Is the Many-Worlds Interpretation of QM at odds with Objectivism? I’ve noticed some Objectivists have been advocating the Theory of Elementary Waves while I haven’t witnessed any Objectivist support for MW. If MW isn’t compatible w. Objectivism I’d like to know why that is. Thanks!
Many worlds? Where are the others? Until there is evidence that they exist, the claim is arbitrary.
mrocktor
Is the Many-Worlds Interpretation of QM at odds with Objectivism?
Would you give a brief explanation of this many-worlds interpretation of QM?
Would you give a brief explanation of this many-worlds interpretation of QM?
Sure – I can’t offer a better brief explanation than the one I found on Wikipedia so I’m going to be lazy and quote it:
The many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics or MWI, also known as the relative state formulation, theory of the universal wavefunction, many-universes interpretation or just many worlds is an interpretation of quantum mechanics that claims to resolve all the “paradoxes” of quantum theory by allowing every possible outcome to every event to define or exist in its own “history” or “world”, via the mechanism of quantum decoherence, instead of wavefunction collapse. Many worlds reconciles how we can perceive non-deterministic events (such as the random decay of a radioactive atom) with the deterministic equations of quantum physics; history, which prior to many worlds had been viewed as a single “world-line”, is rather a many-branched tree where every possible branch of history is realised.
The relative state formulation is due to Hugh Everett[1]in 1957, popularised and renamed many worlds by Bryce Seligman DeWitt in the 1960s and '70s[2][3][4][5]. The decoherent approach to interpreting quantum theory has been further explored and developed[6][7][8] becoming quite popular, taken as a class overall. MWI is one of many multiverse hypotheses in physics and philosophy. It is currently considered a mainstream interpretation along with the other decoherent interpretations and the Copenhagen interpretation.
Advantages
MWI removes the observer-dependent role in the quantum measurement process by replacing wavefunction collapse with quantum decoherence. Since the role of the observer lies at the heart of most, if not all, “quantum paradoxes” this automatically resolves a number of problems; see for example Schrödinger’s cat thought-experiment, the EPR paradox, von Neumann’s “boundary problem” and even wave-particle duality. Quantum cosmology also becomes intelligible, since there is no need anymore for an observer outside of the universe.
MWI allows quantum mechanics to become a realist, deterministic, local theory making it more akin to classical physics (including the theory of relativity).
MWI (or other, broader multiverse considerations) provides a context for the anthropic principle which may provide an explanation for the fine-tuned universe.
MWI, being a decoherent formulation, is axiomatically more streamlined than the Copenhagen and other collapse interpretations and thus favoured by Ockham’s razor. Of course there are other decoherent intepretations that also possess this advantage with respect to the collapse interpretations.
Interesting. I’m going to read up on this, but it does sound a bit problematic.
It’s possible to prove something false in a single “world”; could one prove something were false in many-worlds?
I suppose it does fill in the blank, but.. :worry:
As far as I know the Many-Worlds theories and other extremely off the wall interpretations of QM are not taken very seriously in the scientific world, because of a staggering lack of evidence.
“interpretation of quantum mechanics that claims to resolve all the “paradoxes” of quantum theory by allowing every possible outcome to every event to define or exist in its own “history” or “world””
???
If that isn’t primacy of consciousness, I don’t know what is. “The theory has paradoxes, and I need the theory to be right, therefore, we’ll create unverifiable realities to match the theory.”
Didn’t Schroedinger’s Cat already take care of this? Of course we know the Cat can’t both exist and not exist simultaneously.
As far as I know the Many-Worlds theories and other extremely off the wall interpretations of QM are not taken very seriously in the scientific world, because of a staggering lack of evidence.
Actually, it isn’t an off-the-wall theory according to many leading researchers (the less explanatory Copenhagen interpretation is more of an off-the-wall theory) and it’s relatively popular among physicists.
From Wikipedia:
For example, a poll of 72 leading physicists conducted by the American researcher David Raub in 1995 and published in the French periodical Sciences et Avenir in January 1998 recorded that nearly 60% thought many worlds interpretation was “true”. Max Tegmark (see reference to his web page below) also reports the result of a poll taken at a 1997 quantum mechanics workshop. According to Tegmark, “The many worlds interpretation (MWI) scored second, comfortably ahead of the consistent histories and Bohm interpretations.”
“interpretation of quantum mechanics that claims to resolve all the “paradoxes” of quantum theory by allowing every possible outcome to every event to define or exist in its own “history” or “world””
???
If that isn’t primacy of consciousness, I don’t know what is. “The theory has paradoxes, and I need the theory to be right, therefore, we’ll create unverifiable realities to match the theory.”
Didn’t Schroedinger’s Cat already take care of this? Of course we know the Cat can’t both exist and not exist simultaneously.
Schroedinger’s Cat refers to a paradox. It’s actually resolved by quantum decoherence theories like the MWI.
Also, I know of one researcher at least who’s proposed an experiment to test the MWI:
[David]Deutsch has also proposed that when reversible computers become conscious that MWI will be testable (at least against “naive” Copenhagenism) via the reversible observation of spin[17].
-Wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Many-worlds#A…e_and_Criticism
Didn’t Schroedinger’s Cat already take care of this? Of course we know the Cat can’t both exist and not exist simultaneously.
Everett Lamplighter is correct in that Schrodinger’s Cat is a paradox that arises from quantum mechanics, not a refutation of quantum mechanics. I believe physicists are still trying to resolve all aspects of the double slit experiment, which essentially led to particle-wave duality (which everyone seems to agree upon). The controversial aspect of the experiment is the Copenhagen Interpretation, which argues that, when unobserved, the photons are simultaneously passing through both parallel, disjoint slits. (!!?!) If one observes the photon, then its probability wave collapses and it can be determined which slit the photon traveled through.
Schroedinger’s Cat refers to a paradox. It’s actually resolved by quantum decoherence theories like the MWI.
I think “resolved” may be a strong term. When one creates new realities that are unverifiable to resolve a paradox, one wonders if the paradox doesn’t resolve the decoherence theories. My understanding was that Schrodinger’s Cat was supposed to be a reductio ad absurdum of Copenhagen QM. If we’re calling reductio ad absurdum “paradoxes” well, ok.
I’m not a big QM expert, but I liked the following quote from Wiki on the Cat experiment.from a letter from Einstein to Schrodinger (bold mine).
You are the only contemporary physicist, besides Laue, who sees that one cannot get around the assumption of reality - if only one is honest. Most of them simply do not see what sort of risky game they are playing with reality - reality as something independent of what is experimentally established . Their interpretation is, however, refuted most elegantly by your system of radioactive atom + amplifier + charge of gun powder + cat in a box, in which the psi-function of the system contains both the cat alive and blown to bits. Nobody really doubts that the presence or absence of the cat is something independent of the act of observation.
Obviously, some people still doubt it. ![]()
I pulled up my notes from David Harriman’s lecture, “The Philosophic Corruption of Physics”. His thesis was that Kant started screwing up physics very quickly, resulting in Mach (Kantian) vs. Boltzmann (Newtonian) - where Boltzmann won the atomic theory of matter debate, but Mach Kantian philosophy was accepted. Relativity is derived based upon Einsteinian rationalism, and QM is pure primacy of consciousness (reality is determined by “observation”). Not that the math doesn’t work out in some cases - such as relativity, but that the conclusions about reality, like MWI, are absurd.
Everett Lamplighter is correct in that Schrodinger’s Cat is a paradox that arises from quantum mechanics, not a refutation of quantum mechanics. I believe physicists are still trying to resolve all aspects of the double slit experiment, which essentially led to particle-wave duality (which everyone seems to agree upon). The controversial aspect of the experiment is the Copenhagen Interpretation, which argues that, when unobserved, the photons are simultaneously passing through both parallel, disjoint slits. (!!?!) If one observes the photon, then its probability wave collapses and it can be determined which slit the photon traveled through.
You’re absolutely right, DW.
The single-particle interferometer is a configuration of the double-slit experiment, in which only a single photon is emitted from the light source at a time. Interestingly enough, a single photon still behaves as if other phantom, undetectable photons are traveling through the slits with it, at the same time, to produce the wave-like interference patterns that led to the logically dissonant explanation known as wave/particle duality. One particle acts as if it travels through both slits at the same time in order to produce the interence pattern. A single photon traveling through the slits by itself will only strike the screen in areas that a beam of photons traveling together rom the same light source would strike. Allegedly, the photons in a beam of light interfere with one another in a way not unlike ripples on a lake interfere with one another to amplify and destroy one another – thus producing a pattern of dark and light interference waves on the screen).
This begs the question: if one solitary photon is traveling through the slits at any given time, what then is diverting it to land on the screen at the exact and only same spots as it would have followed if other photons had been traveling from the light source with it? The Copenhagen interepretation sez that the photon is interfering with itself – interfering with itself as it exists in a state of unobserved, superpositioned versions of itself that do not resolve into one, definite real position until the photon is observed.
Are these super-positioned states real or imaginary?
Is there something wrong with quantum physics?
Quantum physics explains the atom. The atom is an impossible paradox in Einsteinian physics. Classical physics (Einsteinian -corrected and -addended Newtonian mechanics) approximately describes the emergent behavior of quantum mechanical processes on the super-quantum, classical physics level. QP has no serious, rational rivals to challenge it as an explanation of reality at the atomic/sub-atomic scale.
It is our deepest theory of reality and yet it has stood with the above-stated question left ignored since the Copenhagen interpretation until it has relatively recently been seriously examined. So, are the super-positioned states of a photon in a single-particle interferometor real or imaginary?
If you answer it in the way in which MWI approaches it, new and age-old paradoxes are shown to be classical, commonsense misunderstandings of the true nature of reality.
E.g. time travel. The equations of classical physics indicate that time travel is at least possible in theory. But our classical view of time produces paradoxes such as the Grandfather Paradox. Applying the MWI to the Grandfather Paradox shows that killing your grandfather before he’s had time to sire your father produces no paradox. A history of your grandfather siring your father would still exist independently of you traveling back to a seperate history in which you murdered your grandfather. Time travel involves traveling into histories that have not produced your own – your travel into these histories produces new, seperate histories. In other words: your history of traveling back in time to kill your grandfather is unaltered by your travel into and intereference with the past. Your travel produces a new history in which you are free to alter your past in any way you desire – even if you desire to kill your grandfather.
We don’t know whether time travel is physically possible or not. Our ability to mathematically model it has traditionally produced these strange paradoxical offenses to logic. MWI provides an understanding of our mathematical models. It lends an understanding to many otherwise unexplained bridge-too-far gaps in knowledge.
Take the EPR Paradox as another example: A particle decays into two seperate particles, one with -1/2 spin and one +1/2 spin. Because of the conservation of angular momentum, these two particles must be in these two spin states. However, each particle possesses no definite spin state until at least one of them is observed. If Particle A is observed to be in a state of +1/2 spin, then Particle B must exist in a state of -1/2 spin. If these two particles are seperated from each other by the distance of a light-year, while still neither has been observed, and then suddenly Particle A is observed to be a state of +1/2 spin, how does Particle B “know” that Particle A has been oberved, causing Particle B to resolve itself into a definite state of -1/2 spin? It would seem that it would take a light-year for a signal to reach Particle B from Particle A in order to communicate the fact that Particle A has been observed and no longer exists in a state of superpositioned +1/2 & -1/2 spin states. However, in the MWI, this paradox is resovled when you consider that the observation of Particle A produces two seperate histories: one in which Particle A has +1/2 spin and Particle B has -1/2, and one in which Particle A has -1/2 spin and Particle B has +1/2 spin. Each history exists and is observed in reality. Each definite history is not embarked upon until observation has taken place.
Something interferes with the paths of single particles in the double-slit experiment. Either it’s real or it’s imaginary. It’s further interesting that taking the more realistic POV in this choice and opting away from an explanation involving imaginary particles that can interfere with real paarticles but somehow do not really exist, one realistic interpretation being the MWI, it only explains more of the questions which burden a world-view unadoptive of an explanation that asserts that imaginary things cannot effect reality.