Because there is no way to measure freeness, you cannot use it as a rational[e]for war (by war I mean one nation invading another).
[This sentence – amended with square brackets – comes from the “American Intentions in Iraq” thread, post 57, by johngalt1972.]
Can freedom be measured or not?
A few days ago I began wondering about this problem when I saw a news report – citing Freedom House, I recall – about Russia becoming less free during the last year. The report ranked various nations. That raised the question, how do these people go about measuring freedom? Then I saw the clear negative statement above.
Here is my attempt to answer, in the affirmative:
A measurement, in Objectivism, is “the identification of a relationship – a quantitative relationship established by means of a standard that serves as a unit. Entities (and their actions) are measured by their attributes …” (Ayn Rand, ITOE, 2nd edition, p. 7, but see the index for many references to “Measurement.”)
(“Quantitative” can include ordinal as well as cardinal measurements.)
A society is an entity (for the purposes of study – see ITOE, p. 271). It has attributes. In the case of a society ruled by a state, one attribute is the freedom the state protects or limits.
Can that attribute be measured? If so, how?
I would suggest the approach should be a mixture. First is hierarchical and second is enumerative. One can first identify a hierarchy of rights, with three basic rights (life, liberty, and property) at the foundation, and other rights (such as a right to a fair and objective trial) being derivative from that base. Second is a count, such as: Two out of three basic rights violated? Seventeen derivative rights violated?
This approach is analogous to the process of measuring concepts of cognition. (See ITOE, p. 32.) There, one measures such concepts in two ways: “breadth,” that is, scope of referents, and “depth,” that is, hierarchical length of the conceptual chain required to reach that concept from its referents.
I am unsure of this approach. As always, consider this to be a target for rejection, correction, or elaboration.