean that every law that is on the books is bad. IP laws developed for a reason, and it behooves us to understand their role before we just categorically branding them as “evil” and cast them aside.
The following is from Rand’s Lexicon, and the underlines are mine:
An idea as such cannot be protected until it has been given a material form. An invention has to be embodied in a physical model before it can be patented; a story has to be written or printed. But what the patent or copyright protects is not the physical object as such, but the idea which it embodies. By forbidding an unauthorized reproduction of the object, the law declares, in effect, that the physical labor of copying is not the source of the object’s value, that that value is created by the originator of the idea and may not be used without his consent; thus the law establishes the property right of a mind to that which it has brought into existence.
How this translates to every day life is that if someone were to steal the unpublished manuscript of Atlas Shrugged, and sell it to a publisher, it is accepted by everyone on this forum that Rand would have the right to restitution for the theft, but WITOUT COPYRIGHT LAWS the only monetary compensation she could recoup would be the market value of the paper. Without copyright laws, the value of the story has no protection. The same is true for Architecture. Drawings and Specifications can cost hundreds of thousands of dollars to produce, but copies only $100 dollars.
Taken to it’s illogical extreme, imagine if someone were to go into a museum and deface a historical painting. Sure, you could demand restitution for the destruction of property, but being true to the anti-IP mentality, the only thing the criminal would have to compensate the museum for is the cost of the frame, canvas and paint.
We live in a complex society, and ideas of ownership, value and property cannot just easily be reduced to material costs. In fact, the value of materials is itself an issue equally as complex as IP. We are not concrete-bound animals. Value is conceptual, and should be treated as such.
But Jaskn, if you did not believe in your OWN right to act on other people’s ideas then you never would have posted that.
I was speaking as broadly as possible, because that’s what howardofski is attacking – the broadest idea that people don’t deserve the product of their mental effort. There’s no point in going to the next step and talking about how to apply this in society if you don’t agree on that first, most basic idea.
Of course, existing patent law already deals with those particulars. It acknowledges that a single person doesn’t think of all uses, implications, applications for a given idea by requiring those things to be specified in the patent. It acknowledges that the protection against economic loss should be linked and limited to the individual’s life who thought up the idea by limiting the time the patent is valid. In essence, patent law is a system that works fairly well at allowing individuals to more precisely use their ideas to support their existence.
Maybe the system could be improved, and we could debate that. But at this point in this thread, people are undermining entirely the notion of having a system like this at all. They are saying that ideas should be considered valuable, but the value is “in the valuer,” not the creator. They acknowledge the way in which men learn while denying the way in which they create.
… that’s what howardofski is attacking – the broadest idea that people don’t deserve the product of their mental effort.
This is false and another misinterpretation. I believe exactly the opposite.
New Buddha,
[Anti-IP debaters] are saying that ideas should be considered valuable, but the value is “in the valuer,” not the creator.
Value, like beauty, is in the eye of the beholder. You can value an idea as you choose. Others will value it as they choose. Passing value judgments is the responsibility of every mind.
Taken to it’s illogical extreme, imagine if someone were to go into a museum and deface a historical painting. Sure, you could demand restitution for the destruction of property, but being true to the anti-IP mentality, the only thing the criminal would have to compensate the museum for is the cost of the frame, canvas and paint.
The cost of the frame, canvas and paint might be millions of dollars if it was a Vermeer. If you are suggesting that the anti-IP position is that the value of the art is irrelevant, then you are failing to understand the position.
The anti-IP debaters , at least in this discussion have relied on physicality as a determining factor. Ownership can not be applied to design and the recognition that design is incorporated into the implementation of physical objects, the ownership can only apply to the the physical objects themselves. IP infringement is not theft because the owner will still own the idea, ie still have the idea ‘in his head’ whether or not others have it in theirs simultaneously and when they implement the content of the idea to make a product or service and trade that thing , no loss of ownership has occured to the creator of the idea , because he still has the idea. The position rests on the idea of physicality.
howardofski in #276 gave
- An example would be: homeowner contracts with roofer. Roofer does the work. Homeowner doesn’t pay. Where is the force? The amount of force is small, but it is enough to keep roofer’s money in homeowner’s pocket so retaliatory force is justified to remove roofer’s money from homeowner’s pocket. It is Roofer’s money because Roofer complied with the contract by doing the work.
Basing infringement of rights involved in trade on physicality and possession of physical objects alone, unless the contract stipulates specific bills(identifable by serial number? or a specific item ‘the gold bar known as..’) what does the roofer not have that the homeowner did have ?
The anti-IP debaters , at least in this discussion have relied on physicality as a determining factor. Ownership can not be applied to design and the recognition that design is incorporated into the implementation of physical objects, the ownership can only apply to the the physical objects themselves. IP infringement is not theft because the owner will still own the idea, ie still have the idea ‘in his head’ whether or not others have it in theirs simultaneously and when they implement the content of the idea to make a product or service and trade that thing , no loss of ownership has occured to the creator of the idea , because he still has the idea. The position rests on the idea of physicality.
howardofski in #276 gave
- An example would be: homeowner contracts with roofer. Roofer does the work. Homeowner doesn’t pay. Where is the force? The amount of force is small, but it is enough to keep roofer’s money in homeowner’s pocket so retaliatory force is justified to remove roofer’s money from homeowner’s pocket. It is Roofer’s money because Roofer complied with the contract by doing the work.
Basing infringement of rights involved in trade on physicality and possession of physical objects alone, unless the contract stipulates specific bills(identifable by serial number? or a specific item ‘the gold bar known as..’) what does the roofer not have that the homeowner did have ?
Your first paragraph above is correct, so long as it is understood that design may very well be why an object is valued - no one is saying that design is irrelevant or without value, merely that it cannot be owned in the abstract. Only the physical objects that incorporate the design are ownable.
Your third paragraph seems to take my point too literally. I did not mean that some specific coins or bills were Roofer’s property. I merely meant Roofer, by doing the work, became the rightful owner of some amount of money (which he is being deprived of by Homeowner), but money is fungible, and I wasn’t intending to say otherwise.
Taken to it’s illogical extreme, imagine if someone were to go into a museum and deface a historical painting. Sure, you could demand restitution for the destruction of property, but being true to the anti-IP mentality, the only thing the criminal would have to compensate the museum for is the cost of the frame, canvas and paint.
Not to nitpick, but a painting (or a single CD or one copy of a novel) falls under conventional property perfectly well; there’s no reason to make it an exclusive matter of materials.
So a painting could be valued as more than its constituent parts, just as a house or a car does.
The hypothetical about the Atlas Shrugged manuscript is accurate. Although it should be treated as more than the ink and paper alone, it cannot be valued as every potential novel it could ever produce (which is the essence of IP).
I actually agree that value is a conceptual matter and should be treated accordingly. To legally treat it as intrinsic would produce something far worse than what I’m arguing against.
My only contention is whether concepts themselves (however valuable they are) can be owned, unless they are “owned” by every mind which holds them.
Jaskn:
To “own” an idea is to own every action of every human being, which depends on it; that nobody has the right to USE your idea without your permission.
If this is proper for ideas then it must be proper for ideas; all ideas.
You (and I include many others in this) have said that whoever invents some new object or technique has the right to dispose of it, BECAUSE they were the ones whose effort created it.
But this reasoning holds equally true for every other sort of idea in existence.
If so then who owns the concept of IP and whom does this discussion rob?
If you agree that you have the right, not only to think, but to ACT on your thoughts, then we already agree.
If not then you contradict yourself by saying so.
That is what I mean, when I say that you cannot advocate IP without self-contradiction.
what does the roofer not have that the homeowner did have ?
The money which became rightfully his when he performed the contractually stipulated actions.
Physical property is all which can be owned; even Rand stated this in her reasoning for IP.
The problem is not that ideas are not physical; neither are contracts. If this was your point then it is correct.
The problem is in denying a causal connection between one person’s mind and their actions (which IP does by asserting the causal relationship between an innovator and every single product they enable).
If you are not responsible for your own ideas, even those ideas which were formed by reading Ayn Rand, then you are responsible for nothing whatsoever.
That is what makes this issue so important. Ownership, consent, guilt and innocence; all of it rises or falls on “responsibility”.
And if you are not responsible for your own mind then you cannot be responsible for your own thoughts, words or actions; you cannot own anything at all or give any consent.
“Man is a being of self-made soul” or else he is a slave, point-blank.
“…to own every action…” Every action? Or just the specific actions which would lead to the specific duplicating of the specific manifestation of the specific idea for the specific person? IP laws today already function like this.
Nobody owns the concept “IP,” but they may own a scholarly work which explains the reasoning behind IP. Your question assumes more about IP reasoning and laws than anyone argues. IP has the element of actual implementation and application. It is simply a more refined step up from the reasoning behind all property, in the specific context of a society. It recognizes that the value of trade is derived from the thinking work of men, and that it is possible for men who did not do the thinking to suck dry the marketable value from the man who did do the thinking. Laws prevent men from “using the property” of his own body from taking your lawn mower from your yard. Why is this kind of law OK? The men are not permitted to use their property in the way they want to – taking the lawn mower home!
Nobody owns the concept “IP,” but they may own a scholarly work which explains the reasoning behind IP. Your question assumes more about IP reasoning and laws than anyone argues.
It is true that nobody has ever said what I am arguing against.
I also have a Communist friend who can’t stand being told that he hates the human mind (starting with his own). He’s never said anything of the sort- only that thinking and wanting are evil.
Now, for your lawnmower analogy, that’s all fine and dandy. It’s my mind but if other people’s thoughts enter it, they aren’t mine. So if I see someone building some novel type of piano then I have no right to use that idea; it belongs to them.
Let’s run with that. How did you learn to speak English?
Because if you’re serious then you should convey your thoughts with concepts that you did not ‘parasitically’ steal from your parents.
I know you have a better mind than that, so I will respond to anything PRINCIPLED you have to say.
This means either considering my point or rejecting it in your own language.
Live long and prosper.
howardofski in #276 gave
An example would be: homeowner contracts with roofer. Roofer does the work. Homeowner doesn’t pay. Where is the force? The amount of force is small, but it is enough to keep roofer’s money in homeowner’s pocket so retaliatory force is justified to remove roofer’s money from homeowner’s pocket. It is Roofer’s money because Roofer complied with the contract by doing the work.
As an aside:
Under our current laws, the Roofer would be allowed to file a Mechanic’s Lien against the property and would actually acquire a security interest in the physical property. It would be legally recorded to the tile and not removed until payment was made. If the property were sold, the lien would accompany it. Been there, done that…
That was a bizarre post.
I guess my reply is, again:
IP is for specific, original ideas and applications. It’s ironic to use human observation and learning as the argument against IP, when that is the very reason IP is necessary. Humans can learn something easily once it is observed in action. If that wasn’t possible, there would be no reason to have IP laws protecting the original idea of the original thinker.
That was a bizarre post.
I guess my reply is, again:
IP is for specific, original ideas and applications. It’s ironic to use human observation and learning as the argument against IP, when that is the very reason IP is necessary. Humans can learn something easily once it is observed in action. If that wasn’t possible, there would be no reason to have IP laws protecting the original idea of the original thinker.
It is bizarre to claim that thinkers need or deserve protection from people who might learn by observation.
It is bizarre to claim that thinkers need or deserve protection from people who might learn by observation.
Says you.
I know you also say that the originator of an idea doesn’t lose marketable value when someone else takes and markets his idea instead.
Anything can be said, really.
Let’s run with that. How did you learn to speak English?
Because if you’re serious then you should convey your thoughts with concepts that you did not ‘parasitically’ steal from your parents.
This is literally irrelevant - you’re fighting windmills. IP isn’t about learning concepts, it’s about using specific kinds of concepts in specific way with a physical implementation like blueprints. It’s not ANY idea whatever. If there is an implication that IP wants to put all concepts under ownership, then point it out. I don’t see how that is possible if a valid IP position requires the physical implementation. Another thing to do is show a paradox.
If there is an implication that IP wants to put all concepts under ownership, then point it out. I don’t see how that is possible if a valid IP position requires the physical implementation.
I agree with Rand’s justification of regular property rights; the fact that they come from the actions of someone.
To say that Franz owns Wolfgang’s piano means that Franz built the piano, INSTEAD OF Wolfgang.
Why in Galt’s name doesn’t this apply to any other action Franz could be said to cause???
If Wolfgang goes through all of the motions of building Franz’s piano, without the proper materials, then what?