Maybe you don’t care about the bum in the street and you don’t care if they die out there. However, you will find that many of these “bums” are often the victims, not of their own laziness, but of the country’s bad political system. Maybe that is not so often in the USA, but here in Croatia, some of these bums are better educated than the “owners” of some of the largest companies. I put the term “owners” between quotes because it is known that it is the politicians who have a final say in these companies and who profit most from them.
Incidentally, the idea that altruism is the central or only proper concern of morality is a tragic instance of what Ayn Rand calls the fallacy of the frozen abstraction. Principally, you should be concerned with how to live your life rationally, so that you may enjoy the fruits of your efforts.
(emphasis mine)
This is not quite accurate. The fallacy of the frozen abstraction is treating a concrete subsumed under an abstraction as synonymous with the abstraction. In the case of morality, this usually manifests itself as someone hearing “morality” and thinking “altruism”–not because they think altruism is the only way to be moral, but that they think it is the only morality.
Another example occurs when people think “reason” means “science,” and you get (for instance), materialists’ claim that the only way to arrive at knowledge is to measure things in a laboratory. While science is one instance of the use of reason, it is not the only one. (A similar error occurs when people substitute “mathematics” for “rigorous argument.”) The Religious Right is fond of freezing “values” to just “Christian values” and saying things like, “Society would have no values without religion.” Finally, although I know of no one who substitutes “orange” for “fruit” or “green” for “color,” these too would be frozen abstractions.
This fallacy usually results from a lack of experience, so that the concept-formation process is short-circuited and the person ends up with a concept that stands for just one item in their mind, rather than “an unlimited number of concretes of a certain kind” (ITOE, p10).
This is not quite accurate. The fallacy of the frozen abstraction is treating a concrete subsumed under an abstraction as synonymous with the abstraction. In the case of morality, this usually manifests itself as someone hearing “morality” and thinking “altruism”–not because they think altruism is the only way to be moral, but that they think it is the only morality.
I do appreciate the lesson, but I understand the fallacy of the frozen abstraction.
My statement reflects the fact that many people do not subscribe to the fallacy strictly, but are instead influenced by it in a somewhat watered down form. Thus, while they sometimes acknowledge that doing things for self has some merit and may be required to some degree, the real essence of being moral for them means doing things for others. Since, we were addressing a very new person to Ayn Rand’s philosophy, I thought it best to focus on a broader and more understandable (while less technically precise) point.
Perhaps I should have used consequence rather than instance.