1 hour ago, 2046 said:
A bold face quote does not an argument make. You have to understand the context this is coming from. Rand is having Galt refute her adversiaries in her trichotomy of value from intricisism and subjectivism. Specifically, the part of the quote after the “or” she is speaking to various medieval conceptions of virtue that are rather altruistic, and duty-based Kantian morals.
This however, rests upon two false assumptions. One is to regard virtue wholly, as Rand puts it, an “end in itself,” the other is to regard as unconnected to happiness. Both assumptions are false for the reasons Rand gives. But, accordingly, the alternative to regarding virtue as an instrumental means isn’t the above, but to partly regard virtue as a means to happiness and partly as an end in itself. It can be partly an end in itself in that it is, partly, constitutive of happiness, and therefore avoids being unconnected to happiness.
For reasons why we should regard virtue as a constitutive means rather than instrumental, I would just point to all the same arguments Aristotle gives in the Nicomachean Ethics. If beyond that and the arguments and reasons and examples I’ve already been giving, you just have to look at it inductively by analyzing the nature of virtue, means, ends, the various ends we have, and ultimate ends.
A helpful way to think about it is asking whether an end is logically separable from its means, or is the means external to the ends, or is part of the end just incorporated by the means.
Also there is the aspect of character development, incorporating long term principled behavior into emotional motivation as well as behavioral dispositions. Part of being virtuous isn’t just a “one and done” thing, once you’ve got happiness or eudaimonia then you’ve got it. It’s an ongoing continuous process, one that has to be developed and achieved and continuously maintained in ones character traits.
Rand talks about a principled commitment to living rationally, for example. It’s not just excercising a faculty here or there, a bunch of neurons fired and I made a deduction, it’s about cultivating a disposition towards using ones faculty and valuing it as a method on principle. The virtues are not only an abstract or intellectual commitment to “okay I need to use reason or be productive,” etc, but also emotional and motivational dispositions. Then once I act to achieve all of these concrete values, I can’t simple say “I’ve got it, I’m done with virtue” I have to keep maintain them, which will commit me to keeping and maintaining the same methods, long term, that brought me to the party, so to speak.
How is this any different from practicing to play Moonlight Sonata as I described above?