(Mod’s note: Merged with a related thread - sN)
I’m still not convinced that everyone is not selfish–even after reading VOS “Isn’t Everyone Selfish?” a couple of times. And, if I remember correctly, Rand had an article about it as well in her book “Philosophy, Who Needs It?” And I didn’t find that very convincing either…so hopefully someone can shed some light on this topic for me.
After reading the article “Isn’t Everyone Selfish?”, I wrote some notes down. This is what I wrote:
Candidates for this view claim that everyone is selfish–regardless of the circumstances. For instance: Pretend a man is going to smoke a cigarette for the first time. He knows the cigarette is harmful to his health yet he wants to satisfy his curiosity. He wonders what’s it like to inhale a puff of smoke and what will happen to him physiologically. The proponents of this view will say that even though the cigarette is dangerously harmful to his health, it is still in the man’s interest to satisfy his curiosity–thus making him selfish.
This is their big mistake (here’s my conclusion–but I’m unsure of it). The man’s curiosity is totally unwarranted. No one should be curious about the effects of anything when they know exclusively that experimenting with such a substance is harmful to their health. Thus, it is not in this man’s interest to fulfill an arbitrary “curiosity” and so he is not acting selfishly.
But then I have a possible objection to my own conclusion:
“Selfishness” simply means concerned with one’s own interest. But by no means does the word “concern” have any correlation with the concept of being “rationally concerned” or “objectively concerned.” So, one can said to be concerned with one’s own interest and simply be misguided as to what they ought to regard as their own interests.
And then my objection to that is this:
The above paragraph is mindlessly messing with semantics regarding the word “concern,” b/c when one uses the word “concern” he is already supposing that the concern is warranted–not arbitrarily created.
Anyhow, as anyone can see, I’m indefinitely confused, so I’d appreciate some help around this area.
PS…I can’t really identify where my confusion is, but the same type of confusion ( I think) exists with other topics. Here are some more examples:
“Everyone, if the act is voluntary, does what they want to do.” For instance, someone may not “want” to go to the dentist, but they end up going anyway b/c they don’t want their cavities to progress into something worse.
Or…there was once a man who joked about everything and was only serious about one thing…joking.
There are more, but I can’t think of them now.
Possibly it would be fair to say that we all try to act in our own self interest?