Is there a way to retain a quote

GreedyCapitalist:

Is there a way to retain a quote within a quote when replying? I have noticed that when you hit the “quote” button in order to reply to someone only that person’s words are quoted and not what they had quoted (this sometimes contains pertinent context) when they replied.

Also, I sometimes compose my relpies offline. Can you tell me how to decipher the code that accompanies a quote? I think I can figure out most of it except the number between the two snapbacks, ex: (snapback)66143(/snapback)

Maybe it would just be easier for me to compose my own quotes using (quote)(/quote) without all the other jazz?

Also what does the multiquote toggle button do and how do you use it?

Thanks,

Marc

To do multiple or compound quotes I always work with a text editor. I just hit reply to anyone I want to quote then cut and paste in MS Word. So if you want to quote the quote of the quote you are responding to, you must reply to the original message - which isn’t usually hard to find tks to the snap back icons. Personally I encourage this way because it takes care of the snap back icons and the header for the quote – which are really convenient for people to catch up on the context. An additional perk of using a text editor is you catch many silly errors - like your spelling of ‘replies’. :confused:

It would be nice if there is an easier way, but if not, cutting and pasting isn’t all that hard.

One question to add though… the QUOTE box to the left of the REPLY box on the bottom right corner of the posts… what does it do? Clicking on it makes it go from + to - but I don’t know what it is affecting. Originally I thought it was for doing exactly what you inquiring -including the quotes in the message you are replying to– but alas this doesn’t seem to be it.

Thanks for the reply GoodOrigamiMan but I’m not sure I follow, so let’s see if I can compose an example:

Is there a way to retain a quote within a quote when replying?

Reply: GoodOrigamiMan

To do multiple or compound quotes I always work with a text editor.

Let us pretend that you quoted me as above and replied as stated. If I want to quote you and retain what you had quoted (my original plus all the identifing information), then I would hit the “reply” button and reply to myself (the original) and then what? Copy and paste your Reply: “To do multiple or compound quotes I always work with a text editor.”

Or: hit the “reply” button again, replying to you, and then cut and paste from the text box where we can edit our posts?

Can you give it one more try???

Thanks,

Marc

Thanks for the reply GoodOrigamiMan but I’m not sure I follow, so let’s see if I can compose an example:

Let us pretend that you quoted me as above and replied as stated. If I want to quote you and retain what you had quoted (my original plus all the identifing information), then I would hit the “reply” button and reply to myself (the original) and then what? Copy and paste your Reply: “To do multiple or compound quotes I always work with a text editor.”

Or: hit the “reply” button again, replying to you, and then cut and paste from the text box where we can edit our posts?

Pretty much… to create your example I replied to your original message, cut out what I didn’t want, then pasted the results in my text editor. To quote my response I replied to my post, cut out what I didn’t want, then pasted the results as well. To layer the quotes you simply paste one inside the other – that includes the header: [.quote], the end: [./quote], and everything in-between. (periods are to fool html)

As far as where to paste one quote in another that depends on the sequence / structure you are going for – for example I could have changed the order of the example you suggested and used my quote as the primary one and simply pasted yours before the text in mine:

To do multiple or compound quotes I always work with a text editor.

So the good news is: there is still some room for individual expression! :confused:

To show the structure of the second version of your example:

[.quote=GoodOrigamiMan,Dec 29 2004, 11:51 AM]

[.quote=Marc K.,Dec 29 2004, 11:11 AM]

Is there a way to retain a quote within a quote when replying?

[.right][.snapback]66555[./snapback][./right] [./quote]

To do multiple or compound quotes I always work with a text editor.

[.right][.snapback]66565[./snapback][./right][./quote]

If anything ever goes wrong it means that your opening and closing tags are not matching up. This happens if you accidentally deleted a tag or cliped off a bracket.. Sometimes I have found not having a space between them stops them from functioning.. Anyways, better safe than sorry - preview your post when messing with multiple quotes.

One question to add though… the QUOTE box to the left of the REPLY box on the bottom right corner of the posts… what does it do?

It is a convenient way to quote from multiple posts in a single reply. You press the QUOTE button on the replies you want to quote from, then click on ADD REPLY at the bottom of the screen. (You can also use this when you do the nested quoting that Marc asked about, although you’ll still have to nest the quotes by hand.)

What I find so peculiar about this whole multiple quoting thing, is that when replying to private messages it does automatically nest the quotes just like we would like to do for these forum postings. In other words, it appears as if the software for automatic multiple level of quotes is already here, but it is not being applied to postings. I suspect – and this is just a guess – that the multiple quote feature has not been turned on, or is not at all available for postings, to reduce or limit the amount of quoted text in replies. People would just tend to quote everything without bothering (or learning how to) snip the quoted material. Seems reasonable, but just a guess.

I suspect – and this is just a guess – that the multiple quote feature has not been turned on, or is not at all available for postings, to reduce or limit the amount of quoted text in replies. People would just tend to quote everything without bothering (or learning how to) snip the quoted material. Seems reasonable, but just a guess.

Your guess is correct.

Thank you all for the relpies (oh, I’m sorry, replies :stuck_out_tongue: ) they were all very helpful. In fact I’m using the multiquote toggle right now :frowning: . I should have caught-on quicker. It’s like a nested computer program (in fact that’s exactly what it is), simple.

My biggest problem now is that:

Also, I sometimes compose my relpies off-line. Can you tell me how to decipher the code that accompanies a quote? I think I can figure out most of it except the number between the two snapbacks, ex: (snapback)66143(/snapback)

When composing off-line I sometimes type out all the code via cut-and-paste like you did here Good:

[.quote=GoodOrigamiMan,Dec 29 2004, 11:51 AM]

[.quote=Marc K.,Dec 29 2004, 11:11 AM]

Is there a way to retain a quote within a quote when replying?

[.right][.snapback]66555[./snapback][./right] [./quote]

To do multiple or compound quotes I always work with a text editor.

[.right][.snapback]66565[./snapback][./right][./quote]

And now I think I figured-out the number. For instance if someone wants to quote this post, its corresponding number should be: 66693, since Stephen’s number is 66687 (each new post adds 6). Thus:

[.right][.snapback]66693[./snapback][./right][./quote] – sans:"."s,

(((… hold on, GreedyCapitalist just chimed in so make that 66699)))

should be the last line in the quote code.

In other words, it appears as if the software for automatic multiple level of quotes is already here, but it is not being applied to postings.

I know the last version of this forum’s software did support this, I made use of it.

People would just tend to quote everything without bothering (or learning how to) snip the quoted material.

Unfortunately, some people do tend to quote everything (it makes me grit my teeth. In a recent thread two people in the first five posts quoted the entire first post :slight_smile: ). Still though, it would be a nice feature to have.

Also, the words some type after a quote get cut-off, I would guess that they are not "preview"ing their "post"s.

Thanks again,

Marc

And now I think I figured-out the number. For instance if someone wants to quote this post, its corresponding number should be: 66693, since Stephen’s number is 66687 (each new post adds 6). Thus:

Logical fallacy of not comparing enough posts! :stuck_out_tongue:

Actually it seems as if the number counts up for each and every post on the forum regardless of what thread it was in. So there were 5 new posts on the forum in-between the two posts whose numbers you were comparing.

Instead of counting you can check the post number by clicking on the Post # link in the upper right corner… the number at the end of the link is the post number. Since every post on the forum seems to have a unique number, a quote with a snap back will work if you throw it in a different thread, like this one:

The settings were rich, creative, and flamboyant; excitingly dramatic designs.

Your guess is correct.

I’m trying to think of a polite way to needle you about this, alas the facts and economics are on your side.

I don’t know if it is rudeness or ignorance that causes this phenomenon. If it is ignorance, then you’d expect the persons guilty of full length quoting to correct their behavior through sheer embarrassment.

Rudeness is a more difficult problem, though I’d be willing to bet that the majority are also non-objective and won’t last long. Anyway, maybe I’ll start inveighing upon them to correct their behavior too.

Logical fallacy of not comparing enough posts!  :nuke:

doh!!! (wish I had a Homer Simpson smily right now)

Darn, that’s two logical errors and one spelling mistake in one thread!!! Better check the carbon monoxide level. :angry:

you can check the post number by clicking on the Post # link in the upper right corner

This is very helpfull, the things you learn.

I don’t know if it is rudeness or ignorance that causes this phenomenon. If it is ignorance, then you’d expect the persons guilty of full length quoting to correct their behavior through sheer embarrassment.

I previously allowed quote embedding, but found that the quoted text would grow out of control, sometimes creating a duplicate of a thread within each post. It’s just too easy to keep hitting the “reply” button. Since the very point of separating posts into threads is to delineate separate “conversations” I don’t see a need for extensive context given for each thread. If you need to quote a mini-conversation each time you post, perhaps you should split your response into a separate thread.